Analysis of This Week's Moves

Walter Mitchell

All Star
BANNED BY MODERATORS
Joined
Jan 23, 2003
Posts
501
Reaction score
0
Location
Wrentham, MA
What a week it's been! I am trying to keep my emotions somewhat in check, but deep down inside I am absolutlely ecstatic with what has already transpired...and equally fascinated with the prospects of what may transpire in the days ahead.

(1) QB: I love the way Jeff Blake came into town and took the bull by the horns. One has to love this man's moxie and his fortitude in staring down the so-called Arizona stigma. I think Mac is going to absolutely love what Blake will bring to the offense. He has guts and a take charge mentality. He's been staring down his own stigmas every year he's played in the NFL, so he's no stranger to rising from the ashes, so to speak. In this regard and by virtue of Blake's ability to provide a formidible vertical passing game, the likes of which we have not seen in Arizona since the days of Neil Lomax, Blake is a fantastic choice. What's the point of having a cadre of speed receivers if the QB can't get them the ball? This guy can.

(2) RB: Marcel Shipp is a dynamic, hard-nosed and productive RB. And now he has a 270 lb. lead destroyer in James Hodgins to blast him through the holes. Just as it's been years since we have been able to watch a vertical passing game in Arizona, it's been years since we have been able to watch a Cardinal FB strike fear in the hearts of would-be tacklers. Hodgins is a major acquisition...a Bill Parcell's type warrior...in fact, it's a boon for the Cardinals to have been able to sign this player because there was significant interest in him from other teams.

As for the possibility of adding Emmitt Smith, if the price is right and I have a feeling that if Mr. Bidwill and Rod Graves are willing to offer an incentive laden deal to Emmitt, this move could be brilliant. First of all, Marcel Shipp will not get lost in the shuffle, not in the least. Every team needs two good running backs throughout the course of each game and the sixteen game schedule. Secondly, having Emmitt Smith in the fold would inspire our potential juggernaut of an offensive line to become all the more dominating. Emmitt's the kind of back that no offensive linemen wants to let down. And, quite frankly, the offensive line could very well take on the mentality of Emmitt's old great lines in Dallas. Such a mentality is what this line is trying to summon...and Smith could be a catalyst. Thirdly, the integrity that Smith would bring to the organization would provide another significant impetus toward obliterating the Cardinals' organizational stigma.

(3) OL: The re-signing of Raleigh Roundtree and the addition of Frank Garcia were outstanding moves. Roundtree's versatility is something every NFL team covets in a backup offensive lineman. I still believe at Roundtree's age he's just starting to enter his prime and could very well emerge as a solid starter in time. Plus, with the continuing health concerns regarding Anthony Clement, having Roundtree in the mix is wise. As for Garcia, he is a solid, experienced center who can add stability in the middle. He and Jason Starkey will battle it out for the starting position at center, and I wouldn't give Starkey short shrift. I like the steady improvement he has made from year to year.

Cameron Spikes comes to town this week and I am drooling over the prospects of the Cardinals adding him to the roster. First of all, Spikes is a pile mover...he's big and tremendously strong. He needs to improve his pass protection techniques, but his ability to open holes in the running game is impressive. Were the Cardinals able to add Spikes, they are providing for further depth this year and more immediate options if Shelton were to be traded this year or lost in free agency next year. Spikes may be better suited to play guard, but he is versatile, much like Roundtree.

Left tackle is Leonard Davis' natural position. While he is a monster at RG, he has the ability to be one of the top three LTs in the game. For those of you like Northern Card who are quick to think that Davis would be frequently beaten by the quick rush ends on the right side...based on the few times (and I repeat, few...like once early to Michael Strahan and then shutting him down the rest of the game) Davis was beaten from the right side this year, Davis has played LT all his life until he came to the Cardinals...and playing LT is quite different for someone who is used to protecting from the left side than the right. It's an opposite slide and weight transfer.

If the Cardinals sign Spikes, and they can get a good WR or DE in a trade for Shelton, they could be set for year to come with Davis at LT, Kendall at LG, Starkey or Garcia at C, Spikes or Dishman at RG and Clement at RT.

(4) WR: This becomes the most critical area to address in the days ahead. Teams will now be loading the box to stop the run, which means the Cardinals can exploit opposing defenses with the vertical passing game. Jason McAddley and Bryan Gilmore are young burners who will have the opportunity to have breakout years, but obviously neither at this point can be considered #1 receivers. Kevin Kasper is a good possession-type and slot receiver. Now the team needs to add an experienced #1 WR. The team made a last minute run at Ricky Proehl, but Proehl is more likely a #3 WR..and I believe that Kasper can thrive in such a role. Martay still has good potential as a #2 and hopefully will be re-signed, even though he is on a free agent tour of North America right now. Somehow, some way, the Cardinals have to secure a #1 WR, especially since they have to take the sting out of losing David Boston.

(5) DL: Did anyone find yesterday's re-signing of Russell Davis a bit curious, especially in light of the notion that supposedly the Cardinals are leaning toward drafting a DT with the #6 pick? The Davis signing means that the Cardinals now have 5 DTs under contract: Bryant, Tanner, Bell, Davis and Dwyer. If the Cardinals intend to draft a DT early, Davis' signing seems moot and a waste of cap space. Most likely this would mean that the Cardinals are eying another position with the #6 pick.

