His biggest point on bankruptcy is - if you go see someone about bankruptcy advice...they're most likely going to advise you to file...because that's the only way they (the adviser) earns their pay.
He says you're better off writing everything down, negotiating on your own with creditors for settlement/payoffs when possible, or getting your income up and paying everything on your own. He is really about financial responsibility. You got yourself in the hole and you should feel obligated to repay what you owe.
I agree with Dave on a ton of things and he's a great force for good, I do however differ with him because of real life experience dealing with customers.
Most BK's are caused by ridiculous medical bills, death or disability of an earner and that's been the truth for a long long time and still is.
Dave is only focusing on the media worthy segment that files due to financial mismanagement, and although it's sizeable, it's not the main problem.
These many times file after exhausting huge amounts of reserves trying to fix things that are out of their control, and most people believe it or not are respectable and reasonable in budgeting other than their savings rate which has gotten better recently.
So Dave is a force for good but a ton of what's the best thing to do has to do with how you got to where you are, you shouldn't feel so terrible about taking a legal remedy to a situation, of course it should be a last resort but it's there for a reason.
People will suffer a ton, and I mean a ton, I've seen older people literally starving themselves rather than file, with no hope of paying down their debts at all, they're on a fixed income alone in the world with relatively no one to help them.
Reality says that Dave is right, most of us live our lives way too optimistically not planning for things that could happen but even the best plans don't always work out and at that point you should consult an attourney.