Best Case Scenario: 2nd
Worst Case Scenario: 4th.
There's no way this team finishes in the cellar. The Rockies are clearly the cream of the crap so to speak, and have immediate dibs on the cellar occupancy for the upcoming season.
Truthfully, neither San Francisco or LA did a whole hell of a lot to improve this post-season. Perhaps if Nomar Garciaparra reverts back to pre-2004 form, they could make some noise, but otherwise, this looks a whole lot like the squad that stunk up the joint last season. Same can be said of San Francisco and San Diego, although I really like the Young-Gonzalez acquisitions they made.
Point being: this is a wide open division. Even though I'm predicting, in a best case scenario, Arizona finishes second, it wouldn't blow my mind entirely if they snuck up on people and won the Division.