LCD or DLP?

Lefty

ASFN Icon
Joined
Jul 4, 2002
Posts
12,579
Reaction score
986
Who has a LCD or DLP tv?

I was wondering if you're happy with your LCD or DLP? I have done research and right now I am leaning towards getting a LCD widescreen tv.
 

Mike Olbinski

Formerly Chandler Mike
Supporting Member
Joined
May 13, 2002
Posts
16,396
Reaction score
13
Location
Phoenix, AZ
We just bought a 42-inch Sony Grand Wega LCD HDTV...and I absolutely love it.

My neighbors have a 52-inch DLP, and it's nice, but I don't like the glare off it...it's too shiny.

Mike
 

JS22

Say Vandelay!
Joined
Oct 21, 2002
Posts
5,791
Reaction score
211
I can never understand why people will spend $10k on an LCD or DLP TV, but laugh at me when I suggest a projector instead.

I have an Infocus Screenplay with a pull-down wall screen and it is freaking awesome. (100 inch screen) And it only ran me $1,500. It's much better than any TV that I have seen. Get a projector!
 

ActingWild

Hall of Famer
Joined
Aug 10, 2002
Posts
1,474
Reaction score
66
I've got a Samsung 61" and I absolutely love it. It's a DLP. There's quite a few extensive articles on cnet.com about the differences, pros and cons of each.
 

Mike Olbinski

Formerly Chandler Mike
Supporting Member
Joined
May 13, 2002
Posts
16,396
Reaction score
13
Location
Phoenix, AZ
WastedFate said:
I can never understand why people will spend $10k on an LCD or DLP TV, but laugh at me when I suggest a projector instead.

I have an Infocus Screenplay with a pull-down wall screen and it is freaking awesome. (100 inch screen) And it only ran me $1,500. It's much better than any TV that I have seen. Get a projector!


Yeah, $1500 + the amount of money to make your room dark so you can actually watch it during the day...

My LCD cost me $1600 + shipping...not sure where you get the $10k figure...

Mike
 

Russ Smith

The Original Whizzinator
Supporting Member
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
89,168
Reaction score
41,111
Chandler Mike said:
Yeah, $1500 + the amount of money to make your room dark so you can actually watch it during the day...

My LCD cost me $1600 + shipping...not sure where you get the $10k figure...

Mike

You got a good price, the best I found at CIrcuit City, good guys and Best Buy was closer to 1900, which is what CC has it for now on sale.

I recently bought a TV and did all the legwork too. I came down to about 4 decisions. The best TV picture IMHO is the Sony XBR(several guys here mentioned it). It's about 2199 and it never goes on sale. I looked at the set you bought but it was too big for my room and too out of my budget. I came down to the Sony 34 inch widescreen KV34HS420, and the Panasonic of the same size. Sony's picture was slightly better but I bought the panasonic because it was ~ 400 cheaper. I really love my tv.

The DLP's have a bulb that has to be replaced and the bulbs are VERY expensive. The estimates on bulb life vary wildly, if you read the online reviews on Circuit City's site you'll find several folks who had a bulb burn out just over 1 year after buying the set, and in many cases I think the warranty on the bulb is only 90 days. Now maybe only people with bad experiences post reports, I don't know, but that's what scared me off DLP.

I really like the LCD's, the tv Mike bought is not a "true" flat screen it's a 15" depth and that's why it's so affordable, the really flat flat screens that you can hang on a wall like a picture cost a lot more. Plasmas seem to be fading out, too noisy and too unreliable, LCD is definitely the better technology of the two IMHO.

I looked at the projector and screen approach too but where i wanted it in a corner a screen made no sense, I would have had to do it flat on one wall and that was the wrong viewing angle for much of the room.
 

Mike Olbinski

Formerly Chandler Mike
Supporting Member
Joined
May 13, 2002
Posts
16,396
Reaction score
13
Location
Phoenix, AZ
Russ Smith said:
You got a good price, the best I found at CIrcuit City, good guys and Best Buy was closer to 1900, which is what CC has it for now on sale.

I recently bought a TV and did all the legwork too. I came down to about 4 decisions. The best TV picture IMHO is the Sony XBR(several guys here mentioned it). It's about 2199 and it never goes on sale. I looked at the set you bought but it was too big for my room and too out of my budget. I came down to the Sony 34 inch widescreen KV34HS420, and the Panasonic of the same size. Sony's picture was slightly better but I bought the panasonic because it was ~ 400 cheaper. I really love my tv.

