I guess Gonzo is going to try to rehabilitate it without surgery, as did Pujols.
What about moving Luis to 1B, where he can flip or sidearm his throws?
That would allow Hillenbrand to settle in at one position at 3B.
With a healthy Bautista and a power-capable guy in RF and LF, we'd be OK at the corners.
(I'd still like to see Hillenbrand batting 3rd in the batting order, in front of Gonzo.)
How would this lineup sound?
FINLEY..............CF
CINTRON..........SS
HILLENBRAND...3B
GONZO.............1B
WALKER............RF
BAUTISTA..........LF
COUNSELL........2B
HAMMOCK..........C