that's a tough thing to say. Stafford makes Johnson look better, sure. But Johnson also makes Stafford look better too...Maybe, but it's lame that Megatron got 3rd while Fitz got 7th. Calvin Johnson had one of the best QB's throwing to him. If not for Drew and Brady throwing then Mathew Stafford would be all world, breaking Dan Marino's record for yards. He's a beast of a QB while Fitz had a bunch of chumps throwing to him. I really think Fitz deserved top 5. I like Johnson, don't get me wrong, he's such a beast, but put him behind our Oline with our QB's and see how awesome he is. Fitz deserved top 5 for just being so awesome and consistent and badass no matter who's throwing to him.
that's a tough thing to say. Stafford makes Johnson look better, sure. But Johnson also makes Stafford look better too...
on a separate note, either Peyton Manning or Terrell Suggs should not be on that list. One didn't see a single snap last year, and one wont see a single snap this year...
for sure. It's hard to compare 2 phenomenal WRs when 1 has a star QB and the other has been fielding balls thrown by, what, six different "not-star" QBs over the past 2 yearsI agree, but my point is our QB's didn't give Fitz a chance to make anyone look good. He caught one-handers, sure, but he didn't get the same throws Stafford gave to Megatron. No way. There's no argument that Stafford was better than both our QB's combined on their best days. At least 'tron had something to jump for. C'mon man.
Well that is not very fair since Suggs was injured after the list was made.that's a tough thing to say. Stafford makes Johnson look better, sure. But Johnson also makes Stafford look better too...
on a separate note, either Peyton Manning or Terrell Suggs should not be on that list. One didn't see a single snap last year, and one wont see a single snap this year...
that's a tough thing to say. Stafford makes Johnson look better, sure. But Johnson also makes Stafford look better too...
on a separate note, either Peyton Manning or Terrell Suggs should not be on that list. One didn't see a single snap last year, and one wont see a single snap this year...
if that's the case, Peyton shouldn't be on it, given he didn't touch a football last yearBut this list was based on last year. So I have no problem with Suggs on it.
Nah it is slightly based on last year as they are the most recent performances but it is a prediction list of who will be the top performers next year.But this list was based on last year. So I have no problem with Suggs on it.
I forgot the list was made so long ago. Even still, it's not like they couldn't have amended it and just move every player up 1 spot and put #101 on itNah it is slightly based on last year as they are the most recent performances but it is a prediction list of who will be the top performers next year.
So by that measure @52brandon Peyton is fine to be on the list, he should be higher IMO, and no one knew Suggs would be injured so he is fine there too.
I forgot the list was made so long ago. Even still, it's not like they couldn't have amended it and just move every player up 1 spot and put #101 on it
lol, yup. You said it a lot betterDont take this list seriously
Peyton Manning was on it for crying out loud. That undermines all credibility or arguments for how the list is constructed.
- if its recent production, then yes, CJ should be top 5, but Peyton shouldnt even be on the list.
- if its career numbers, then Peyton should be on the list, but Larry should be the #1 WR listed.
so on.
Its a fun tv program, nothing else.
*basically what I just said was already posted above, didnt see it.