Becoming a General Manager

Harry

ASFN Consultant and Senior Writer
Joined
Jan 7, 2003
Posts
12,506
Reaction score
27,391
Location
Orlando, FL
Another key Cardinal decision maker is the General Manager. This spot is occupied by yet another person in training. I will urge the same caution here. I don’t care how prepared an individual is. People new to a position will make mistakes. Yes, I consider 2 years new to a position. Quick decisions to discharge often weakens an organization. The only time I deviate from that stance is when I feel the person has been unreasonably deceptive. Like saying you’re okay with a 3 or 4 man defensive line, then making personnel decisions that clearly indicate that wasn’t the case.

Aside from hiring coaches there are two obvious duties of the position that determine the fate of the team; the draft & free agency. Turning first to the draft Ossenfort has overseen 2 drafts. His drafts as a whole have been exceptionally good. All 2023 draftees are still on the roster. That’s hard to believe. Ojalari has been injured but shows promise. Of the other 8, 4 have started regularly or rotated steadily. The others have occasionally started or played significant snaps. Looking at 2024, 6 of the first 7 have either started of been primary backups. The 7th was injured. The final 2 draftees are both on the practice squad.

Free agency is extremely hard to evaluate. Guys signed who started include White, Froholdt, Collier, Woods, Barnes, Daley and Wilkenson. I may have missed a few. It’s fair to say they blew a couple of quality re-signings by letting Zach Allen & Byron Murphy walk. In 2024 Ossenfort signed Williams, Dallas, Brown, Bunting, Jones, Nichols and Wilson. Nichols, Williams and Jones went down to injury almost immediately. Wilson was terrific. Dallas has been valuable. Brown and Bunting have been inconsistent. Williams has played well when healthy.

During the course of the season Ossenfort added Browning who has flashed sack ability. When long range kicker, Prater, was lost Ryland was signed and starred with 3 game winning kicks and a couple of other plus efforts were booted.

Again there was criticism of Ossenfort that he should have signed more free agents. Keep in mind the free agents signed were plagued by injuries, several season ending. The team as a whole likewise suffered the same fate. At one point in addition to what I mentioned they were missing both tackles, the right guard, the top 3 running backs, a key linebacker and their punter. They had numerous players who missed games here and there. The team might have had better results and fewer needs if not for those injuries. Nobody bats a thousand on free agents. Again I think Ossenfort wanted to avoid overspending and saw fewer sure things than others. It’s easy to pick free agents in hindsight. Few GMs are good at both of these aspects. Ossenfort’s showed that potential. If he can continue to hit on 70% of his draft picks and hit 50% on free agents, he’s a winner. Realize as the team gets better, that’s harder to do.

Apparently he’s kept out of the team’s day-to-day play. He’s let the coaches; coach. He’s kept a solid, business-like presence. Ossenfort has the potential to be a great choice.
 

kerouac9

Klowned by Keim
Joined
Feb 14, 2003
Posts
38,711
Reaction score
30,566
Location
Gilbert, AZ
All 2023 draftees are still on the roster. That’s hard to believe.
Why? Last year we were bad on purpose; who were they competing with?

Jon Gaines has played 11 offensive snaps and 48 special teams snaps.
The team as a whole likewise suffered the same fate.

This team has been exceptionally healthy up to these last couple weeks.
 

kerouac9

Klowned by Keim
Joined
Feb 14, 2003
Posts
38,711
Reaction score
30,566
Location
Gilbert, AZ
One positive that I really like with Monti has been how proactive he's been w/r/t contract extensions.

What got Keim into trouble was re-signing solid-to-good players to top 5 extensions. The Jermaine Gresham contract was insane. Monti has re-signed a solid group of foundational contributors to market or (maybe) below-market deals. That's a definite improvement.
 

Cbus cardsfan

Back to Back ASFN FFL Champion
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
21,533
Reaction score
7,825
Big off season for Monti. I agree his drafts have been very good. Wasn’t a fan of passing on Will Anderson but Paris has been pretty good in his own right.
I’d like to know his thoughts on Kyler. I know he was stuck with him at first but is he thinking he’s the guy going forward. That will probably determine his future.
 

az jam

ASFN Icon
Joined
Mar 6, 2004
Posts
13,007
Reaction score
5,267
Location
Scottsdale, AZ
Nice write up Harry. I agree with Cbus that this off season will be big for Monti. We have about 90 million in cap space and should be a player in free agency. We sill have lots of holes to fill. IMO year 3 needs to be a playoff team for Monti, and JC.
 