Something doesn't feel right about Vonnie Holliday and hasn't from the get-go. Could be another Eric Swann. Forget about him. He's not a bona fide pass rusher anyway. Get back in the Okeafor hunt, make a move for Willie Whitehead and draft a pass rusher early in the draft.

(6) LB: James Darling is a nice addition. Solid player, speedy and aggressive and may win a starting job.

The question is: do the Cardinals trade for Junior Seau? One would think Seau would love to play in Arizona to be close to home. His cap hit this year would be a mere $3M and would rise to $5.5M in 2004 and 2005. Since the Chargers have to pay Seau's signing bonus, whoever picks up Seau's salary could release him after a year or two and not have to take a cap hit. What an injection of energy Seau could bring to this defense! Wow! He could play the role that Colvin would have assumed as an aggressive, attack the edge LB...only Colvin can't hold Seau's jock as a LBer. Seau's outstanding veteran leadership could galvanize the young talent on the defense. He had an injury plagued season last year and some think he's getting long in the tooth. If he stays healthy this year, the $3M investment would be one of the best deals for any team in the off-season...an investment, in my opinion, that the Cardinals would be crazy not to make....especially seeing as Seau would welcome a move to Arizona probably more than any other locale due to his desire to play close to home.

(7) DB: The addition of Dexter Jackson for essentially what the team was offering Kwamie Lassiter last year is a deal and a half. In Jackson the Cardinals are getting a complete safety...a hitter and rangy, super fast ballhawk. Having Jackson to man the deep patrol against the pass happy NFC West teams is just what the Cardinals need. A stellar acquisition.

This week CB Tod McBride of Green Bay comes for a visit. He's a tall, physical corner who may be able to dog the likes of Terrell Owens in the slot in the nickel and dime packages. This is yet another move to bolster the team's depth and special teams play.

Summary: Positions addressed: QB, FB, OL depth, LB depth, FS. Positions still needing to be addressed: WR, DE. Rating the Cardinals' moves this week: A
 

slanidrac16

ASFN Icon
Supporting Member
Joined
Jul 11, 2002
Posts
15,578
Reaction score
15,839
Location
Plainfield, Il.
Absolutely!

And we still have cap space. GET SEAU AND SMITH! For Gods sake, Seau at that price could be a roving pass rusher. Emmitt Smith would make this team deeper and better. These 2 players would add 15,000 fans a game.

I too am concerned about wr. Not much has been mentioned about Gilmore's injury. I understand it was pretty serious and I doubt that we can be counting on him this year. Would Andre Johnson be the answer ? Is he worth taking with the 6th pick?

Are there any f/a wr available that would be considered a #1 wr?

Lot of work still left to do.
 

Rats

Somanyfreaks,SofewCircus'
Joined
Sep 28, 2002
Posts
4,075
Reaction score
6
Re: Absolutely!

Originally posted by slanidrac16
And we still have cap space. GET SEAU AND SMITH! For Gods sake, Seau at that price could be a roving pass rusher. Emmitt Smith would make this team deeper and better. These 2 players would add 15,000 fans a game.

I too am concerned about wr. Not much has been mentioned about Gilmore's injury. I understand it was pretty serious and I doubt that we can be counting on him this year. Would Andre Johnson be the answer ? Is he worth taking with the 6th pick?

Are there any f/a wr available that would be considered a #1 wr?

Lot of work still left to do.
Walter and Slan....I think you both hit right on what seems to be the needs of this team....We may very well be just one "IMPACT" player away from a very good Offense. THe pick we could have gotten for DB might have done it...oh well...but on Defense if we do not get a corner that can match up with the bigger receivers..we will have a problem. This front office team deserves a round of applause at this point . They have built a solid foundation for our Cards...but we still need impact guys at key positions...
 

CardinalChris

Big Man Himself
Joined
Jul 11, 2002
Posts
3,929
Reaction score
0
Location
Fresno, CA
I lived inSan diego the past two seasons and Seau has lost it. He hurt the Charger defense more than he helped him the past two years. There is NO WAY we should trade for him.

I like McBride. I think depth at CB is important this off season. Hill should not be our primary backup.
 

Tangodnzr

ASFN Lifer
BANNED BY MODERATORS
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
3,837
Reaction score
5
Location
Idaho
Good post. But I would totally disagree about Shelton. There's just no way that losing him improves this team right now...Period!!

I also don't think Seau is very likely to come here. He is not a good team player. His history is playing out of control, over running plays, and not playing within the system. Yes, he has a load of individual talent, and makes the highlight films....while the rest of the defense breaks down covering his grandstanding butt.

I don't see a big need for him at all, nor do I see him truly being a Mac type player, other than in intensity. But he's an unguided missle. Why do you think Marty is getting rid of him? I doubt that it's JUST because of the money. He gives defensive co-ordinators fits.
 
