R I S E ___ U P ___ D A R K ___ S I D E (2024)

BritCard

ASFN Icon
Joined
Jan 10, 2020
Posts
22,863
Reaction score
41,818
Location
UK
There's actually a lot I like about this team. I don't think we are in Darkside territory at all.

Defense plays their asses off and are tough to play for any team. There's some good young talent all over the team. Several CB's, DTD looks like a potential great find, Stills was a great draft pick, McBride is a top 5 TE, Wilson is a dependable possession receiver, Benson could go either way but shows flashes when given a chance, PJJ, while poor yesterday, has been good most of the season and Marv will work out, he's too talented not to. This isn't a bad team.

And I like all the coaching staff, they are all still young and learning but clearly have talent.

If we had a Justin Herbert, CJ Stroud or even a Jalen Hurts, at Quarterback then this team likely finishes 10-7 and we're all deliriously happy, but we don't.
 

DVontel

ASFN Icon
Joined
Jan 28, 2015
Posts
13,346
Reaction score
24,002
There's actually a lot I like about this team. I don't think we are in Darkside territory at all.

Defense plays their asses off and are tough to play for any team. There's some good young talent all over the team. Several CB's, DTD looks like a potential great find, Stills was a great draft pick, McBride is a top 5 TE, Wilson is a dependable possession receiver, Benson could go either way but shows flashes when given a chance, PJJ, while poor yesterday, has been good most of the season and Marv will work out, he's too talented not to. This isn't a bad team.

And I like all the coaching staff, they are all still young and learning but clearly have talent.

If we had a Justin Herbert, CJ Stroud or even a Jalen Hurts, at Quarterback then this team likely finishes 10-7 and we're all deliriously happy, but we don't.
I mean, it’s still not all cookies & rainbows.

We still need an EDGE considering we can’t sack the QB unless it’s a blitz or coverage sack.
 

Stout

Hold onto the ball, Murray!
Joined
Dec 30, 2002
Posts
40,179
Reaction score
24,702
Location
Pittsburgh, PA--Enemy territory!
There's actually a lot I like about this team. I don't think we are in Darkside territory at all.

Defense plays their asses off and are tough to play for any team. There's some good young talent all over the team. Several CB's, DTD looks like a potential great find, Stills was a great draft pick, McBride is a top 5 TE, Wilson is a dependable possession receiver, Benson could go either way but shows flashes when given a chance, PJJ, while poor yesterday, has been good most of the season and Marv will work out, he's too talented not to. This isn't a bad team.

And I like all the coaching staff, they are all still young and learning but clearly have talent.

If we had a Justin Herbert, CJ Stroud or even a Jalen Hurts, at Quarterback then this team likely finishes 10-7 and we're all deliriously happy, but we don't.
I don't necessarily disagree here. I don't think it's quite this sunshiny, but a solid QB would make a big difference with this team and probably have us in the playoffs. That said, we will know a lot more about all of the above in the final run in.
 

Ouchie-Z-Clown

I'm better than Mulli!
Joined
Sep 16, 2002
Posts
64,281
Reaction score
59,362
Location
SoCal
Also starting to get real concerned Paris will be just a “decent” OT at best & not on the level of a Wirfs(sigh) or Sewell.
Agreed. It was my concern when we traded down and drafted him. He was just going to be above average and not great. Which means if Robinson is likewise just above average we blew an opportunity for a difference maker. Two dimes for a quarter.
 

Chopper0080

2021 - Prove It
Joined
May 15, 2002
Posts
28,910
Reaction score
42,157
Location
Colorado
Also starting to get real concerned Paris will be just a “decent” OT at best & not on the level of a Wirfs(sigh) or Sewell.
Keep in mind that this offense has limited his development as a pass blocker to a degree because of minimal reps. Also, it’s tough blocking for a non-timing/rhythm qb.

He might not be special but he will be very good. Still feel his floor is DJ Humphries.
 

BirdGangThing

Cultist
Joined
Dec 27, 2019
Posts
16,698
Reaction score
22,901
Location
Arcadia
nah it's still dark side for me - had we won yesterday or at least competed we could've been a semi destination during free agency and not a last resort

that free agency was supposed to help catapult us further into relevancy - especially since we won't be drafting top 15

the only sooth im feeling is monti's ability to recognize talent - and rallis' ability to coach it - i think rallis is the real deal - if he had a premiere edge rusher .. forget about it
 

kerouac9

Klowned by Keim
Joined
Feb 14, 2003
Posts
38,720
Reaction score
30,593
Location
Gilbert, AZ
Agreed. It was my concern when we traded down and drafted him. He was just going to be above average and not great. Which means if Robinson is likewise just above average we blew an opportunity for a difference maker. Two dimes for a quarter.
The bigger deal is that the marginal value between having the best LT in the NFL and the 12th best LT isn’t that great. The difference between those categories of pass rusher are profound.
 

BritCard

ASFN Icon
Joined
Jan 10, 2020
Posts
22,863
Reaction score
41,818
Location
UK
I mean, it’s still not all cookies & rainbows.

We still need an EDGE considering we can’t sack the QB unless it’s a blitz or coverage sack.

