ARI 23 SF 20 Thoughts

Mitch

Crawled Through 5 FB Fields
Joined
Aug 10, 2005
Posts
13,405
Reaction score
2,982
Location
Wrentham, MA
Going into the game, I did not think this was going to be a cake walk. For one, Colin Kaepernick is starting to settle into Chip Kelly's system. For two, having a 1-7 record allows them to take risks and to play free and easy---my worry going in was that if the game were close, Kelly would go for two and the win. When that exact scenario presented itself, I was supremely relieved to see him kick the PAT.

Before I get to the Cardinals, I want to tip my hat to Kelly, Kaepernick, the 49ers defensive line and the hitting of their secondary. They came to play and made the Cardinals earn every inch of that close victory.

I think I would like to offer my concerns first, because, in closing, I want to emphasize the positives of which i feel there are many.

Concerns:

Run Blocking---obviously the 49ers made run defense their priority in this game and they were successful bottling up the Cardinals o-line and David Johnson. Like other teams, especially the ones in the division, it looked like they knew when the Cardinals were going to run. They were rarely fooled. By the time the 4th quarter came along, their defensive linemen were making so many stops that the ILBers didn't have to bite on play action, which is why the Cardinals' play action pass on 1st and 10 with a tad under 2 minutes left in the game was an absolute no-no.

David Johnson---now that he is getting the vast majority of the snaps, he has become strictly a finesse runner. By that I mean, in skiing terms, he's not running downhill, he's slaloming. He's decelerating on contact and not lowering his shoulder or delivering any punishment on the tacklers. Even in a pre-season game, rookie RB Ezekiel Elliott lowered his should on Kam Chancellor and made a statement that tackling him was not going to fun and easy. But, back to Johnson, it's not that any RB should lower the shoulder on every sign of contact, necessarily...but the best RBs do in key situations. For example, had DJ done so at the goal-line versus the Seahawks, that TD could have won the game. Instead, he decelerated and let K.J. Wright stand him up on the one yard line.

Andre Ellington---this team really missed Chris Johnson because CJ reminded DJ how important it is to run tough and to battle and fight for yards. Ellington wants absolutely no part of contact and does absolutely nothing to inspire or challenge DJ. For weeks I and others have been clamoring for bringing up Elijhaa Penny---at least he will lower his shoulder and fight for yards.

Carson Palmer---I forget which team said it last year but they said they were hoping to capitalize on the 3-4 Palmer aberrant decisions he makes each game. Palmer was having a big first half---but his two turnovers in the second half were both inexcusable for a QB of his experience and caliber. But this is what Carson does repeatedly and this year it is affecting the team's chances to close out and win games.

Earl Watford---love the enthusiasm, but am very concerned about the lack of pop, leverage and aggression he's showing at RG. It is to the point where I am hoping the coaches try Cole Toner or Taylor Boggs.

All TEs---worst TE blocking in BA's 3 1/2 year tenure as HC. Lousy technique and inconsistent effort.

J.J. Nelson---BA and CP wanted to feature him in this game, but the game hasn't quite slowed down fro him yet. I think eventually it will, especially when he learns to look the ball in, catch, tuck and slip under contact when necessary. His deep ball tracking needs work as well, although Palmer's timing on deep balls hasn't been sharp.

Contain on Defense---lost it twice on the 49ers' game-tying TD drive and it nearly cost the team the game. The first time it looked like Calais Campbell had contain to Kaep's left, but Campbell isn't fast enough to do that job. Credit Bettcher for sending an athlete moments later like Deone Bucannon off the edge to Kaep's right---but what in the world was Bucannon doing and thinking? For one, he can't take an inside angle rush, for two he has to break down and sit on Kaep's first move so Kaep doesn't just take a sidestep and bolt free from the pocket.

49ers' Easy 1st TD---Up 14-0 the defense very clearly lost it edge, focus and desire. Yet another series of colossal coverage mixups and breakdowns---first leaving McDonald so wide open over the middle and then having Marcus Cooper and Pat P. standing side by side in no man's land while Patton drifted past them wide open in the end zone.

What's Going On?

