Clarett to sue NFL?

AZCB34

ASFN Icon
Joined
Sep 23, 2002
Posts
14,848
Reaction score
7,091
Location
Mesa, AZ
The bolded quote is interesting since it is from Claretts lawyer (I think):

http://www.foxsports.com/content/view?contentId=1638888

Clarett wants to take troubles to NFL
Print this story AIM this story Email this story
BY RUSTY MILLER
Associated Press
Sep. 4, 2003 2:25 p.m.

COLUMBUS, Ohio (AP)— Maurice Clarett and his mother are considering suing the NFL for a chance to enter the league a year early, the family's attorney said Thursday.
That's one of several options for the suspended Ohio State tailback, according to Alan C. Milstein, a lawyer in Pennsauken, N.J.

He painted a picture of a contentious relationship between Ohio State officials and Michelle Clarett and her son, the leading rusher for last season's national championship team.

Clarett's mother is "distraught" at the way her son is being treated by Ohio State, Milstein said. He called Clarett "a good kid who has tried to cooperate" with investigators and university officials but is being held accountable for discrepancies in his statements after almost 11 hours of interviews over at least four days.

"We're looking at all the options," Milstein said when asked if the Claretts might sue to allow Maurice to enter the 2004 draft. "It's obviously one of the options."

The NFL does not permit players to be eligible for its draft until they have been out of high school at least three years. Clarett is a sophomore and, under the rule, could not be selected until the 2005 draft at the earliest.

Milstein said he did not believe that a court test of the NFL rule would take years and years. NFL commissioner Paul Tagliabue has said the league will fight any underclassman who tries to overturn the rule.

"When a player decides to do that, I think it's going to be a legal issue and decided rather quickly by the court," Milstein said. "There's no facts in dispute. It's just, is the rule lawful or not?"

Clarett, one of Ohio State's top players during its run to the national title last season, is suspended from the team while the NCAA and the university investigate his behavior off the field.

Ohio State athletic director Andy Geiger said Clarett was suspended because of allegations of accepting improper benefits and for misleading investigators.

Ohio State has been working for the past two weeks on a response to "several pages" of allegations sent by the NCAA to the university. Geiger said then that he thought the university would have a response finished last week.

"The family has said, 'Tell us what it is that you're going to do so that we can make the choices that we need to make,"' Milstein said. "It's unfair to string this kid out like this."

Ohio State spokesman Steve Snapp said the university's response to the NCAA is not complete and "there is no definite timetable for when it will be completed."

Geiger did not return a request left with Snapp seeking comment.

Clarett was suspended Aug. 22 but was permitted to return to practice. On Tuesday, coach Jim Tressel said Clarett would no longer be allowed to work out with the team.

"This business about you can train but then you can't train - it's ludicrous," Milstein said.

Tressel said Tuesday that the suspension appears to be "significant. It's going to be long." Geiger added, "I'm not optimistic about any number of games at this point."

Milstein said the public perception of Clarett is skewed by the intense media coverage of his situation.

"He's a little kid in a big kid's body. He has been attacked and his integrity has been questioned and he's been put through this whirlwind of accusations and he's been questioned hours and hours and hours," Milstein said.

"It's just absolutely unfair to treat any kid this way. It's just awful, to put any kid up under this kind of a microscope as if he is a professional athlete who is mature."

Milstein said Clarett's mother is upset with how her son has been handled by Ohio State. She has declined numerous requests for comment.

Geiger has not done all he can to help Clarett, Milstein said.

"I cannot understand what is motivating Ohio State," he said. "It defies explanation."
 
OP
OP
AZCB34

AZCB34

ASFN Icon
Joined
Sep 23, 2002
Posts
14,848
Reaction score
7,091
Location
Mesa, AZ
Doesn't that quote, in a nutshell, explain the NFL's whole argument for their rule?

EDIT: I think the NFL should battle this one long and hard even if it is a losing cause. This could make football just like the NBA.
 

AndyO

Veteran
Joined
Jul 19, 2003
Posts
302
Reaction score
0
Location
Mesa, AZ
The key word here, used by his own lawyer, is that he is a "kid". Suffice to say, kids don't belong in the NFL. Besides, are we all supposed to assume that after one good season of college ball that he is a drop dead NFL certainty?

I hope the NFL lawyers, if he decides to sue, bury him deep. If Clarett should win, it will be the ruination of both the NFL and NCAA football.
 