The DLP's have a bulb that has to be replaced and the bulbs are VERY expensive. The estimates on bulb life vary wildly, if you read the online reviews on Circuit City's site you'll find several folks who had a bulb burn out just over 1 year after buying the set, and in many cases I think the warranty on the bulb is only 90 days. Now maybe only people with bad experiences post reports, I don't know, but that's what scared me off DLP.

I really like the LCD's, the tv Mike bought is not a "true" flat screen it's a 15" depth and that's why it's so affordable, the really flat flat screens that you can hang on a wall like a picture cost a lot more. Plasmas seem to be fading out, too noisy and too unreliable, LCD is definitely the better technology of the two IMHO.

I looked at the projector and screen approach too but where i wanted it in a corner a screen made no sense, I would have had to do it flat on one wall and that was the wrong viewing angle for much of the room.


The LCD I have is projection as well, so I'll need the bulb. But I got a 3 year warranty on that, so I should be good for a bit.

The LCD I have IS a flat screen, just not a flat PANEL as some thing these days...but it's nice and light, sits on a pedestal entertainment center and it's just great.

The image on the screen is so vivid...it's only downside is dark scenes can be a little bit hard to see, but that's usually not a problem from what I've seen.

We got the HD Tivo as well, and ESPN is frreaking unbelievable. Also got a HDMI Upconvert DVD player, and my movies just look sweet.

Suggestion is to maybe check out online retailers...which is where I got mine. PriceGrabber.com is a good place to start.

Mike
 

Russ Smith

The Original Whizzinator
Supporting Member
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
89,168
Reaction score
41,111
Chandler Mike said:
The LCD I have is projection as well, so I'll need the bulb. But I got a 3 year warranty on that, so I should be good for a bit.

The LCD I have IS a flat screen, just not a flat PANEL as some thing these days...but it's nice and light, sits on a pedestal entertainment center and it's just great.

The image on the screen is so vivid...it's only downside is dark scenes can be a little bit hard to see, but that's usually not a problem from what I've seen.

We got the HD Tivo as well, and ESPN is frreaking unbelievable. Also got a HDMI Upconvert DVD player, and my movies just look sweet.

Suggestion is to maybe check out online retailers...which is where I got mine. PriceGrabber.com is a good place to start.

Mike

I did check a bunch of online places but in most cases the shipping was high enough it made no sense. I bought mine online at Circuit City and got free delivery.

THe set you have I found not one complaint about the bulb burning out early or often, the DLP's there were people that were on their 3rd bulb in 18 months, things like that.

I really like the set you have, the 42 inch was just too big for my area although in reality it's not a whole lot bigger than 34 inch since mine has speakers on the sides. Mainly it was the budget.

What I mean by true flatscreen is I think they consider anything over about 8 inches deep to not be a flat screen, at least that's what I was told at ANderson's big screen. I called your tv a flat screen and got a lecture on it, the guy was of course trying to sell me a more expensive LCD and said the Sony wasn't a true flatscreen. It's much thinner than the set I got so to ME it was flat.

The Panasonic has a darker picture too, but I really love it. I watched Shark Tale yesterday and the color is amazing, of course the DVD kept jamming and skipping but that's not the tv's fault it was the 2 small gouges on the disk from blockbuster online.
 

Mike Olbinski

Formerly Chandler Mike
Supporting Member
Joined
May 13, 2002
Posts
16,396
Reaction score
13
Location
Phoenix, AZ
Russ Smith said:
I did check a bunch of online places but in most cases the shipping was high enough it made no sense. I bought mine online at Circuit City and got free delivery.

THe set you have I found not one complaint about the bulb burning out early or often, the DLP's there were people that were on their 3rd bulb in 18 months, things like that.

I really like the set you have, the 42 inch was just too big for my area although in reality it's not a whole lot bigger than 34 inch since mine has speakers on the sides. Mainly it was the budget.

What I mean by true flatscreen is I think they consider anything over about 8 inches deep to not be a flat screen, at least that's what I was told at ANderson's big screen. I called your tv a flat screen and got a lecture on it, the guy was of course trying to sell me a more expensive LCD and said the Sony wasn't a true flatscreen. It's much thinner than the set I got so to ME it was flat.