I think that BA, CP and the offense plays at times like they want to score two TDs at once---they are so programmed to think that FGs are unacceptable that everyone gets impatient. With the Cardinals' defense playing pretty well, sometimes they have to feel good about taking points whatever way they can get them. i was happy to see BA call for the FG those 2 times in the 1st half because on both occasions it was close enough to go for it on 4th down. Those decisions by BA are key reasons why they won this game---unlike other close games where the offense came away empty in the red zone too many times.

It's good to be hungry to score TDs every time, but Palmer is doing what Kurt Warner was doing before he settled down---trying to make every play a big play at the expense of getting stripped or throwing forced errors into coverage.

On defense, it is losing focus on key assignments and responsibilities, especially late in games when those things matter the most.

The Positives:

1st Quarter Offensive TD. Hooray.

David Johnson's pass receiving. Sensational.

Carson Palmer's late game determination. Resilient.

John Wetzel's pass protection. Huge.

D.J. Humphries' pass protection. Usually Ahmad Brooks has been tough to contain.

Larry Fitzgerald's stellar play, toughness and leadership. Legendary.

Michael Floyd's bounce back performance. Spectacular.

Jefferson and Swearinger. Highly productive.

Chandler Jones, Calais Campbell and Markus Golden. Explosive.

Josh Mauro's versatility and toughness. Unsung.

Justin Bethel. Improving.

Pat P. Glue.

Gabe Martin. STs ace this week.

Ryan Quigley. Solid.

Chandler Catanzaro. Clutch.

Close Win. Timely.
 

RugbyMuffin

ASFN IDOL
Joined
Apr 30, 2003
Posts
30,485
Reaction score
4,877
I agree with most the post.

1. Still don't know why people think a 198lbs running back with injury issues is going to fight for 1/8th of a yard when that is not his game and never will be. Andre Ellington is not a power back, and never will be. The wanting for this player to play like he is 230lbs is almost sadistic. Just ask him to snap his own leg and get it over with. You want a power back ? Then demand that Arians put Stepfan Taylor in the game instead of Andre Ellington, at least it would make sense to call out Taylor for not playing physical which is his game. To use some hyperbole, this is like lining up JJ Nelson at fullback and screaming that he didn't take on the defensive tackle.


2. Justin Bethel is not improving, not even a little. He has regressed as a special teams player as well. He is good as gone in the offseason, who needs an overpaid, under performing special teams player? Youth will be served, and when the rookie is about as good as you at your position, you are usually gone, and that is where Bethel is.


Josh Mauro has really come into his own this year, I think he is going to be a key part for this team going forward.
 

b8rtm8nn

ASFN Lifer
Joined
Jan 14, 2003
Posts
3,370
Reaction score
1,647
Location
Tucson
Sad thing about contain on defense - Bucannon overpursued the RB on the option where Kaep scored because he was so mad at missing the tackle on the play before. Kid needs to learn to contain himself still.

Not much to love about Watford - this is his fourth year and he still makes mistakes and just isn't very good overall. So hit and miss with him.

Bethel always regresses when he plays defense and ST Rugby, he was very good on ST two weeks ago. No reason to cut him, just isolate him on ST and a use him as a CB5 for backup...which is what we are doing.
 

Jetstream Green

Kool Aid with a touch of vodka
Joined
Feb 5, 2003
Posts
29,476
Reaction score
16,649
Location
San Antonio, Texas
Going into the game, I did not think this was going to be a cake walk. For one, Colin Kaepernick is starting to settle into Chip Kelly's system. For two, having a 1-7 record allows them to take risks and to play free and easy---my worry going in was that if the game were close, Kelly would go for two and the win. When that exact scenario presented itself, I was supremely relieved to see him kick the PAT.

Before I get to the Cardinals, I want to tip my hat to Kelly, Kaepernick, the 49ers defensive line and the hitting of their secondary. They came to play and made the Cardinals earn every inch of that close victory.

I think I would like to offer my concerns first, because, in closing, I want to emphasize the positives of which i feel there are many.

Concerns:

Run Blocking---obviously the 49ers made run defense their priority in this game and they were successful bottling up the Cardinals o-line and David Johnson. Like other teams, especially the ones in the division, it looked like they knew when the Cardinals were going to run. They were rarely fooled. By the time the 4th quarter came along, their defensive linemen were making so many stops that the ILBers didn't have to bite on play action, which is why the Cardinals' play action pass on 1st and 10 with a tad under 2 minutes left in the game was an absolute no-no.

