Lie to Me
Was stunned to discover there's no thread on this show. It's my current favorite drama. It's an unusual procedural. Or it used to be, I guess, before everyone decided to come up with their own Monk clone.
Tim Roth is what makes this show awesome. Big-screen caliber actor on a TV show. He brings an intensity you don't usually get from a leading actor. There aren't many moments where he's laid back and mugging for the camera. When he is, he's sublimely caustic, and you get the impression he's probably not acting in those episodes. He's a jerk in real life. As a character, I love it. He's a more lovable jerk than Hugh Laurie, though Laurie is probably doing much more acting than Roth to pull off the character.
There are weaknesses. The tertiary characters are underdeveloped to the point it feels like they meant to kill them off last season and forgot to get around to it. Waiting for them to do something with the "understudies."
It's biggest weakness -- the premise -- usually becomes a strength, though. I'm dazzled by the writing staff's ability to turn the implausible to the believable most weeks. I'm surprised they've had the same staff for most of the show and they continue to come up with new ideas. I might have had three shows in me on that show and I'd need to move on to something less challenging. I'm sure the science is more absurd than real pseudoscience, but they usually get me to suspend my disbelief. Not even House pulls that off on a weekly basis (a show that's begun to mock itself every time the show-ending light bulb goes on for House when he figures out what's wrong with his patient).