The Panasonic has a darker picture too, but I really love it. I watched Shark Tale yesterday and the color is amazing, of course the DVD kept jamming and skipping but that's not the tv's fault it was the 2 small gouges on the disk from blockbuster online.


Well, when I checked my TV, the lowest I could find in a store was $2300 +tax...

I got it online for $1600ish plus shipping for $1898. Not a bad deal :)

You are right, I guess it's not a flatscreen if that's what they say...I just thought it was Flat Panel...

My TV I researched up the butt...nothing I can find anywhere shows it having anything wrong with it...which is the reason I got it.

The bulbs are around $150-200, so if one goes out in the first year, the warranty will be nice to have...

Mike
 
OP
OP
Lefty

Lefty

ASFN Icon
Joined
Jul 4, 2002
Posts
12,579
Reaction score
986
LCD or DLP

I was about to buy a DLP widescreen TV when a friend said I would be better off with a LCD TV. Is there a big difference? I also heard there is some kind of new HDTV coming out. Anyone else hear about this?
 

nathan

ASFN Lifer
Supporting Member
Joined
May 13, 2002
Posts
4,891
Reaction score
4
Location
Alexandria, VA
Chandler Mike said:
Uhhh, did you miss the thread you started already?

Mike

No offense Zona90 but it seems you need lots of help and ask quite a few questions. :D

Zona90 said:
Cuisinart Toaster Oven
What movie should I see?
How do you put chapters on a dvd?
Where is everyone going for their summer vacation?
I have a question regarding names
I need a lift in my shoe. Does anyone else have one?
I need help in buying an international phone card
What movie has the cheesiest ending?
Question about movie dvd labels
What are the best ice cream establishments?
Need help with buying a cake online
Top sports movies per sport
I have a question regarding speed of dvd's
Looking for a good video editing software
Question about Norton Internet Security
Downloading music question
Car Question
What are your favorite recipes to cook/bake? Cooking thread
Has anyone used Zero 6 for burning discs?
What is your favorite girl scout cookie?
Need help on burning a video that is too big
Why do Hollywood people need to tell the world how much they are giving to the relief
Has anyone ever used efudex-40?
Need help buying a new digital camcorder for Christmas
What is the software called to copy dvds?
I am having a virus problem
Question regarding VHS tapes to DVD
Help in transfering files to a new computer
DLP or LCD and what brands to look at?
I have a stock question
Having problems when logging on
I need help on PayPal
What is your favorite not typical holiday movie?
What kind of TV would you buy, Plasma, LCD or DLP?
Brady Bunch question
I need help on finding how much a painting is worth
What are the top running shoes
Would you buy this movie?
Help in purchasing a new computer
What DVD recorder is the best out there?
Is Sony the way to go when buying a digital camcorder?
Digital camcorder question
You can buy five sports movies, which one's do you purchase?
Where are you guys going this summer for vacation?
Just saw a movie that makes the list for worst movies
Should I buy DVD's that are viewed widescreen or fullscreen?
I need help buying car tires
Boxers or briefs? Chunky or smooth
Cooking question
A question for those who rent
What movies had evil winning at the end?
Rate The Usual Suspects on a scale from 1-10
Looking for help on buying a plasma tv
You're on a deserted island and you are granted
Has anyone had a tooth pulled and replaced by a bridge?
Is Runaway Jury worth buying?
I need help on what color shoe to buy.
Release date for Miracle on dvd?
What are the top documentaries to buy?
Hoosiers questions
Need help in buying a DVD player
Has anyone seen Miracle yet?
Running shoes
Buying airline tickets on-line
Computer question
Need to buy a movie for a 2.5 year old girl
Question regarding Carb bars
Is Identitiy worth renting?
Does anyone have the Balance Bracelet?
Chicken Run or Ice Age?
Is One-Hour Photo any good?
What movie should I see?
How can I get a countdown scoreboard?
I need help on a high school football documentary
If you had to buy one sport movie, which one?
 
OP
OP
Lefty

Lefty

ASFN Icon
Joined
Jul 4, 2002
Posts
12,579
Reaction score
986
Chandler Mike said:
Uhhh, did you miss the thread you started already?

Mike

With work and researching this tv, I totally spaced it. Sorry. As for the bulb burning out,, can we install a new one or does the TV have to be sent in for repair?
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
560,593
Posts
5,473,231
Members
6,337
Latest member
61_Shasta
Top