David Johnson---now that he is getting the vast majority of the snaps, he has become strictly a finesse runner. By that I mean, in skiing terms, he's not running downhill, he's slaloming. He's decelerating on contact and not lowering his shoulder or delivering any punishment on the tacklers. Even in a pre-season game, rookie RB Ezekiel Elliott lowered his should on Kam Chancellor and made a statement that tackling him was not going to fun and easy. But, back to Johnson, it's not that any RB should lower the shoulder on every sign of contact, necessarily...but the best RBs do in key situations. For example, had DJ done so at the goal-line versus the Seahawks, that TD could have won the game. Instead, he decelerated and let K.J. Wright stand him up on the one yard line.

Andre Ellington---this team really missed Chris Johnson because CJ reminded DJ how important it is to run tough and to battle and fight for yards. Ellington wants absolutely no part of contact and does absolutely nothing to inspire or challenge DJ. For weeks I and others have been clamoring for bringing up Elijhaa Penny---at least he will lower his shoulder and fight for yards.

Carson Palmer---I forget which team said it last year but they said they were hoping to capitalize on the 3-4 Palmer aberrant decisions he makes each game. Palmer was having a big first half---but his two turnovers in the second half were both inexcusable for a QB of his experience and caliber. But this is what Carson does repeatedly and this year it is affecting the team's chances to close out and win games.

Earl Watford---love the enthusiasm, but am very concerned about the lack of pop, leverage and aggression he's showing at RG. It is to the point where I am hoping the coaches try Cole Toner or Taylor Boggs.

All TEs---worst TE blocking in BA's 3 1/2 year tenure as HC. Lousy technique and inconsistent effort.

J.J. Nelson---BA and CP wanted to feature him in this game, but the game hasn't quite slowed down fro him yet. I think eventually it will, especially when he learns to look the ball in, catch, tuck and slip under contact when necessary. His deep ball tracking needs work as well, although Palmer's timing on deep balls hasn't been sharp.

Contain on Defense---lost it twice on the 49ers' game-tying TD drive and it nearly cost the team the game. The first time it looked like Calais Campbell had contain to Kaep's left, but Campbell isn't fast enough to do that job. Credit Bettcher for sending an athlete moments later like Deone Bucannon off the edge to Kaep's right---but what in the world was Bucannon doing and thinking? For one, he can't take an inside angle rush, for two he has to break down and sit on Kaep's first move so Kaep doesn't just take a sidestep and bolt free from the pocket.

49ers' Easy 1st TD---Up 14-0 the defense very clearly lost it edge, focus and desire. Yet another series of colossal coverage mixups and breakdowns---first leaving McDonald so wide open over the middle and then having Marcus Cooper and Pat P. standing side by side in no man's land while Patton drifted past them wide open in the end zone.

What's Going On?

I think that BA, CP and the offense plays at times like they want to score two TDs at once---they are so programmed to think that FGs are unacceptable that everyone gets impatient. With the Cardinals' defense playing pretty well, sometimes they have to feel good about taking points whatever way they can get them. i was happy to see BA call for the FG those 2 times in the 1st half because on both occasions it was close enough to go for it on 4th down. Those decisions by BA are key reasons why they won this game---unlike other close games where the offense came away empty in the red zone too many times.

It's good to be hungry to score TDs every time, but Palmer is doing what Kurt Warner was doing before he settled down---trying to make every play a big play at the expense of getting stripped or throwing forced errors into coverage.

On defense, it is losing focus on key assignments and responsibilities, especially late in games when those things matter the most.

The Positives:

1st Quarter Offensive TD. Hooray.

David Johnson's pass receiving. Sensational.

Carson Palmer's late game determination. Resilient.

John Wetzel's pass protection. Huge.

D.J. Humphries' pass protection. Usually Ahmad Brooks has been tough to contain.

Larry Fitzgerald's stellar play, toughness and leadership. Legendary.

Michael Floyd's bounce back performance. Spectacular.

Jefferson and Swearinger. Highly productive.

Chandler Jones, Calais Campbell and Markus Golden. Explosive.

Josh Mauro's versatility and toughness. Unsung.

Justin Bethel. Improving.

Pat P. Glue.

Gabe Martin. STs ace this week.

Ryan Quigley. Solid.

