Rosen vs Eli Manning

[TheCardFan]

Thought this was interesting...

Eli Manning rookie season vs Rosen

First 8 games (Manning only played in 8)


Manning

You must be registered for see images attach

Rosen

You must be registered for see images attach

 

[Jetstream Green]

Thought this was interesting...

Eli Manning rookie season vs Rosen

First 8 games (Manning only played in 8)


Manning

You must be registered for see images attach

Rosen

You must be registered for see images attach

That's his comp as I have stated before but I think Rosen can be a better QB

 

[dscher]

Very similar. I'll be a fan of whatever QB we have.. that will never change...but if I have to watch an Eli Manning clone, I'll be doing a lot of yelling at my TV. I will always remember just how bad he was for years before he strangely became super man in the playoffs.. if we hold on to Rosen, I can only hope he has such abilities.

 

[juza76]

From what we saw last year its unfair at this point compare Rosen to Manning

He has to get a lot better before thinking about any kind of comparison

 

[Shane]

From what we saw last year its unfair at this point compare Rosen to Manning

He has to get a lot better before thinking about any kind of comparison

Actuall it’s completely fair to compare rookie stats... Now if he was comparing him to manning of 5-8 years ago it would be a problem.

 

[kerouac9]

I know that Eli HAAZ RINGZ, but I'd be disappointed AF if Rosen mirrored Eli's career.

Eli's career completion percentage is 60.5%. He's lead the NFL in INTs three times. He's never had a QBR over 70.

 

[b8rtm8nn]

Rosen is MUCH better at getting sacked than Eli - HOF, here we come!

 

[kerouac9]

Rosen is MUCH better at getting sacked than Eli - HOF, here we come!

Gah! Rosen was sacked on over 10% of his dropbacks?!

 

[Shane]

Rosen is MUCH better at getting sacked than Eli - HOF, here we come!

Eli is in no way a HOFer and if he makes it it’s a travesty

 

[TheCardFan]

Eli is in no way a HOFer and if he makes it it’s a travesty

Manning had a better career than Troy Aikman. (Stats)

Aikman also had way more talent around him.

Aikman's rookie year FWIW

You must be registered for see images attach

 

[Harry]

They really aren’t similar. Eli grew up in a structure that demanded he learn to read defenses. He’s not as good as his brother, but he’s a technician. I doubt Rosen can close that gap. Rosen is far more athletic, not faster but more agile.

I think Rosen has a slightly stronger arm. I think Rosen has far more to offer than he’s shown. I just hope the Cards are once again just giving away a decent player.

 

[TheCardFan]

HALL OF FAME QUARTERBACKS STATS IN THEIR FIRST YEAR AS A FULL TIME NFL STARTER

Some are in the Hall of Fame and some of them are well on their way. Here’s a few of them.

1. Troy Aikman (1989) 11 games; 155-293 for 1749 yards; 9 TD; 18 INT; 55.9 passer rating. A career 81.6 passer rating. Never had a 4000 yard passing season.
2. John Elway (1983) 11 games; 123-259 for 1663 yards; 7 TD; 14 INT; 54.9 passer rating. Only one season with a passer rating over 90 (1993). Who knew he’d walk away with two Super Bowl titles?
3. Warren Moon (1984) 16 games; 259-450 for 3338 yards; 12 TD; 14 INT; 76.9 passer rating. Never had a 16 game season with less than 14 INTs
4. Steve Young (1986) 14 games; 195-363 for 2282 yards; 8 TD; 13 INT; 65.5 passer rating. His legs couldn’t prevent concussions. Ended up with the best ever career passer rating. Spent six years as Joe Montana’s backup.
5. Jim Kelly (1986) 16 games; 285-480 for 3593 yards; 22 TD; 17 INT; 83.3 passer rating. Spent first two professional years starting in USFL.

Potential Hall of Fame QB stats in their first full year as an NFL starter.

1. Peyton Manning (1998) 16 games; 326-575 for 3739 yards; 26 TD; 28 INT (ouch!); 71.2 passer rating. Won 3 games that year which is one of just two seasons in 12 years with less than 10 wins.
2. Drew Brees (2002) 16 games; 320-526 for 3284 yards; 17 TD; 16 INT; 76.9 passer rating. Following year was worse (67.5 passer rating) before 6 straight seasons of 89 passer rating or higher. Mr. Who Dat got dismissed by the San Diego Chargers only to eventually win a Super Bowl elsewhere

 

[TheCardFan]

Neil Lomax

You must be registered for see images attach

 

[GatorAZ]

Guys like Elway, Bradshaw and Namath have QB ratings in the 70’s. Rings will always put them over.

 

[TheCardFan]

Mathew Stafford

You must be registered for see images attach

 

[TheCardFan]

Jared Goff

You must be registered for see images attach

 

[sunsfan88]

Eli is in no way a HOFer and if he makes it it’s a travesty

He will based on the last name alone.

Hilarious to me when people say Eli should get in and Rivers shouldn’t.

HOF has never been strictly about rings and nor will it ever be.

 

[Shane]

He will based on the last name alone.

Hilarious to me when people say Eli should get in and Rivers shouldn’t.

HOF has never been strictly about rings and nor will it ever be.

Agree and I personally think Rivers should be a shoe in!!!

 

[RON_IN_OC]

I know that Eli HAAZ RINGZ, but I'd be disappointed AF if Rosen mirrored Eli's career.

Eli's career completion percentage is 60.5%. He's lead the NFL in INTs three times. He's never had a QBR over 70.

If you had to choose 1: Eli, Kurt, or Brett?

Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk

 

[TheCardFan]

Per Daniel Jeremiah on Twitter:

You must be registered for see images attach

 

[kerouac9]

If you had to choose 1: Eli, Kurt, or Brett?

Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk

Choose for what, and when? I think the Brett Favre towers above both those other guys. He threw for 4400+ yards in 1995(!!!).

 

[Jake6233]

Choose for what, and when? I think the Brett Favre towers above both those other guys. He threw for 4400+ yards in 1995(!!!).

Warner And Eli were much better in the postseason then Favre though.

 

[juza76]

The bad about Rosen is that all his performances were flat mediocre, not even a single good game

 

[kerouac9]

Warner And Eli were much better in the postseason then Favre though.

Were they, though? Favre had 24 playoff starts(!!) and an 86.3 passer rating in the playoffs.

Kurt Warner has just 13 playoff starts with much more stacked offensive rosters and a 102.8 passer rating.

Eli has 12 playoff starts and an 87.4 passer rating.

 

[Arz101]

Were they, though? Favre had 24 playoff starts(!!) and an 86.3 passer rating in the playoffs.

Kurt Warner has just 13 playoff starts with much more stacked offensive rosters and a 102.8 passer rating.

Eli has 12 playoff starts and an 87.4 passer rating.

The gulf between rating 103 and ~87 is too huge to be only attributable to players around Kurt. Have to disagree.