Russ Smith

The Original Whizzinator
Supporting Member
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
88,131
Reaction score
39,702
Originally posted by AndyO
The key word here, used by his own lawyer, is that he is a "kid". Suffice to say, kids don't belong in the NFL. Besides, are we all supposed to assume that after one good season of college ball that he is a drop dead NFL certainty?

I hope the NFL lawyers, if he decides to sue, bury him deep. If Clarett should win, it will be the ruination of both the NFL and NCAA football.

How come none of these national writers are comparing his situation to that of marcus Dupree? It's so similar it's eery, all he hasn't done is suffer a knee injury otherwise he's doing exactly what Dupree did.

The kid needs to take a look at where Dupree's career ended up and think about it.

Am I the only one who thinks he actually could succeed in the NFL talent wise right now? I hope he doesn't but I think he could, it's the off field Clarett that scares me, I don't think Jim Brown is doing much to help him either defending every mistake he makes.
 

LVCARDFREAK

In the league 20 years!
Joined
Mar 3, 2003
Posts
6,360
Reaction score
1
Location
Vegas
I disagree wholeheartedly. No one tells you you cant make a living because of your age. Why is football so different?

I think he could do very well in the NFL right now. I dont think he is a dead-lock as the #1 overall pick, but he is a stud. I think he realizes just how talented he is and wants the opportunity to make some money while that window of opportunity is still there.

I just dont see how anyone can say "You arent mature enough to play pro ball" thats bull.

Let the kid make some money, take care of his family, and show his talent!
 

BuckeyeCardinal

Cantankerous Curmudgeon
Joined
Jan 8, 2003
Posts
2,252
Reaction score
0
No Choice But To

He'll probably file a lawsuit cause he'll never again play for OSU.

If he transfers he's screwed because he has to sit out a year but still go to school.

That going to school part is a slight problem for him.

But then again I'm sure he'll receive the proper advice from the life-long family friend that's he's known for 3 weeks.....Mr. Jim Brown.
 
OP
OP
AZCB34

AZCB34

ASFN Icon
Joined
Sep 23, 2002
Posts
14,848
Reaction score
7,091
Location
Mesa, AZ
Originally posted by Russ Smith
How come none of these national writers are comparing his situation to that of marcus Dupree? It's so similar it's eery, all he hasn't done is suffer a knee injury otherwise he's doing exactly what Dupree did.

The kid needs to take a look at where Dupree's career ended up and think about it.

Am I the only one who thinks he actually could succeed in the NFL talent wise right now? I hope he doesn't but I think he could, it's the off field Clarett that scares me, I don't think Jim Brown is doing much to help him either defending every mistake he makes.

Russ, right now I disagree about him suceed talentwise because he only had half of a good season last year before he hurt his shoulder. If he were to come back off that injury this year and perform exactly like he did last year, then maybe there is an argument. One mroe year would have been nice.

IMO, the NFL should have the right to say who can and cannot play in their league. Nobody is saying he cannot make a living off football just not in the NFL yet. Go to Canada or Arena but the NFL has their rules in place. Go get a job at Walmart for another year and have fun. Unless a forklift runs over that "window" will still be open. The NFL isn't a welfare program for guys who don't have the intelligence or maturity to hack it in college (not even the real world). Clarett must be held accountable for his actions...doesn;t matter what Jim Brown is saying.

I don't pretend to know the legal issues as to why it is a slam dunk the NFL would lose but most seem to think that.

The off field stuff is a HUGE HUGE HUGE red flag and should be a serious consideration for drafting him if he were to win the case. Of course if he won and got into the draft and wasn;t taken until 4th round or something, then we would have a collusion case.

I think I agree with Section 11. He is a punk who lied to the police, has broken very simple rules and thinks he is now owed something. Real life doesn;t work that way...but alas football isn't real life.
 

Rivercard

Too much good stuff
Joined
Jul 2, 2003
Posts
29,690
Reaction score
17,744
Location
Is everything
Re: No Choice But To

Originally posted by BuckeyeCardinal
He'll probably file a lawsuit cause he'll never again play for OSU.

If he transfers he's screwed because he has to sit out a year but still go to school.

That going to school part is a slight problem for him.

But then again I'm sure he'll receive the proper advice from the life-long family friend that's he's known for 3 weeks.....Mr. Jim Brown.

Jim Brown is becoming the Gloria Allred of the NFL. He seems to attract these high profile cases.
 