Chandler Catanzaro. Clutch.

Close Win. Timely.

Bethel improving?... the guy was saved towards the end by bad passes and dropped balls, and he gives so much cushion they should call him Charmin
 
OP
OP
Mitch

Mitch

Crawled Through 5 FB Fields
Joined
Aug 10, 2005
Posts
13,405
Reaction score
2,982
Location
Wrentham, MA
Ellington---Rugby, remember when Edgerrin James was backed up by Tim Hightower? Hightower made Edgerrin James a better RB because he ran so hard and tough. This is what i meant. If DJ could see his backup running hard and tough, then it could motivate him. CJ motivated DJ to run better and harder. We need that.

For all the reasons you mentioned, Ellington is not suited to be the #2 RB. Situational #3 RB, yes.

Bethel---man, more often than not in the second half, he was right there, step for step in coverage. BA called his performance "solid." I thought as the game went on, Bethel was more aggressive and in much better position on a number of passes his way.
 

Russ Smith

The Original Whizzinator
Supporting Member
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
87,491
Reaction score
38,744
I actually think the reason DJ isn't doing that is simple, CJ is hurt and he knows Ellington is fragile and soft so he figures if I run like a bull in a china shop and get hurt we're in big trouble. He's not exactly Franco Harris running out of bounds all the time he does still take contact but he's just pacing himself more because he knows how valuable he is to the team.

Bethel is terrible at CB. Maybe he can play S but IIRC he started out there and was converted to CB so probably not.

This is a pretty typical football game IMO you take 2 very poor decisions by Palmer and bad CB play by Bethel and reverse it and this game is a blowout. Palmer cost us at least a FG and possibly a TD on the fumble, and cost us at least a FG and possibly a TD on the INT late in the game. Bethel turned a team punting from it's own endzone into a fg drive.

Nelson's tip for the INT was a bad play too because it should have been a first down extending the drive, but the 2 that really killed us were the fumble and the INT.

I actually would have put DJ on the KO return after they tied it up you just knew they'd kick to Ellington and he'd take another dive and he did.
 
Last edited:

NeverSayDieFan

ASFN Lifer
Joined
Feb 13, 2004
Posts
2,864
Reaction score
210
EXCELLENT write-up, as always, bud. ANY win at this point in the season is pivotal/ my advice is STOP thinking Super Bowl or Bust and enjoy being in the play-off chase. FACT: Every team is going to be disappointed at the end of the year...save one!/ Suggestions: MORE passes to A.E. and D.J. in the flat...instead of getting swallowed up in the line get out in the open-space./ Agree that the offense is "forcing it" when 3 pts. are better than none ('specially with a competitive "D"/ Concerns: Look! Even if we do get in the play-offs the "tank" is likely to be pretty empty after the physicality of playing Seattle and L.A. back-to-back. I'm optimistic but I'm also a realist.

GO CARDINALS!

Make it...INTERESTING!

Have a GREAT day, everyone!

Mark in SC :)
 

splitsecond

ASFN Addict
Joined
Jan 16, 2009
Posts
5,582
Reaction score
1,536
Location
Chandler, AZ
As much as I absolutely hated watching that game last night, a lot of it was self imposed. When you look at this team we are seriously a few plays off each game from complete domination. If we get a couple more guys to click like Floyd seems to have finally found it last night, things can be better.

Remember: we are 2 kicks from being tied with Seattle right now. 2 kicks and one blown pass from being in first place. That is as frustrating and infuriating as it is comforting. I feel like Ricky Bobby when he couldn't figure out what to do with his hands.
 

Kel Varnsen

Moderator
Moderator
Supporting Member
Moderator Emeritus
Joined
Jun 28, 2003
Posts
33,369
Reaction score
11,994
Location
Phoenix
I know it was just preseason, but I was really impressed with how Penny played. I'd like to see him get a shot.
 

JeffGollin

ASFN Icon
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
20,472
Reaction score
3,056
Location
Holmdel, NJ
Bethel should be farther along than he is.

So should Watford.

Is a scrambling Kaepernick really that fast? Or our contain guys really that slow?

Gritty play by both Fitz and Floyd

We're not getting enough production from our TE's.

Is there something wrong with Cooper that forces us to play Bethel?

