Top 3?

[arthurracoon]

Vote for the top 3 players in the draft...ONLY VOTE FOR 3

 

[vince56]

Only thing Manning has on Roethlisberger is his name. Roe is a better QB, hands down IMO.

 

[TheCardFan]

Originally posted by vince56
Only thing Manning has on Roethlisberger is his name. Roe is a better QB, hands down IMO.

Hands down? They were saying the exact same thing when Peyton came out. Manning has the genes, the experience, and played much better opponents.

 

[Brevity]

Manning, M. Williams, and Fitzgerald are the first three if no one trades out of their position.

Phillip Rivers may go before Roethlisberger IMHO.

 

[Skkorpion]

I agree with Brevity on Rivers. My top 3 for the Cards draft board:

1. Philip Rivers
2. Udeze
3. Wilfork

Bill Walsh has often said the two most important stats for a QB are completion percentage and interception percentage. Philip Rivers completed 71% of his throws with a low interception rate. The other qbs stats pale in comparison.

 

[NFL_FAN]

To clarify, top 3 talent or what we think the top three picks will be?

 

[vince56]

Originally posted by TheCardFan
Hands down? They were saying the exact same thing when Peyton came out. Manning has the genes, the experience, and played much better opponents.

Yes, hands down...... IN MY OPINION

I watched both QBs play this year, and Ben impressed me more than Eli.

 

[Diamondback Jay]

Originally posted by vince56
Only thing Manning has on Roethlisberger is his name. Roe is a better QB, hands down IMO.

Not to knock the MAC, which is easily the best of the Mid Major Conferences in College Football, but the one game Roethlesberger played against a major team, he looked like **** (Opener against Iowa).

If I'm picking and both fall in to my lap, I go with Manning. He's got the bloodlines, he's got the proven experience in a major conference, and he seems to have all the necessary intangables to be a franchise QB.

However, for the needs Arizona has, if I'm Denny Green I'm taking a long look at Manning, Fitzgerald (3 WideOut Set with Boldin and Bryant Johnson) and Sean Taylor.

 

[arthurracoon]

Originally posted by NFL_FAN
To clarify, top 3 talent or what we think the top three picks will be?

Vote whichever way you would feel if you were the Cards GM, but post both your opinions.

 

[HoodieBets]

Man Gamble gets no respect, he is better then big ben and harris.