Last edited:

Mr. Boldin

Mel Kiper's Daddy
Joined
Jan 8, 2003
Posts
1,634
Reaction score
284
No way we should trade for Seau,,, his agent said if they cant work a trade the Bolts will release him... If he wants to play here so bad why trade for him when we can sign him... ala D. Boston. As for draft Andre Johnson, he is a great wr but I dont think we should draft him. To me Next years class of WR is just as good and prob better. I dont think Andre will be an impact #1 wr as a rookie unlike what Roy or Reggie WIlliams might be next year. If Lewftwich and Suggs are not there I highly suggest somehow getting Marcus Trufant... Trade down a few spots or whatnot.. pick up an extra 3rd rounder. I really think if Leftwich or Suggs is gone we have to go defense this year.. If we are 1 player away form great offense, but our defense is one of the worst in the NFL, why draft offense in a strong defensive draft?
 

Rats

Somanyfreaks,SofewCircus'
Joined
Sep 28, 2002
Posts
4,075
Reaction score
6
Originally posted by Tangodnzr
Good post. But I would totally disagree about Shelton. There's just no way that losing him improves this team right now...Period!!
Dude....get Therapy!...As I have stated...judging by what it would cost us by extending LS...we get better value in trade...by getting an impact guy...thats not to say LS is not a good LT...it's to say that he is more valuable to the team if they move him for a WR, DE, or CB...in the draft. WE can replace him with what is on the roster....:wave:
 

40yearfan

DEFENSE!!!!
Supporting Member
Joined
Feb 2, 2003
Posts
35,013
Reaction score
456
Location
Phoenix, AZ.
Walter Mitchell----Great post and a really in-depth report. We've gone from the depths of degradation 10 days ago to a team on a mission with a well thought out plan. I agree with you on Seau and Smith. I think what they would add to this team is immeasurable by just the dollars they would cost. Experience, a winning attitude, and a knowledge of how to win can change a young, inexperienced hard luck team into a true winner, create fan excitement, and fill the stands.
 

Tangodnzr

ASFN Lifer
BANNED BY MODERATORS
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
3,837
Reaction score
5
Location
Idaho
Originally posted by Rats
Dude....get Therapy!...Dude??? LOL.
....grow up!!!!


As I have stated...judging by what it would cost us by extending LS...we get better value in trade...by getting an impact guy...thats not to say LS is not a good LT...it's to say that he is more valuable to the team if they move him for a WR, DE, or CB...in the draft. WE can replace him with what is on the roster....:wave:
ZZZZZZZZZZZZZ!!!!
[/B]
 

Rats

Somanyfreaks,SofewCircus'
Joined
Sep 28, 2002
Posts
4,075
Reaction score
6
Originally posted by Tangodnzr
Glad to see you went back to your nap there Harry...zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
 

john h

Registered User
LEGACY MEMBER
Joined
Sep 24, 2002
Posts
10,552
Reaction score
13
Location
Little Rock
Re: Absolutely!

Originally posted by slanidrac16
And we still have cap space. GET SEAU AND SMITH! For Gods sake, Seau at that price could be a roving pass rusher. Emmitt Smith would make this team deeper and better. These 2 players would add 15,000 fans a game.

I too am concerned about wr. Not much has been mentioned about Gilmore's injury. I understand it was pretty serious and I doubt that we can be counting on him this year. Would Andre Johnson be the answer ? Is he worth taking with the 6th pick?

Are there any f/a wr available that would be considered a #1 wr?

Lot of work still left to do.

I do not rule out us taking a receiver with our #1. I am not for it but several draft boards have us taking one and we have an obvious need. Our current guys may have potential but that is all it is right now.
 

Zeno

Ancient
Joined
Sep 24, 2002
Posts
15,587
Reaction score
5,432
Location
Fort Myers
I wouldn't trade Shelton at this point. You will be weakening one position while attempting to strengthen another(there are no guarantees).

I am less sold on Starkey than you are, I don't think he is even much better than a back-up and a very average one at best. Center is the weak spot on the O-Line and I have yet to see anything from Starkey to make me think otherwise. He may be a guy the Cardinals can live with for another season but he isn't a long term answer(neither is Garcia).

Also 2 things I am still against signing Smith, unless its for dirt cheap--like $1.5 million tops and while I think idea of Seau is intriguing unless he is deemed 100% healthy and fit I wouldn't touch him.
 

JeffGollin

ASFN Icon
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
20,472
Reaction score
3,056
Location
Holmdel, NJ
Leave the O-Line be. Keep Shelton and at the very most sign Spikes and don't re-sign Fina if we feel Spikes is an upgrade and that Leonard would essentially be our backup LT to Shelton with Spikes sliding in to Leonard's RG position should Leonard have to make that move.

Before we even consider trading anyone for a WR or DE, we should ask ourselves: "Is there anyone on the block worth trading for?" Tai Streets maybe. But who else?

The person we trade for must fit the following job description - otherwise why bother:

WR - Over 6-2 195 lbs, runs a 4.45 or better, can jump thru the roof and has great receiving and route running skills.

DE - Edge rusher who can get to the QB. Period.
 

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
552,755
Posts
5,402,580
Members
6,313
Latest member
50 year card fan
Top