Who is your ultimate boom or bust player in the draft

[Jetstream Green]

A lot of people are going to say that Murray guy but for me it's Ed Oliver. Might seem a little undersized but if he could get what's there going on constant hum, then watch out... or he could be like the Niche from Ole we Miss that one

 

[Shane]

Ultimate bust Kyler Murray

Ultimate Boom Josh Allen

 

[GatorAZ]

Boom - Byron Murphy
Bust - Rashan Gary

 

[Syracusecards]

Josh Allen & Quinnen Williams. D lineman are soooooo hard to project as sure fire things.

 

[Shane]

Josh Allen & Quinnen Williams. D lineman are soooooo hard to project as sure fire things.

Which is boom which is bust

 

[Syracusecards]

Which is boom which is bust

he was asking what player do you think could boom or bust. both of these guys seem like they could either turn out to be pro-bowlers or trash. I’d pick bust for both though.

 

[BW52]

Boom-Chris Lindstrom G Boston college
Bust-Kyler Murray,Ed Oliver

 

[PACardsFan]

Biggest boom/bust potential is Quinnen Williams. He’ll either be great or absolute garbage.

 

[TJ]

I’ll just say that people are setting Murray up for failure with all of the hype. He’s not as good as some are promoting him to be, so anything less than spectacular is going to be a major let down.

 

[wkycardsfan]

Boom: Jeffrey Simmons & Hakeem Butler
Bust: Bosa (if taken by a 3-4 team)

Before you guys start telling me he is a generational talent let me say this: If taken by a 4-3 team I think the guy would be special if he stays healthy. Missed most of this last season and a large part of his HS Senior season so only 2 healthy years out of the last 4. Taken by a 3-4 team with a move to OLB.... then the bust factor goes up to me. The next time he drops into coverage will probably be his 1st time.

 

[cardpa]

Biggest boom/bust potential is Quinnen Williams. He’ll either be great or absolute garbage.

Totally agree with this, he's my pick for this also.

 

[cardpa]

Biggest surprise/Boom - Myles Sanders

Biggest Boom/Bust - Kyler Murray, Quinnen Williams

 

[Ronin]

Biggest Boom- Ed Oliver
Biggest Bust- Ed Oliver

 

[Zeno]

Boom or Bust to me is Josh Allen, he is going to be either awesome or a situational player.

 

[DVontel]

Biggest Boom - Dawson Knox

Biggest Bust - This is obvious

 

[RugbyMuffin]

Lil'Jordan Humphrey

Hands down.

 

[scandalous_b]

Boom: Jeffrey Simmons & Hakeem Butler
Bust: Bosa (if taken by a 3-4 team)

Before you guys start telling me he is a generational talent let me say this: If taken by a 4-3 team I think the guy would be special if he stays healthy. Missed most of this last season and a large part of his HS Senior season so only 2 healthy years out of the last 4. Taken by a 3-4 team with a move to OLB.... then the bust factor goes up to me. The next time he drops into coverage will probably be his 1st time.

Where to begin...

1. You are drastically overrating the difference between playing 4-3 DE and 3-4 OLB. A guy like Bosa will rarely be asked to drop into coverage. Even when he does drop into coverage, he will be asked to literally do the bare minimum. And whether he is amazing or terrible in coverage, nobody is going to care. His job is to rush the passer.

2. While the next time Bosa drops into coverage may be his first time - you do realize that is the case for probably 95% of edge rushers coming out of college. There's VERY few college teams that run a legit 3-4 scheme. It's typically not a concern for players to make the switch because its not exactly rocket science.

 

[Krangodnzr]

Boom: Jeffrey Simmons & Hakeem Butler
Bust: Bosa (if taken by a 3-4 team)

Before you guys start telling me he is a generational talent let me say this: If taken by a 4-3 team I think the guy would be special if he stays healthy. Missed most of this last season and a large part of his HS Senior season so only 2 healthy years out of the last 4. Taken by a 3-4 team with a move to OLB.... then the bust factor goes up to me. The next time he drops into coverage will probably be his 1st time.

Chandler Jones like never drops in coverage.