Errntknght said:
"I don't see how anyone can accurately answer this question."
We don't have to answer it accurately, just answer on the basis of what we know and have heard. I've heard that Milos isn't much of a defender, and few Euros have been labelled as poor defenders then proved otherwise, so I go with Barbs - who isn't really a good defender yet but he has good possibilities in that realm. I don't expect him to turn out to be a starting PG in the NBA but I think he'll be a solid bench contributor as a combo guard who can up the tempo of a game.
The key thing to remember when it comes to getting players is to think playoffs, where weak defenders get picked on unmercifully. If a guy won't help you in the playoffs you are better off without him - with him you might go into the playoffs thinking your team is better than it really is.
I watched this game Thursday. Ideally the Phoenix Suns would want a point guard who is good in the open court, a strong defender, a good shooter, and can break down opposing defenses when a half-court offense stalls. I obviously have yet to see Vujanic against a strong, NBA defender, but at this point I think the only area he will probably struggle in his defense.
I believe I have now seen Vujanic in 5-6 games. He may not pick up a lot of assists for Skipper Bologna, but he is a very good passer. He just really isn't asked to run the point guard position like we're used to seeing from a traditional NBA point guard. However I think he would be capable of doing that.
He is very good at finding the open man if the defense collapses on him when he drives to the basket. He's also very good at running a fast break. He is not like Barbosa, Eisley, or some of the other guards we have seen in the Suns uniform lately who will almost always try to finish the break on their own. He knows where to put the ball to get easy basket. He has a nice runner in the land similar to what we see from Tony Parker and Steve Nash.
Like Nash, Vujanic does not possess a great first step that is going to allow him to just below by defenders, so he uses changes in his speed to get to the basket. He has excellent acceleration. I think that he will be very similar to Steve Nash. I'm not sure he has quite the range on his shot yet, but the rest of the games are very similar.
I'm sure Barbosa will improve this summer, but based on what I've seen so far Vujanic would be better for the Phoenix Suns offensively. Barbosa is basically a spot up shooter. Occasionally he can take his man off the dribble, but if the defense collapses he seems lost. At least that's the way it was last season. Defensively I do think Barbosa would be better because of his length and quickness. Vujanic is probably very similar to Steve Nash defensively.
Basically I've come to the conclusion that Barbosa and Vujanic would probably make a nice point guard tandem. I'm not sure it really matters who starts. They could each play 20-25 minutes per game depending on the matchups. It's going to come down to the Phoenix Suns other lands in the draft, the expansion draft, free agency, and trade market.
The Phoenix Suns have so many options this summer it's beginning to make my head spin. I don't think they will make a decision on Vujanic until later in the summer assuming that he actually wants to play with the team. That will give them a chance to see what the team looks like and how he looks against the world's best players in the Olympics. I really hope we get to see him go head to head against the Americans or an international , NBA point guard like Tony Parker. It should give us a better idea of how he is going to fair defensively in the NBA.
Joe Mama