Military vs. Football

Brian

PANEM ET CIRCENSES
Joined
Mar 4, 2003
Posts
8,022
Reaction score
280
Location
With the mob
Just a little rant about something that has been bugging the hell out of me for 36 hours now.

Alot of people compare/equate the military and football. They use terms like "Going to war with" or "Out there on the battlefield" or "Field General" etc.

It's a somewhat valid comparison, BUT there is something I'd give my left nut to explain to B.A.

I was a Platoon Sergeant when I went into Iraq. I served in Desert Storm prior to that. My last position I was Cadre at a schoolhouse responsible for soldiers numbering anywhere between 80 - 120. Coaches are responsible for up to 60 some odd players. Solid comparison.

In the Army there are certain absolutes. Number one is Mission first. Period. Do whatever is necessary to accomplish the mission. Football mission = win the game. Valid comparison.

Number 2, take care of your soldiers. You are everything from instructor to mentor, to father, and priest. Head coaching gig is similar. Valid comparison still.

Number 3 (Are you listening coach?) A GOOD LEADER NEVER BLAMES HIS SOLDIERS. That is a mantra in the Army and Marine Corps that is older than I am. It is something that was hammered into me through 3 different Leadership Academies. My job was to train my soldiers, lead them, put them in the best possible position to accomplish the mission, motivate them, instill pride, and develop teamwork. If they failed, I FAILED, but I didn't blame them. I found another way to motivate them. Same as a football team. No different, except maybe the consequences of losing.

If a squad leader (Amos) couldn't handle the job, I replaced him. Then we worked on his deficiencies while the Platoon moved on. Some men are leaders, some are not. Soldiers will sniff that poo out in a heartbeat. Believe me. When poo goes sideways some lead, some follow. Soldiers/players will follow a good leader. They will shun/ignore someone who is just faking it or not cut out for it anymore (even if at one time they could, past deeds and reputation doesn't matter when the bullets start flying).

Coach needs to stop blaming the players. Fire Amos. It's not personal.
 

Bert

Walkin' on Sunshine
LEGACY MEMBER
Joined
Oct 16, 2008
Posts
10,139
Reaction score
3,234
Location
Arizona
Great post, totally agree!
 

DeAnna

Just A Face in The Crowd
Joined
Jun 13, 2002
Posts
7,282
Reaction score
761
Location
Goodyear, AZ
Yeah, it always irks me when they start using those analogies 'going to war' ... nothing of the sort!
 

Krangodnzr

Captain of Team Conner
Joined
Jul 21, 2002
Posts
36,490
Reaction score
34,470
Location
Charlotte, NC
I can't say that I disagree.

I remember back when I was a PFC and my Platoon Sergeant tried to blame something happening on me to the First Sergeant and the First Sergeant exploded on him. He threatened a reduction and to make him the NBC room NCOIC. He said you will clean masks, and when you are finished you will clean masks again.

I've tried to maintain the standard of not blaming your Soldiers, but it's tough sometimes.
 
Joined
Aug 7, 2008
Posts
10,458
Reaction score
7,416
Location
Chandler
Just a little rant about something that has been bugging the hell out of me for 36 hours now.

Alot of people compare/equate the military and football. They use terms like "Going to war with" or "Out there on the battlefield" or "Field General" etc.

It's a somewhat valid comparison, BUT there is something I'd give my left nut to explain to B.A.

I was a Platoon Sergeant when I went into Iraq. I served in Desert Storm prior to that. My last position I was Cadre at a schoolhouse responsible for soldiers numbering anywhere between 80 - 120. Coaches are responsible for up to 60 some odd players. Solid comparison.

In the Army there are certain absolutes. Number one is Mission first. Period. Do whatever is necessary to accomplish the mission. Football mission = win the game. Valid comparison.

Number 2, take care of your soldiers. You are everything from instructor to mentor, to father, and priest. Head coaching gig is similar. Valid comparison still.

Number 3 (Are you listening coach?) A GOOD LEADER NEVER BLAMES HIS SOLDIERS. That is a mantra in the Army and Marine Corps that is older than I am. It is something that was hammered into me through 3 different Leadership Academies. My job was to train my soldiers, lead them, put them in the best possible position to accomplish the mission, motivate them, instill pride, and develop teamwork. If they failed, I FAILED, but I didn't blame them. I found another way to motivate them. Same as a football team. No different, except maybe the consequences of losing.

If a squad leader (Amos) couldn't handle the job, I replaced him. Then we worked on his deficiencies while the Platoon moved on. Some men are leaders, some are not. Soldiers will sniff that **** out in a heartbeat. Believe me. When **** goes sideways some lead, some follow. Soldiers/players will follow a good leader. They will shun/ignore someone who is just faking it or not cut out for it anymore (even if at one time they could, past deeds and reputation doesn't matter when the bullets start flying).

Coach needs to stop blaming the players. Fire Amos. It's not personal.


Brian, I can't thank you enough for your service & others that have served. Thank you sincerely.
 

82CardsGrad

7 x 70
Joined
Dec 31, 2004
Posts
36,148
Reaction score
8,072
Location
Scottsdale
Post of the Season!!! You nailed it Brian, perfectly! It's been eating at me as well, ever since BA said "coaches don't fix locker rooms." I don't necessarily buy that... and I would NEVER expect a head coach to utter such a cop-out statement... Bummer for sure...
 

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
553,880
Posts
5,412,385
Members
6,319
Latest member
route66
Top