Best Trade for Josh

[sinsay]

Would it be a good move if the Cards trade Josh along with a 4th and 6th to Redskins for the 15th pick and a 3rd rounder?

Cards draft Ed Oliver with the 15th pick
3rd rounder draft best OLB available.

2 spots filled on D with the 10th pick in last year draft.

The 6th round pick will have a hard time my this squad anyway.

I think if Cards offer a low round pick to sweeten the deal they may get a 1st rounder for Josh,

 

[GuernseyCard]

Would it be a good move if the Cards trade Josh along with a 4th and 6th to Redskins for the 15th pick and a 3rd rounder?

Cards draft Ed Oliver with the 15th pick
3rd rounder draft best OLB available.

2 spots filled on D with the 10th pick in last year draft.

The 6th round pick will have a hard time my this squad anyway.

I think if Cards offer a low round pick to sweeten the deal they may get a 1st rounder for Josh,

The compensation may add up, but, I doubt Oliver is there at #15. More likely second rated ILB, CB, TE, OL or perhaps best w/o.

 

[outcent13]

I would absolutely do that . More likely we add a third and receive their fourth though in my opinion.

 

[Shane]

If they trade him they are gonna get a first regardless of what the talking heads on here think... lol

No need to give up more pics.

 

[AZCrazy]

Giants or Raiders. Straight up for one of the Giants first rounders or one of the Raiders late firsts and early 2nds.
Giants have to take Eli's replacement now. They either have to spend a boatload to move up, or just give us 17 for Rosen even up.
They still get a stud at 6, get their QBOF without spending a fortune. We get top pick Murray and another solid first rounder to build the team. Rosen gets to go to a more classical situation in the brightest lights of all.

 

[Cardsfaninlouky]

If they trade him they are gonna get a first regardless of what the talking heads on here think... lol

No need to give up more pics.

I'm with you on that, no way they give him away for less than a first round pick. Gave up too much to draft him #10.

 

[Timm Rosenbach]

If they trade him they are gonna get a first regardless of what the talking heads on here think... lol

No need to give up more pics.

Insane that people are now thinking about giving away picks IN ADDITION TO ROSEN. Might as well just flush the next 3 years down the drain

 

[TheCardFan]

I'm with you on that, no way they give him away for less than a first round pick. Gave up too much to draft him #10.

+3

But if it happens, the Cardinals organization is not who I thought they were. Total amateurs.

 

[Ouchie-Z-Clown]

If they trade him they are gonna get a first regardless of what the talking heads on here think... lol

No need to give up more pics.

I agree.

 

[Ouchie-Z-Clown]

Insane that people are now thinking about giving away picks IN ADDITION TO ROSEN. Might as well just flush the next 3 years down the drain

Lol. Nice overreaction.

 

[overseascardfan]

If they trade him they are gonna get a first regardless of what the talking heads on here think... lol

No need to give up more pics.

There are potentially 4 or 5 teams interested in Rosen, the market is going to drive his price up to a mid first but no way I deal him unless its for #6 from NYG. I wouldn't even settle for #17.

 

[gamebird98]

Wont get a one for him....Unless its N.E. …..which is the last pick in round one

 

[POISON]

If they trade him they are gonna get a first regardless of what the talking heads on here think... lol

No need to give up more pics.

Rosie isn't worth a 1st round pick. Other teams know that. Cards were stupid to pick this scrub.

 

[gimpy]

Give me a break

 

[Shane]

Rosie isn't worth a 1st round pick. Other teams know that. Cards were stupid to pick this scrub.

“Talking heads” = Exhibit A

 

[dscher]

Insane that people are now thinking about giving away picks IN ADDITION TO ROSEN. Might as well just flush the next 3 years down the drain

Why not? Just start fresh.. last two years of Arians they did no obvious planning for the future...then last year was, well, last year.

 

[GatorAZ]

Rosie isn't worth a 1st round pick. Other teams know that. Cards were stupid to pick this scrub.

How bout Pittsburg? All their QB’s behind Ben are noodle-armed scrubs...

 

[cardsfanmd]

If he’s going to the redskins, I’d be very surprised if Keenum isn’t part of the deal.

 

[RON_IN_OC]

How bout Pittsburg? All their QB’s behind Ben are noodle-armed scrubs...

The kid from Ok St? Who some on hear wanted the Cards to draft?

Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk

 

[TheCardFan]

If he’s going to the redskins, I’d be very surprised if Keenum isn’t part of the deal.

Makes sense on the surface due to KK connection but...

Wouldn't that say the Cardinals knew they were drafting Murray and trading Rosen to the Redskins by March 8th (when the Redskins traded for Keenum)?

What do you do with Hundley? I don't see 2 veteran back-ups.

 

[cardsfanmd]

Makes sense on the surface due to KK connection but...

Wouldn't that say the Cardinals knew they were drafting Murray and trading Rosen to the Redskins by March 8th (when the Redskins traded for Keenum)?

What do you do with Hundley? I don't see 2 veteran back-ups.

I have no real response to the first part. You’ve got me there. As to having two veteran backups, I think it’s totally feasible if we have a rookie starter; especially considering that Hundley is cheap and sucks.

 

[TJ]

Arizona is not motivated to trade Rosen; otherwise, they’d be counter-offering these teams. If Rosen is available, it will be in the form of a bidding war, not an active negotiation.

I don’t see Arizona giving him up for less than a first.

 

[Finito]

I'm with you on that, no way they give him away for less than a first round pick. Gave up too much to draft him #10.

They actually didn’t give up anything just swapped 1st and a 3rd but we had 2 3rd round picks that year.

It was a steal by SK.

 

[HeHasRosen]

They actually didn’t give up anything just swapped 1st and a 3rd but we had 2 3rd round picks that year.

It was a steal by SK.

They gave up a 5th also. A 3rd and a 5th most definitely is not nothing. Many good players picked in those rounds. Plus that's where Keim does his best work.

 

[Timm Rosenbach]

Arizona is not motivated to trade Rosen; otherwise, they’d be counter-offering these teams. If Rosen is available, it will be in the form of a bidding war, not an active negotiation.

I don’t see Arizona giving him up for less than a first.

I don’t see him going for anything below a mid teens pick in the 1st round. Anything less than that and we are getting robbed