Russ Smith

The Original Whizzinator
Supporting Member
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
88,131
Reaction score
39,702
Originally posted by AZCB34
Russ, right now I disagree about him suceed talentwise because he only had half of a good season last year before he hurt his shoulder. If he were to come back off that injury this year and perform exactly like he did last year, then maybe there is an argument. One mroe year would have been nice.

IMO, the NFL should have the right to say who can and cannot play in their league. Nobody is saying he cannot make a living off football just not in the NFL yet. Go to Canada or Arena but the NFL has their rules in place. Go get a job at Walmart for another year and have fun. Unless a forklift runs over that "window" will still be open. The NFL isn't a welfare program for guys who don't have the intelligence or maturity to hack it in college (not even the real world). Clarett must be held accountable for his actions...doesn;t matter what Jim Brown is saying.


I just haven't seen too many guys that big and strong who can run like that, he's not just a bull he's maneuverable too.

I think that will translate to the NFL, he actually does remind me a lot of Dupree in that way although he's not nearly as fast as Dupree was pre injury.

Where he'll have issues is the maturity stuff. Will he be able to learn an NFL playbook and be responsible to be at meetings and stay out of trouble? That's where I worry about him, when the game starts as long as he knows his job he'd be able to compete.

but it's a different level, in college if you miss pass blocking assignments you get away with it, in the NFL you get a 5 million a year QB killed. THat's where a guy like Clarett scares me.
 

BuckeyeCardinal

Cantankerous Curmudgeon
Joined
Jan 8, 2003
Posts
2,252
Reaction score
0
Mo

"I just haven't seen too many guys that big and strong who can run like that, he's not just a bull he's maneuverable too."


If you saw the interception play in the NC where he ran back and stripped the ball from the Miami dude....that one play shows that he's a special player.....if he can become unstupid he'll be a Pro Bowler.....maybe maturation will help....I said maturation....don't get crazy on me...but maybe he'll just stay plain stupid.....which he is now.
 

Cbus cardsfan

Back to Back ASFN FFL Champion
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
21,509
Reaction score
7,771
Clarett is done at OSU,just ax him.He's a kid who's talented and wants everything handed to him.I'm friends with his freshman "tutor" and i have known of all these shenaningans since prior to last year.He enrolled early and would've been academically inelgible his 1st quarter there.Basically,he wants money and he doesn't really care how he gets it.He's had lawyers looking into the NFL challenge ever since game 1 at osu.As for his talent,the best comparison i have seen about him is that he's a faster EDgerrin James.I don't know how Jim Brown got invloved in this.Maybe he got tired of beating his wife and had to focus his energy on something else.All in all, to sum up Clarett-good kid,talented,very stupid.
 

wierwolf

Koolaid Guzzler
Joined
Mar 22, 2003
Posts
1,025
Reaction score
0
Location
Gainesville, FL
I think the steam has diminished (the chance to win a case) by suing the NFL. I mean if he had done it when the publicity was at it's peak before he was allowed back to Ohio State. Now game 1 he didn't get his way, now let's go back to suing the NFL again, even though he was even on an interview saying he had no intentions of sueing the NFL. Yes he has talent but like some, his outer actions just takes away from his potential. Yeah.. Jim Brown is a good speaker for him. Next he'll probably have Jesse Jackson come out.
 

Cbus cardsfan

Back to Back ASFN FFL Champion
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
21,509
Reaction score
7,771
I think he ought to bring in O.J.(not Anderson) to speak for him.That will give him some more credibility.Is Rae Carruth available?
 

cardzfan

Veteran
Joined
Jul 13, 2003
Posts
111
Reaction score
0
Location
Las Vegas
Claret is not ready for the NFL. I doubt many teams will waste a high pick on aguy who has to sit for a while. Even if his lawsuit is successfull he will not find big money. IF a team tries to play such a young guy he will be slapped around.
 

Skkorpion

Grey haired old Bird
LEGACY MEMBER
Supporting Member
Joined
May 9, 2002
Posts
11,026
Reaction score
5
Location
Sun City, AZ
I think Claret would start right now for a third of all the NFL teams. He's that talented.

The problem is that he's a willing, lieing, cheat, with no remorse and no moral values to his life. A complete turd of a human being.
 

BW52

Registered
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
5,043
Reaction score
1,904
Location
crestwood,Ky
Originally posted by Skkorpion
I think Claret would start right now for a third of all the NFL teams. He's that talented.

The problem is that he's a willing, lieing, cheat, with no remorse and no moral values to his life. A complete turd of a human being.


Sounds like a natural for the Cowboys.
 
Top