Disagree with opinion that "DJ is becoming a finesse runner." There were a couple of running plays where - when he had leverage - he dragged tacklers for extra yardage.

When both our offense and offense seemed the most futile, I must confess that I wondered out loud whether we're tipping off plays.
 

b8rtm8nn

ASFN Lifer
Joined
Jan 14, 2003
Posts
3,370
Reaction score
1,647
Location
Tucson
Is a scrambling Kaepernick really that fast? Or our contain guys really that slow?

--He is really that fast.


Is there something wrong with Cooper that forces us to play Bethel?

--Since Honey Badger and Simon are out, they moved Cooper to the slot, where they acknowledge he is weaker versus playing on the outside
 

WindCardinal

All Star
Joined
Sep 10, 2012
Posts
927
Reaction score
750
Location
Abilene TX
This is from PFF. I just thought it was humorous.

Top offensive grades

WR Larry Fitzgerald, 82.8
WR Michael Floyd 79.7
G Earl Watford, 72.5
C A.Q. Shipley, 70.1
HB David A. Johnson, 66.0

Not really a "good" grade but not really bad either
 

Russ Smith

The Original Whizzinator
Supporting Member
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
87,491
Reaction score
38,744
Bethel should be farther along than he is.

So should Watford.

Is a scrambling Kaepernick really that fast? Or our contain guys really that slow?

Gritty play by both Fitz and Floyd

We're not getting enough production from our TE's.

Is there something wrong with Cooper that forces us to play Bethel?

Disagree with opinion that "DJ is becoming a finesse runner." There were a couple of running plays where - when he had leverage - he dragged tacklers for extra yardage.

When both our offense and offense seemed the most futile, I must confess that I wondered out loud whether we're tipping off plays.


We definitely tip some things.

There's one play in the game where Cooper is lined up on the left side in the slot and you can hear on TV Kaepernick points right at him and yells "watch blitz 41 left". And sure enough on the snap Cooper blitzes from the slot the RB picks him up. CK is one of those guys you can hear on every down he's pretty loud so I don't think this was a case where he calls out the guy there on every down and I just noticed this one, there was some "tell" they had that told them Cooper was coming off the slot CB blitz and it was 100% accurate.

This wasnt' one of those 51 is the mike kind of calls by a QB this was a QB knowing we were sending a CB blitz.
 

WisconsinCard

Herfin BIg Time
Joined
Apr 1, 2003
Posts
15,917
Reaction score
7,683
Location
In A Cigar Bar Near You
Bethel---man, more often than not in the second half, he was right there, step for step in coverage. BA called his performance "solid." I thought as the game went on, Bethel was more aggressive and in much better position on a number of passes his way.


Mitch here was my assessment of Bethel in another thread, I would like your take, please. This was in regards to a post by Russ about the overthrown ball that JB was trailing on.

He is constantly playing a trail technique which IMO he is not capable of doing, but I think (he got away with it on the play you describe) that is why that ball was thrown high. I just don't think he has the instincts or the make-up speed to play in the trail technique.

Playing man to man he also lets wide-outs get directly in front of him, which is an ultimate No-No. In man to man coverage he needs to be up on the LOS to get a jam on the receivers and not let them get a "run" on him. I hope this is all due to the foot injury and him not confident in his footwork.
 

mrbyte

Be careful what you wish for.
Joined
Sep 5, 2008
Posts
649
Reaction score
18
Location
Coventry, England
David Johnson---now that he is getting the vast majority of the snaps, he has become strictly a finesse runner. By that I mean, in skiing terms, he's not running downhill, he's slaloming. He's decelerating on contact and not lowering his shoulder or delivering any punishment on the tacklers. Even in a pre-season game, rookie RB Ezekiel Elliott lowered his should on Kam Chancellor and made a statement that tackling him was not going to fun and easy. But, back to Johnson, it's not that any RB should lower the shoulder on every sign of contact, necessarily...but the best RBs do in key situations. For example, had DJ done so at the goal-line versus the Seahawks, that TD could have won the game. Instead, he decelerated and let K.J. Wright stand him up on the one yard line.

Totally agree with this Mitch, I know they have been looking for a nickname for him I guess its 'happy feet' :)
 

Latest posts

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
552,681
Posts
5,401,978
Members
6,313
Latest member
50 year card fan
Top