A Tale of the Tape

Harry

ASFN Consultant and Senior Writer
Joined
Jan 7, 2003
Posts
12,389
Reaction score
27,096
Location
Orlando, FL
My first impression of this season is that much of it will hinge on the training staff’s ability to tape up the players and keep them going. The Cap has made depth in the NFL a luxury, so a few injuries in the wrong places can doom most any team. The Cards would seem to have less margin for error at key positions than a typical playoff bound team.

Before turning to the Cards it’s worth considering the NFC West competition. There isn’t much. The only legitimate threat comes from the somewhat recently successful Seahawks. Injuries killed them off last year, but mostly they just got too old. Their offensive line hasn’t been effective since Hutchison left and they may soon have to wheel Jones out to his spot. He can’t be happy about the switch to a new blocking scheme (modified zone), so if they get to 8-8, they’ve done a good job. If Hasselbeck goes down, this could well be another totally lost year. Mora is better than he gets credit for being, but he’s no miracle worker.

The Niners told us what they thought about the upcoming season when they traded away a draft pick for a next year’s number one. They see themselves as at least a year away and who am I to argue. St, Louis will continue its history of NFL season ticket holders being abused by the resident team. Can a threatened move back to LA be far away? Perhaps they could play half their games in each city and rip-off both of them at once.

By now it’s clear that I think a winning season will put the Cards in the playoffs. Keep in mind the Cards made last year’s playoffs by default. There is no discounting their impressive run in those playoffs, but can they sustain that level of play for a season? Historically teams coming out of the Super Bowl struggle. They typically lose key players to free agency and have mediocre drafts due to a low draft position. The Cards lost a couple of good players but they didn’t lose key players to free agency. The draft, while helpful, leaves several positions very vulnerable.

On offense I tend to discount Warner’s pre-season struggles. The hip may be bothering him, but if the line can protect him; he will be good enough to get the job done. He has the best wide receiver group in the league and the Cards would put points on the board if Jerry Jones called the plays. They’ll make some painful turnovers, but hopefully they will be in non-win situations. Where you’ll see the biggest improvement is at running back. I think Wells will stay relatively healthy and he will be a huge upgrade over Hightower and the departed Mr. James. Hightower will still get most of the goal line carries. Wells is the best (prime years of a career) back the Cards have had since Otis Anderson. He will take the pressure off Warner and force teams to play straight-up defense. Keep an eye on Dominique Byrd. I liked him coming out of college and until Patrick comes back he may be the best receiving tight end the Cards have. I expect they will also use him at fullback in a similar safety valve role.

The line looks better inside and massive Mount Johnson could well prove a 5th round steal. He’s amazingly mobile for his size. My concern remains at tackle. Gandy’s losing speed and Keith did not step up to challenge him. Brown still looks vulnerable to speed rushers. Overall the line still struggles too much with blitzes, especially when you consider how long they’ve played as a unit.

The defense presents issues at several positions. It’s disappointing that Watson couldn’t take the nose tackle spot away from Bryan Robinson. It’s not that Robinson is poor, but that no one offers an impact player at that slot. At end I think Campbell will be an upgrade offering more versatility and move geographic coverage. He may develop into a player who takes some of the heat off Dockett.

The inside linebackers might be the best duo in the league, but the outside linebackers are getting long in the tooth and guile is rarely effective for 16 games. Before his season-ending injury Cody Brown was expected to help and the absence of youth is a major concern at this spot. Collectively this group must get to the passer and I have my doubts. It did look like they finally recalled the Dansby is an outstanding rusher, so that may help with the options.

You could see in the pre-season how the lack of a decent rush impacted the corners. Of course the Cards didn’t show everything, but it would be a disaster if this team goes back to the old mode of ruining corners by constantly asking them to cover with no rush. DRC is just learning the game and has an impressive upside. Setting him up for failure should not be an option. Beyond that there is little depth at corner. If they lose a starter, I see no viable option at corner for a prolonged absence.