ASUCHRIS

ONE HEART BEAT!!!
Joined
Sep 2, 2002
Posts
16,672
Reaction score
15,023
Another key Cardinal decision maker is the General Manager. This spot is occupied by yet another person in training. I will urge the same caution here. I don’t care how prepared an individual is. People new to a position will make mistakes. Yes, I consider 2 years new to a position. Quick decisions to discharge often weakens an organization. The only time I deviate from that stance is when I feel the person has been unreasonably deceptive. Like saying you’re okay with a 3 or 4 man defensive line, then making personnel decisions that clearly indicate that wasn’t the case.

Aside from hiring coaches there are two obvious duties of the position that determine the fate of the team; the draft & free agency. Turning first to the draft Ossenfort has overseen 2 drafts. His drafts as a whole have been exceptionally good. All 2023 draftees are still on the roster. That’s hard to believe. Ojalari has been injured but shows promise. Of the other 8, 4 have started regularly or rotated steadily. The others have occasionally started or played significant snaps. Looking at 2024, 6 of the first 7 have either started of been primary backups. The 7th was injured. The final 2 draftees are both on the practice squad.

Free agency is extremely hard to evaluate. Guys signed who started include White, Froholdt, Collier, Woods, Barnes, Daley and Wilkenson. I may have missed a few. It’s fair to say they blew a couple of quality re-signings by letting Zach Allen & Byron Murphy walk. In 2024 Ossenfort signed Williams, Dallas, Brown, Bunting, Jones, Nichols and Wilson. Nichols, Williams and Jones went down to injury almost immediately. Wilson was terrific. Dallas has been valuable. Brown and Bunting have been inconsistent. Williams has played well when healthy.

During the course of the season Ossenfort added Browning who has flashed sack ability. When long range kicker, Prater, was lost Ryland was signed and starred with 3 game winning kicks and a couple of other plus efforts were booted.

Again there was criticism of Ossenfort that he should have signed more free agents. Keep in mind the free agents signed were plagued by injuries, several season ending. The team as a whole likewise suffered the same fate. At one point in addition to what I mentioned they were missing both tackles, the right guard, the top 3 running backs, a key linebacker and their punter. They had numerous players who missed games here and there. The team might have had better results and fewer needs if not for those injuries. Nobody bats a thousand on free agents. Again I think Ossenfort wanted to avoid overspending and saw fewer sure things than others. It’s easy to pick free agents in hindsight. Few GMs are good at both of these aspects. Ossenfort’s showed that potential. If he can continue to hit on 70% of his draft picks and hit 50% on free agents, he’s a winner. Realize as the team gets better, that’s harder to do.

Apparently he’s kept out of the team’s day-to-day play. He’s let the coaches; coach. He’s kept a solid, business-like presence. Ossenfort has the potential to be a great choice.
I love your stuff Harry, but I think it's far too early to call his two drafts exceptionally good. He's a had a ton of draft resources and turned them into a bunch of ok players. Lots of question marks about most of the picks.

Regarding FA, Nichols and Jones were awful even before they were injured, and SMB is a constant target.

We still haven't solved our two biggest problems (WR and pass rusher) and our QB situation is a huge question mark moving forward.

We'll see how it all pans out, but I don't think he's been anything more than average at best as a GM.
 

PDXChris

All In!
Supporting Member
Banned from P+R
Joined
Mar 28, 2003
Posts
31,681
Reaction score
28,607
Location
Nowhere
Nice write up Harry. I agree with Cbus that this off season will be big for Monti. We have about 90 million in cap space and should be a player in free agency. We sill have lots of holes to fill. IMO year 3 needs to be a playoff team for Monti, and JC.
We have about $12 million to carry over after the recent extensions and we are projected to have $95 million in space before that, so we could have $90 after extending McBride! Maybe $85.after White/McBride if done right!
 
Top