D-Backs turn to Melvin after sacking Backman

azdad1978

Championship!!!!
Joined
Dec 8, 2002
Posts
14,982
Reaction score
50
Location
ordinance 2257
By Ed Price, Tribune

Bob Melvin’s background check came through squeaky clean.
After deciding they could not go forward with Wally Backman as their manager, the Diamondbacks on Friday announced they were instead hiring Melvin, a former Arizona bench coach and Seattle Mariners manager.

"The credibility of this organization and our obligation to the fans who support it is paramount," CEO Jeff Moorad said at a Bank One Ballpark news conference.

"In the end we made a decision that was not an easy decision, but a decision that we felt was in the organization’s best interest: To turn the page — which had only been printed a few days before — but to turn the page and turn back to Bob Melvin."

The team also announced that former Diamondbacks infielder Jay Bell would serve as Melvin’s bench coach.

Backman and his agent were unavailable for comment.

"He’s very disappointed but he understands and respects our decision," said Ken Kendrick, one of the controlling investors.

The D-Backs on Monday touted Backman as the right person to take over a team that went 51-111 this year. Kendrick introduced Backman as "absolutely a first-class person."

When it surfaced Tuesday that, in two separate incidents, Backman had pleaded guilty to driving under the influence and misdemeanor harassment in relation to a domestic dispute, the D-Backs admitted they had not done a thorough background check on Backman.

Yet Kendrick said then, "We would have hired him" even if the team had uncovered those episodes.

But, according to sources, even though Backman said there was nothing beyond what had already been revealed, the team found other troubles when it conducted an investigation.

That led the team to withdraw its contract offer to Backman.

"All of us take responsibility for not doing as thorough a job as could have been done in terms of background investigation," general manager Joe Garagiola Jr. said.

Because Backman had not signed a contract, the team does not intend to compensate him.

According to the Tri-City Herald of Kennewick, Wash., Backman now faces a year in jail for possibly violating his probation in the drunkendriving case. A judge in Washington, where the DUI took place, ordered a Dec. 3 hearing.

Citing court documents, the Herald reported that Backman — whose bloodalcohol content was measured at more than 68 percent above the legal limit — was evaluated by a treatment facility and determined to be in the early stage of alcohol dependency. But when he did not seek treatment, his deferred prosecution was revoked.

Fan backlash this week was "not a lot," Kendrick said, "but I think it would have and it should have" played a part in the decision not to hire Backman.

Melvin, 43, served as bench coach under Arizona manager Bob Brenly in 2001-02, leaving to manage the Mariners. He was fired last month after Seattle went 63-99.

"I think the record of Bob Melvin and the coaches, when they’re announced, as well as who they are and the way they have and will conduct themselves will go a long way toward restoring faith in this organization," Garagiola said.

"Time will tell. If there are people who don’t want to let go of the fact we made a mistake and we said we made a mistake, well then they won’t let go of it.’’

Melvin had no qualms about being second choice.

"All the paper ballots and the absentee ballots are in," he joked, "and I’m the manager of the Arizona Diamondbacks."

http://www.eastvalleytribune.com/index.php?sty=31083
 

FanOfTheGame1

Riding The Pine
Joined
Jul 30, 2003
Posts
198
Reaction score
0
azdad1978 said:
"He’s very disappointed but he understands and respects our decision," said Ken Kendrick, one of the controlling investors.
I hope Kendrick will understand and respect my decision not to spend another friggin' dime on tickets. There was no reason to let Backman go. Players love playing for him. And everyone - EVERYONE - loved the guy and what he could do for the quality of baseball here - until Tuesday.

Of course, his personal affairs oughta be just that, but Kendrick seems to think his ticket base thinks being "nice" is more important. Maybe that's true of the 15,000 or so that he had left at the end of last season, but it's not gonna draw anyone back.
 

DbaxJ

I was lost but now I'm found
Joined
Sep 3, 2002
Posts
3,756
Reaction score
0
FanOfTheGame1 said:
I hope Kendrick will understand and respect my decision not to spend another friggin' dime on tickets. There was no reason to let Backman go. Players love playing for him. And everyone - EVERYONE - loved the guy and what he could do for the quality of baseball here - until Tuesday.

Of course, his personal affairs oughta be just that, but Kendrick seems to think his ticket base thinks being "nice" is more important. Maybe that's true of the 15,000 or so that he had left at the end of last season, but it's not gonna draw anyone back.
Thats true on many levels, but the facts are that Wally may be facing jail time... and that is something the organization does not need lurking as the season gets under way... god forbid he gets a judge with a fly up his butt and decides to put him in custody for a month or 2, and of course to set that example, its right in the middle of the season or even playoff time....

The FO screwed the pooch on this one, no matter how you look at it.... and if the coming season turns remotely out as bad as the last one, you can bet it will be Melvins fault and he will be gone too!! Just my opinion though..
 

sunsfn

Registered User
Joined
Oct 3, 2002
Posts
4,522
Reaction score
0
The D-Backs screwed up without a doubt, but if they had kept Backman that would have been another screwup, the man is in trouble a lot and they did not need that looking at them in the future.
 

AZZenny

Registered User
Joined
Feb 18, 2003
Posts
9,235
Reaction score
2
Location
Cave Creek
I was totally for hiring Backman, and I don't like Ken Kendricks at this point (his slam at Colangelo and the Suns was grossly inappropriate), but Wally simply could not be retained once the issue of a court appearance for probation violation came up, esp. with the risk of jail time being levied. I don't know the truth of the more recent assertion they DID ask him about problems in his past and that he lied - that sounds like convenient revisionist history, or they would have said it immediately - but if there is any truth to it, another reason they just couldn't keep him.

As someone on radio said the other day, every time Wally got tossed from a game this year - and it would have happened for sure - newspapers and other media would dredge up the whole sordid past, question the DBacks' decision to hire him, etc.

Btw - reportedly a number of teams have admitted they don't do full background checks, and will begin doing so from now on.


(Hey - If you aren't going to buy tix, do the rest of us a favor! Write a letter to the org saying so, and blame it totally on the presence of Joe Jr. as GM.)
 

FanOfTheGame1

Riding The Pine
Joined
Jul 30, 2003
Posts
198
Reaction score
0
AZZenny said:
Wally simply could not be retained once the issue of a court appearance for probation violation came up, esp. with the risk of jail time being levied.

That, I will have to agree with.

Have they completely booted his ass from the organization? It would be a shame to lose him. Although when he gets his personal problems ironed out (i.e. the jail issue settled one way or the other), I expect another organization (one with more of a spine) to hire him to manage.
 

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
556,387
Posts
5,435,602
Members
6,329
Latest member
cardinals2025
Top