Safety play should be improved. Rolle showed steady improvement last season and Johnson offers potential.

Special teams look solid, but thing would have been better had the Cards acquired a versatile return specialist.

The Cards played their typical close-to-the-vest pre-season showing little of their offense or blitz packages, so there is no reason for the doom and gloom I've been seeing.

Still looking back at vulnerabilities, an injury to Wells, a starting CB or a starting tackle could make this a very disappointing season.

I see some publication putting the Cards at 11-5. Sorry, but I don’t see things as that rosy. I think they hover around a .500 record for most of the season. They should finish by winning 3 or 4 of their last 4 games. That would leave them at 9-7 or 10-6. Either record should win the West.

It will be interesting to see if Graves can resolve any of the long term contract issues as the season progresses. If not, the next off-season will be the most critical in the history of the franchise in Arizona.
 

football karma

Michael snuggles the cap space
Joined
Jul 22, 2002
Posts
15,291
Reaction score
14,397
one thing I was really surprised about in the preseason: Brandon Keith not getting time at left tackle

they played Oliver Ross there in the preseason -- who was cut.

People have been raving about Keith, and there was some talk of him being the first olineman off the bench, so they wanted to give him reps at guard. But I would think you would have wanted to see him at left tackle -- particulalry with Gandy a free agent after this season.
 
Joined
Nov 15, 2002
Posts
13,304
Reaction score
1,181
Location
SE Valley
Always appreciate your words, Harry!
My first impression of this season is that much of it will hinge on the training staff’s ability to tape up the players and keep them going. The Cap has made depth in the NFL a luxury, so a few injuries in the wrong places can doom most any team. The Cards would seem to have less margin for error at key positions than a typical playoff bound team.
Most critical, league-wide determinant of success.
The line looks better inside and massive Mount Johnson could well prove a 5th round steal. He’s amazingly mobile for his size. My concern remains at tackle. Gandy’s losing speed and Keith did not step up to challenge him. Brown still looks vulnerable to speed rushers. Overall the line still struggles too much with blitzes, especially when you consider how long they’ve played as a unit.
Having good feet, couldn't/shouldn't Johnson be considered at OT, eventually?

The defense presents issues at several positions. It’s disappointing that Watson couldn’t take the nose tackle spot away from Bryan Robinson. It’s not that Robinson is poor, but that no one offers an impact player at that slot. At end I think Campbell will be an upgrade offering more versatility and move geographic coverage. He may develop into a player who takes some of the heat off Dockett.
As I stated in another thread, I think that Watson is still regaining his pre-injury form. At this point, it may be a more of a mental rather than a physical rehabilitative process, i.e. - having confidence in his knee holding up. If he can get over the hurdle, I still believe that he can become a dominant force at NT. This development alone could make a drastic improvement in the Cardinals defense.

The inside linebackers might be the best duo in the league, but the outside linebackers are getting long in the tooth and guile is rarely effective for 16 games. Before his season-ending injury Cody Brown was expected to help and the absence of youth is a major concern at this spot. Collectively this group must get to the passer and I have my doubts. It did look like they finally recalled the Dansby is an outstanding rusher, so that may help with the options.
That's high praise... We can only hope that they play up to it.

You could see in the pre-season how the lack of a decent rush impacted the corners. Of course the Cards didn’t show everything, but it would be a disaster if this team goes back to the old mode of ruining corners by constantly asking them to cover with no rush. DRC is just learning the game and has an impressive upside. Setting him up for failure should not be an option. Beyond that there is little depth at corner. If they lose a starter, I see no viable option at corner for a prolonged absence.

Safety play should be improved. Rolle showed steady improvement last season and Johnson offers potential.
Michael Adams had a good pre-season... Too bad he isn't about 6'2"! :)

Special teams look solid, but thing would have been better had the Cards acquired a versatile return specialist.
Does this mean you don't think LSH is the answer there? Come to think of it, did "Hyphen" return punts in pre-season?

