Cardiac
ASFN Icon
- Joined
- Jul 21, 2002
- Posts
- 12,082
- Reaction score
- 3,354
Newton is a top 15 athlete.
If he doesn't fit the QB profile, you could always make him a RB, TE or even a SS or LB.
Regarding character issues - I'd be careful about writing him off prematurely. I admit that I haven't been scrutinizing every Newton story to hit the media, but - on face value - believe there's a significant difference between, say, (a) robbing a bank, beating up a girlfriend or shooting somebody and (b) letting an agent (or a mom, dad or uncle or coach) talk you into taking money from an agent or otherwise violating NCAA recruiting regs.
Separate but related - We should be careful to distinguish whether a trangression reflects a genuine ongoing character flaw or merely a stupid decision made immaturely.
Warren Sapp and Randy Moss were two prospects many teams wrote off due to "character issues." While neither were exactly angels, they went on to have productive careers and help their teams be successful.
Bottom line: Is Newton the next Sapp or the next Phillips?
I get what you are saying here Jeff. thing is the QB position is different for me then any other position in that character flaws are severly magnified for QB's. Big Ben is the only elite QB that I can think of that has character issues. All the other top QB's are without issues. Now if Vick actually wins some playoff games etc then you would have 2 top QB's with character issues.