Who Was the "Real Genius" Behind the Band?

KingLouieLouie

Going Old School!
Supporting Member
Joined
Jun 24, 2003
Posts
5,532
Reaction score
46
Location
Phoenix, AZ
This question applies to any band you can think of... who was the real genius behind the band's existance? Some to me are obvious.. whereas others arent... perhaps some of the following might be ones that you may disagree with..... or... in some instances there are ones that every member was the genius to a degree.....

I'll just start with my general list for now:

1) the Who: Pete Townshend- He really has always dictated the course of the band through his innovative and sophisticated style... both in terms of musically and lyrically.. he defines the Who

2) the Beatles: John Lennon was the creative force (mainly with his 1st person narrative lyrics), however, Paul McCartney was in terms of arranging the music.....

3) Rolling Stones: In the beginning it was Brian Jones who set them on their path through his devout following of the Blues and his versatility on many instruments, but.... in some cases now...Ron Wood has steered them in a different direction... Im not underestimating both Mick & Keith here who are both geniuses in their own regards, but to me Jones and later Wood's contributions have had a more major impact in some regards...

4) Alice-in-Chains: Jerry Cantrell and Layne Staley both shared those titles for obvious reasons.....

5) Led Zeppelin: Jimmy Page.... He was the catalyst of the band that really launched them in the right direction, but later on Plant's progression as a song-writer really propelled them to further heights.....

That's all I'll list for now......
 

AzCards21

Registered User
BANNED BY MODERATORS
Banned from P+R
Joined
Jul 24, 2002
Posts
18,054
Reaction score
61
Location
What?
Def Leppard, Shania Twain- Mutt Lange

I don't think either would have done as well without him. Well, Shania could have done Playboy. :D

Actually, now Im kinda pissed off at the Mutt for screwin up a Shania center fold. :mad:
 

Gizmo Williams

Registered
Joined
Sep 11, 2002
Posts
1,301
Reaction score
4
While I don't think Liam Gallagher is ever mistaken as a genius....but Noel is the talent in Oasis and nobody would notice or care if Liam left the band. In fact, I don't think anyone cared when he left the band for awhile and Noel handled the vocals.

Another option is Mike Mills and Peter Buck with REM....I doubt REM would have been listenable if Michael Stipe was allowed to do whatever he wanted.
 

vince56

ASFN Addict
Joined
Sep 15, 2002
Posts
9,092
Reaction score
2,332
Location
Arizona
AzCards21 said:
Def Leppard, Shania Twain- Mutt Lange

I don't think either would have done as well without him. Well, Shania could have done Playboy. :D

Actually, now Im kinda pissed off at the Mutt for screwin up a Shania center fold. :mad:

:biglaugh:
 
Top