It will be interesting to see if Graves can resolve any of the long term contract issues as the season progresses. If not, the next off-season will be the most critical in the history of the franchise in Arizona.
Simply the volume of work to be done (Boldin, Dansby, the overall number of FA, and RFA' s for 2010) cause me concern. I question if "One-at-a-time" Graves is up to the task...
 

Cardiac

ASFN Icon
Joined
Jul 21, 2002
Posts
12,071
Reaction score
3,343
Thanks Harry. Many of us look forward to your insight tell it like it is approach.
 

Redheart

Stack 'em up!
Joined
Aug 9, 2002
Posts
4,391
Reaction score
3
Location
Mesa
Thanks Harry;
I know the season is truly here when your posts start showing up!

I would take 10-6 and the Division crown again. The SB seems so long ago now, and so far away...

If Beani blows up into a monster, I think we can go back. With a running game, we can win anywhere.
 

lauraw

"Vincere, Aut Mori" !
Joined
Jan 30, 2009
Posts
2,889
Reaction score
0
Location
Big BQ!
Agree FootballKarma! Harry, Great Post!!! On the Seattle Board I saw their posters are thinking they're going to go
12-4, 13-3..
 
Last edited:

lauraw

"Vincere, Aut Mori" !
Joined
Jan 30, 2009
Posts
2,889
Reaction score
0
Location
Big BQ!
What did we do with Garvin, did we put him on the PS?
 
Joined
Nov 15, 2002
Posts
13,304
Reaction score
1,181
Location
SE Valley
Agree FootballKarma! Harry, Great Post!!! On the Seattle Board I saw their posters are thinking they're going to go
12-4, 13-3..
The Seahawk should be at least more competitive than last season, when they were decimated by injuries. But 12-4, 13-3... ??? :p

Put down the pipe Seattle fans.
 

Garthshort

ASFN Addict
Joined
Aug 11, 2002
Posts
9,507
Reaction score
5,785
Location
Scarsdale, NY
Thanks Harry. I can't disagree with much, except maybe that LSH showed return ability to me. Of the nine OL, I'm pretty sure that HJ will be inactive most Sundays, and if the team goes with only two OL reserves (Claxton being one) on gamedays, will the other be Elton or Brandon? Last year Brandon was IA every week, and if they have confidence that he can backup at OG and OT, it shows significant improvement. What does everyone think?
 

Catfish

Registered
Joined
Aug 14, 2006
Posts
4,551
Reaction score
64
I have to believe that they are comfortable with Brandon Keith at the OT back-up slot. Seems like they gave Ross a good shot at the position, but he played himself out of a job despite the good feelings that Grimm and Whiz have for him.

I think that LSH displayed significant return ability, especially on KO's. I would not be surprised to see him there sooner rather than later----especially if Breaston begins to show a tendancy toward injury. I believe that they would be less apt to expose him to continued pounding on the return teams.

Watson looked solid again in the Denver game in my opinion. Maybe he has learned to trust the knee, or has finally broken down the scar tissue. He looked immovable again to me, and might be a real staple in the middle after a game or two.

I enjoyed your write-up Harry. One can see that you have given a lot of thought to this, and we thank you for that. Good to see you posting again----its football time.
 

Stout

Hold onto the ball, Murray!
Joined
Dec 30, 2002
Posts
40,099
Reaction score
24,562
Location
Pittsburgh, PA--Enemy territory!
one thing I was really surprised about in the preseason: Brandon Keith not getting time at left tackle

they played Oliver Ross there in the preseason -- who was cut.

People have been raving about Keith, and there was some talk of him being the first olineman off the bench, so they wanted to give him reps at guard. But I would think you would have wanted to see him at left tackle -- particulalry with Gandy a free agent after this season.