Sure, but this isn't the "It's all rainbows" thread. We ain't in darkside territory. This is a better team than anything Keim put together since 2016.
 

Cheesebeef

ASFN IDOL
Supporting Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2003
Posts
92,247
Reaction score
70,562
Sure, but this isn't the "It's all rainbows" thread. We ain't in darkside territory. This is a better team than anything Keim put together since 2016.
No it’s not. The 2020 team at least had a superstar WR, what looked like an ascending QB and a dynamic young pass rusher that finished with 8 wins. This team likely finishes with less wins, a QB we know stinks, no pass rusher and an overhyped WR that is light years away from superstardom.

The 2021 team had the superstar WR, another 1000 yard WR, a much better Kyler but with very big question marks starting to be asked and won 11 games.

This team has no pass rusher, a QB everyone agrees isn’t the guy, a mediocre o-line and a great TE that likely wins 7 games.

This current team is stuck in mediocrity purgatory.
 

DVontel

ASFN Icon
Joined
Jan 28, 2015
Posts
13,346
Reaction score
24,002
I’ll be honest, I don’t think we have had a legitimately great roster on paper since 2013.

2015 was a very high powered offense, but a defense which lacked a pass-rush.

2021 was more of the same thing.
 

BritCard

ASFN Icon
Joined
Jan 10, 2020
Posts
22,863
Reaction score
41,818
Location
UK
No it’s not. The 2020 team at least had a superstar WR, what looked like an ascending QB and a dynamic young pass rusher that finished with 8 wins. This team likely finishes with less wins, a QB we know stinks, no pass rusher and an overhyped WR that is light years away from superstardom.

The 2021 team had the superstar WR, another 1000 yard WR, a much better Kyler but with very big question marks starting to be asked and won 11 games.

This team has no pass rusher, a QB everyone agrees isn’t the guy, a mediocre o-line and a great TE that likely wins 7 games.

This current team is stuck in mediocrity purgatory.

The O line is better, the running backs are better, TE is better, QB is the same, the only spot you can argue those teams were better is at WR.

2021 defense wasn't stacked with talent. CJ was turning to dust. P2 was a ghost of his former self at CB. It's pretty much a wash for me.

They ended with a better record, but for me that's because Kyler played better football. He was on fire through the first half of 2021. Had he played to that same level this year we would have a similar record.
 

Proteus

ASFN Icon
Joined
Nov 26, 2007
Posts
12,959
Reaction score
5,777
I’ll be honest, I don’t think we have had a legitimately great roster on paper since 2013.

2015 was a very high powered offense, but a defense which lacked a pass-rush.

2021 was more of the same thing.
It'd be pretty nice if we currently had one side of the ball that was great or close to it. :(
 
OP
OP
Brian in Mesa

Brian in Mesa

Advocatus Diaboli
Super Moderator
Moderator
Supporting Member
Joined
May 13, 2002
Posts
73,175
Reaction score
25,115
Location
Killjoy Central
It'd be pretty nice if we currently had one side of the ball that was great or close to it. :(
Coming into the season what we heard most of the time was how stacked the offense was and that we were going to be in a lot of high-scoring shootouts because the talent on the defensive side left a lot to be desired. Then the defense goes out and plays well, kept us in games, held opponents to low enough scores (in all but a couple of games) that if our offense was even a little subpar, we still should have won games and MEH.
 

MrYeahBut

4 Food groups: beans, chili, cheese, bacon
Supporting Member
Joined
May 20, 2002
Posts
17,970
Reaction score
13,781
Location
Albq
Coming into the season what we heard most of the time was how stacked the offense was and that we were going to be in a lot of high-scoring shootouts because the talent on the defensive side left a lot to be desired. Then the defense goes out and plays well, kept us in games, held opponents to low enough scores (in all but a couple of games) that if our offense was even a little subpar, we still should have won games and MEH.

I envy you having season tix and watching every game live. You also have my sympathy for watching every game live.

:cards:
 

slanidrac16

ASFN Icon
Supporting Member
Joined
Jul 11, 2002
Posts
15,996
Reaction score
16,718
Location
Plainfield, Il.
Coming into the season what we heard most of the time was how stacked the offense was and that we were going to be in a lot of high-scoring shootouts because the talent on the defensive side left a lot to be desired. Then the defense goes out and plays well, kept us in games, held opponents to low enough scores (in all but a couple of games) that if our offense was even a little subpar, we still should have won games and MEH.
The problem is we totally fell in love with the running game. As it turns out it’s because we have to because we have no passing game.
 

Ouchie-Z-Clown

I'm better than Mulli!
Joined
Sep 16, 2002
Posts
64,281
Reaction score
59,362
Location
SoCal
Coming into the season what we heard most of the time was how stacked the offense was and that we were going to be in a lot of high-scoring shootouts because the talent on the defensive side left a lot to be desired. Then the defense goes out and plays well, kept us in games, held opponents to low enough scores (in all but a couple of games) that if our offense was even a little subpar, we still should have won games and MEH.
I believe I was told our offense was more talented than the lions. Lol.
 

Latest posts

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
556,662
Posts
5,438,778
Members
6,330
Latest member
Trainwreck20
Top