4 years from now which of the "8 impact players" will be the best?

[Lomax to Green 84]

Eli Manning

Ben Rothlesberger

Larry Fitzgerald

Sean Taylor

Robert Gallery

Tommie Harris

Roy Williams

Kellen Winslow Jr.

 

[PDXChris]

I say Eli, and I have no reason behind it.

 

[CardShark]

It really depends upon which team they end up on. No player is going to make much of an impact by himself. Alot can change in 4 years. I hope it happens to be whoever the Cards pick up though.

 

[HoodieBets]

How come my boy Gamble isnt on the list? He is going to be a shutdown premier corner in the league plus a pro bowl return man.

 

[Jetstream Green]

either

Sean Taylor, or yes.. Roy Williams


Pick one, though... Taylor (see Roy Williams, Cowboy S)


Qbs... who knows...Eli?..Ben?...................Akili Smith? Ryan Leaf? Tim Couch?

 

[Savage58]

Kinda looks like we're answering our own questions on who to pick here, don't it.

Our big board should be

1. Eli
2. Taylor
3. Ben ?

Picking for need is a mistake, this is the best way to draft, BPA all the way baby!

Udeze should be on this poll btw, better prospect than Harris hands down, IMO.

 

[Northern Card]

This one is easy... KELLEN WINSLOW

 

[cardsunsfan]

what if the best player was a kicker? Set all kinds of records as a field goal kicker and can do punts and kickoffs? He also was quite fast and athletic enough to be a good last defense for kick and punt returners and can play on special teams?

If Ben ended up being the third best QB in the NFL and Taylor ended up being the best safety in the NFL I'd take Ben over Taylor...