Does anybody know how the leadership of US Soccer works? Was Gulati voted into his position or is he simply a CEO? I never understood the deal there.
This is mostly OPINION, but from what I understand...
Being named as a member of the "board of directors" is in large part an honorary designation. The board of directors are a collection of representatives from their specific part of soccer in the USA that only come together once or twice a year. The commissioners of the MLS and Woman Pro League are included along with about a dozen leaders from youth soccer, paralympic, adult recreational, beach, futsol and player representatives. These members get together to lobby a larger portion of the pie for their specific part of soccer.
From what I understand... Gulati and Dan Flynn (and to a MUCH smaller degree, Mike Edwards) are the USSF. Gulati and Flynn listen to everyones' input, make decisions, present the final outline and get the other board of directors to rubber stamp the policy. Any excuse that attempts to deflect blame onto the "board of directors", is crap.
Its not that the other members are ineffectual. By definition, their real job is to represent their specific segment of soccer and while being a "board of directors", get the most for their specific league and people. This puts them in competition against other members of the board. They have voting power, when it comes to policy, but their needs, wants and displeasures are expressed before actions come to a vote. Again, the vote is simply an "OK" to the decisions/compromises made by Gulati and Flynn.
Yes, they do have a vote in determining the President and CEO. But as Coyote mentioned, the canidate has to be qualified and willing to receive a very small to none, salary. Also, (IMO) it is very difficult to oust the sitting President and/or CEO because of the influence they have on other board members. What I mean by that... image you are the commissioner of (X) and have developed a good relationship with the people who help you improve your league. As the commissioner of (X), you might be a fan of the MNT, but your job is concerning a segment of soccer that only has a residual effect when it comes to MNT policy.
Right now US soccer is caught in a Catch-22. It would take a huge fan outrage and media scrutenity to force the USSF to act in a way that prioritizes a hugely successful MNT. Until we get a hugely successful MNT, the actions of the USSF may never get a huge fan outrage or media scrutenity.
Again, this mostly my opinion.