He doesn't get challenged by many QBs because his man is rarely open.
There isn't a man who's gameplanned against more on our defense than PP21, and that includes Chandler Jones. It's the reason why the opposite CBs since he came into the league have allowed embarrassing passing stats.
Last season was obviously a tumultuous one for many reasons save for the last quarter, but before that, he'd never missed a game for any reason, had always been known as a top-five at worst CB, and made the pro bowl eight out of nine seasons.
Wayyy too early to write his obituary, despite people's desire to do so.
I strongly disagree.
When he is targeted is receptions allowed isn't anything to write home about.
2019 - 58 targets - 39 receptions - 67% (10 games)
2018 - 52 targets - 30 receptions - 57%
2017 - 60 targets - 28 receptions - 47%
2016 - 71 targets - 43 receptions - 60%
Avg - 57.75%
Richard Sherman through those same season
2019 - 53%
2018 - 62%
2017 - 46%
2016 - 51%
Avg - 53%
This idea that QB's don't target great corners because players aren't open is also rubbish.
Stephon Gilmore has been the best cornerback in the league for 2 years and had 96 targets last year. But that Pats have a great D with a bunch of great corners and safeties so QB's don't have a choice. With P2 they always have. He's always been by far the best cover man and the rest of the team has often been weak.
Gilmore by the way 48% allowed on those 96 targets. 47% the season before.
Would it be fair to say a sub 50% catch rate is a fair measure for a great CB? P2 has only done it twice in '15 and '17 with an average of 62.5 targets. Gilmore had 90+ on both his past 2 seasons.
P2 is a very good CB. I just don't think he's close to the level some fans, some commentators and P2 himself thinks he is.
Let's have a look at some of the notable WR1's he's come up against in recent years. Looking only at teams with a clear WR1 on the field.
2018
Brandin Cooks - 7/9 - 159 yards
Manny Sanders - 6/7 - 102 yards - TD
Tyreek Hill - 7/10 - 117 - 2 TDs
Keenan Allen - 7/7 - 72 yards - TD
Davante Adams - 8/13 - 93 yards - TD
Julio Jones - 6/8 - 82 yards - TD
2017
Golden Tate - 10/12 - 107 yards
Mike Evans - 3/8 - 95 yards - TD
Hopkins - 4/9 - 79 yards - TD
Doug Baldwin - 4/5 - 90 yards - 2 TDs
Doug Baldwin - 5/6 - 95 yards
Baldwin was the clear WR1 on that team, although only ran 40% of his route outside slot.
Either way, it's clear just from going back 2 seasons that WR1's feast against us far more often than not. This idea that P2 is closing down WR1's is a myth.