Perhaps, and this is a big leap of logic on my part, the team is so sold on Keith at OT that they didn't even need to worry about evaluating him there in the preseason and instead wanted to focus entirely on developing his versatility in playing at guard. Again, this is complete supposition on my part, so don't take it as the gospel. Just the gospel according to Stout ;)
 

Duckjake

LEGACY MEMBER
LEGACY MEMBER
Joined
Jun 10, 2002
Posts
32,190
Reaction score
317
Location
Texas
Having good feet, couldn't/shouldn't Johnson be considered at OT, eventually?

Big Baby played a lot of snaps at Right Tackle in preseason.

And looked very good for a rookie who played Guard in college.
 

RonF

Per Ardua Ad Astra
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
2,090
Reaction score
4
Location
Sun City, AZ
Harry, you give me hope that our poor play during the pre-season does not a season make.
 

Chopper0080

2021 - Prove It
Joined
May 15, 2002
Posts
28,840
Reaction score
41,957
Location
Colorado
Herman Johnson is our future at RT as the Cards will move Levi Brown to LT instead of resigning Gandy. From there I would not be surprised if they look for a more natural LT to develop behind Brown so they can let Brown go if he does not perform at LT.
 

PrescottLooie

Registered
Joined
Jul 13, 2004
Posts
228
Reaction score
0
Harry, I thought the rookie (Greg Toler) looked pretty good at CB for us. I thought he made good progress during the preseason. He may be raw, but if we don't have to have him start for maybe 5, 6 or 7 games he could step in, don't you think ?
 

Russ Smith

The Original Whizzinator
Supporting Member
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
88,145
Reaction score
39,740
Herman Johnson is our future at RT as the Cards will move Levi Brown to LT instead of resigning Gandy. From there I would not be surprised if they look for a more natural LT to develop behind Brown so they can let Brown go if he does not perform at LT.

I have to admit I shudder at the thought of Brown at LT. If he has trouble with speed rushers at RT what's he going to do at LT? Maybe he's got better footwork moving that way who knows?
 

football karma

Michael snuggles the cap space
Joined
Jul 22, 2002
Posts
15,291
Reaction score
14,397
I have to admit I shudder at the thought of Brown at LT. If he has trouble with speed rushers at RT what's he going to do at LT? Maybe he's got better footwork moving that way who knows?

Its why I thought that Keith would get a look there -- all I heard last year was how the guy had 1st round feet for a tackle
 

SuperSpck

ASFN Addict
Joined
Mar 24, 2004
Posts
7,977
Reaction score
15
Location
Iowa
Its why I thought that Keith would get a look there -- all I heard last year was how the guy had 1st round feet for a tackle

He does, he looked a little lost at guard this year (he was a tackle at UNI) and really looked natural at T in his first season, but I still think height is a big reason they're pressing Johnson outside and hoping Keith works out in.
 

Duckjake

LEGACY MEMBER
LEGACY MEMBER
Joined
Jun 10, 2002
Posts
32,190
Reaction score
317
Location
Texas
I have to admit I shudder at the thought of Brown at LT. If he has trouble with speed rushers at RT what's he going to do at LT? Maybe he's got better footwork moving that way who knows?

If Brown has to move to LT Leinart will be our starter within 2 weeks and then Big Baby at RT becomes the protection for the QB's blindside.

:D
 

Chopper0080

2021 - Prove It
Joined
May 15, 2002
Posts
28,840
Reaction score
41,957
Location
Colorado
Russ- I would guess that the coaches hope the the pressure of the left side leads to an increase in Levi's production. Now, if it were me, I would move him over next year. Sign a veteran behind him and have the both compete with B Kieth. Winner takes all and we still have some depth. I don't believe that L Brown will be our answer at LT, but we have to find out sometime soon at his price.

Sidenote: Does Herman Johnson remind anyone else of "Zeus", Orlando Brown? Every time I watched Herman on the right side I had visions of him devastating defensive ends and tackles alike.
 

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
556,122
Posts
5,433,534
Members
6,329
Latest member
cardinals2025
Top