I'm not optimistic. While I think he could be a quality role player off the bench for the Suns for a few seasons, and maybe a little more than quality at his best, this piece copied from RealGM at least keeps Suns fans hopeful for just a bit more...
I know it's way too early to start making these type of claims. However, here's some similarities for fun:
-Tucker is 6-6, 210. Howard was 6-6, 207
-Both were taken at pick 29 in round 1.
-Both played all 4 years for a major conference and won conference player of the year their final season.
-Both were consensus first-team All-Americans their senior season
-Tucker averaged 19.9 PPG, 2.0 APG and shot 47% from the field, Howard was at 19.5 PPG, 2.1 APG and 47.7% from the field.
Here's a comparison of both players' college scouting report. These are exact comments, just re-ordered to make a comparison easier:
Howard in 2003
Strengths:
1. A rangy wing with good height. Plays big for his size.
2. Has quick hands, and is a solid all around defender, and also a very good man-defender who could become a great defender if he works at it.
3. Has a variety of moves including a baby hook shot, good fakes, and under-the-basket scoop shots.
4. Howard is a great finisher, especially in traffic.
5. He really attacks the glass and his long arms make him a formidable rebounder.
6. Looks quite coachable.
7. Team player with great competiveness and leadership qualities.
8. Vision and passing ability are another asset.
9. Has great intangibles.
Weaknesses:
1. His scoring ability is good but his outside shooting can improve.
2. He will need to develop better range to be a consistent scorer at the next level.
3. Has good handle, but can get careless and must get better at protecting the ball.
4. Howard's athleticism is not overwhelming and his first step isn't as quick as many NBA wing players
5. He has the experience that many players don't, but may have a limited upside.
Tucker
Strengths:
1. Possesses an NBA ready body that is strong enough to absorb contact in the lane and finish
2. Physically he has all the tools needed to be a quality defender: quickness, good hands, long arms and intelligence
3. Crafty scorer who uses a number of fakes and his leaping ability to create scoring opportunities for himself
4. Excellent finisher who is blessed with cat like body control to get off even the most difficult shots in traffic
5. Solid rebounder due to his athleticism, long arms and body strength
6. Coachable player with a great work ethic to improve
7. Tough minded player who enjoys physical play and will not back down from a challenge
8. Unselfish player with the willingness to set-up open teammates
9. 9/10 on intangibles
Weaknesses:
1. While blessed with athleticism, he may struggle to shoot consistently enough to play shooting guard
2. Solid three point shooter when his feet are set but struggles to hit with regularity
3. Ball handling, while improved, still isn’t great
4. Despite being a great athlete, Tucker rarely explodes off the dribble due to his average first step
5. While his game has progressed considerably over the past 5 years, one has to wonder how much more he can improve