Just holds Andy Reid's burgers apparently
Doug Pederson
- Thread starter MaoTosiFanClub
- Start date
Just holds Andy Reid's burgers apparently
So because he one season where the Eagles was decimated by injury and Wentz was garbage he's now trash who only won because of Reid and Schwartz?
DVontel
ASFN Icon
- Joined
- Jan 28, 2015
- Posts
- 13,017
- Reaction score
- 23,172
A coach left one team & that team has done nothing, but crashed in a bad division.
That same coach went to a team has done nothing, but trend up in a tougher division.
I’m not gonna break it down any longer, even for you.
phillycard
ASFN Addict
phillycard
ASFN Addict
Cbus cardsfan
Back to Back ASFN FFL Champion
- Joined
- May 14, 2002
- Posts
- 21,463
- Reaction score
- 7,632
So Pederson gets no credit for being the OC, but Reich gets all the credit for being the OC?
What has Reich won in Indy? He's never finished first in a mediocre division.
I could care less about Reich or Pederson but I don't get the logic and praise for Reich.
Probably a good job really as before the season began you were holding up Pederson as a top tier coach who had done great work at Philly without much talent at the skill positions.
So it would look rather silly if you kept down this path of saying he was garbage that only did well because of Reid and Reich.
You: "Where did I say in that post that Arians didn’t matter? He was a good coach for us. Sorry, I’m not going to do backflips & hold him in a similar regard to the Doug Pedersons of the world"
Solar7: "What the hell has Doug Pederson done besides one streaky Super Bowl run? His teams play in the garbage NFC East and have barely held on to do anything that matters outside of that one year. He has had a ton of talent to work with for years. He's an alright coach, but that's about it."
You: "What’s streaky about it? He has made the playoffs 3 out of 4 years there & the 1 year he missed it, it was his & Wentz’s rookie year. You know you, me, & everyone else here would be doing backflips if Arians did what Pederson has done, especially with a backup(!!!!) QB. He doesn’t have a ton of talent. He just has a good OLine/DLine. Most of the skill positions players leave a lot to be desired."
So either you're just arguing for the sake of it, or you changed you whole opinion of a coaches career based on one season where practically the whole of the O line was out, plus some of the backups and where for large chunks of the season the entire starting WR corps and DB corps have been out.
It's fair to think a little less of someone after a bad season, but I'm not sure how you go from Pederson is great to "Pederson only ever won anything because of Reid and Reich".
Last edited:
DVontel
ASFN Icon
- Joined
- Jan 28, 2015
- Posts
- 13,017
- Reaction score
- 23,172
It’s crazy that opinions can change, right?
From this guys great to this guys only ever been good because of Reid and Reich? That's not a change. That's rewriting history.
DVontel
ASFN Icon
- Joined
- Jan 28, 2015
- Posts
- 13,017
- Reaction score
- 23,172
I’m not gonna break it down any further like you’re 12. This is my fault for even entertaining you this long.
No need to break it down, I get it. Your opinions are built on sand. They are of the moment. They don't evolve so much as get deleted and replaced.
Doug Pederson winning and he's a top tier coach. Doug Pederson has a single bad season with a ridiculously long injury list and a QB that forgot how to play and he's "only ever been good because of Reid and Reich". Makes sense. Let's move on then.
He places the Cheeseburger & Milkshake orders at Shake Shack and meets DoorDash at the door. Look at the size of those 2.
For what it's worth they were the best team to lose in the wild card round and a helluva bit better than Chuck Pagano who had Luck.
P.S. Lurie is the guy who fired Andy Reid.
Chopper0080
2021 - Prove It
Do I think Doug Pederson is better than Kliff Kingsbury? His resume shows that it is.
Did he still manage to get fired despite that resume? Yes, so I don't know how big the gap is between the two of them.
Did he still manage to get fired despite that resume? Yes, so I don't know how big the gap is between the two of them.
Krusher kardinals
All Star
No no no
Solar7
Go Suns
I had to do a double take here to figure out where I came in. I didn't realize this was a long time ago.
Arians > Pederson > Kingsbury.
And, yeah, I think @DVontel's quick to jump from "they're great" to "they're trash" a little faster than needed. Pederson will get another head coaching job, I imagine. If not, he'll at least be a highly regarded candidate at OC.
GatorAZ
feed hopkins
Do we want a coach that was trying to get fired?
Jetstream Green
Kool Aid with a touch of vodka
He tried really hard too and is no quitter, finally fired... he's a winner!
- Joined
- Jan 2, 2003
- Posts
- 91,362
- Reaction score
- 68,439
Right? Especially when we already have that guy after that 3rd and 18 option call with a QB on a bad leg, followed up by a wave the white flag 4th down punt with 3 minutes left, down 11 with the playoffs on the line.
How many coaches don't get fired if they are around long enough? There are very few Mike Tomlins and Sean Paytons and their time will come.
At the end of the day the football world was surprised Pederson was fired. Or left by "mutual consent". It seems Pederson wanted out because the FO were telling him who he had to fire as they did with Mike Groh last yeah and Pederson had enough of the interference and wanted out so he refused to do it this year.
It's not like they fired him because he was garbage.
I said towards the end of the season that I didn't want Kliff fired, but that was before the Rams game which I thought was just abysmal. From the decision that Streveler was a better backup than Hundley (clearly not) to running a speed option on 3rd and 18 with a gimpy QB, the whole game was a disaster. We held the Rams to 18 in a crucial game and we couldn't score 19. Kliff crapped the bed.
I've also said before that I think there are very few head coaches that could properly make use of Kyler. I think Pederson is one of them. He did well with Hurts late in the season and I think if we want a HC with NFL experience, a good record and a SB win that would fit this offense Pederson is a rare opportunity.
On saying that I know it won't happen, but if we only talked about things that will happen this board would be empty
Last edited:
Jetstream Green
Kool Aid with a touch of vodka
How many coaches don't get fired if they are around long enough? There are very few Mike Tomlins and Sean Paytons and their time will come.
At the end of the day the football world was surprised Pederson was fired. Or left by "mutual consent". It seems Pederson wanted out because the FO were telling him who he had to fire as they did with Mike Groh last yeah and Pederson had enough of the interference and wanted out so he refused to do it this year.
It's not like they fired him because he was garbage.
I said towards the end of the season that I didn't want Kliff fired, but that was before the Rams game which I thought was just abysmal. From the decision that Streveler was a better backup than Hundley (clearly not) to running a speed option on 3rd and 18 with a gimpy QB, the whole game was a disaster. We held the Rams to 18 in a crucial game and we couldn't score 19. Kliff crapped the bed.
I've also said before that I think there are very few head coaches that could properly make use of Kyler. I think Pederson is one of them. He did well with Hurts late in the season and I think if we want a HC with NFL experience, a good record and a SB win that would fit this offense Pederson is a rare opportunity.
On saying that I know it won't happen, but if we only talked about things that will happen this board would be empty
The football world was not surprised in the least, and the football world is probably expecting Wentz to be next now
JeffGollin
ASFN Icon
The QB situation is thought to,have put him at odds with Lurie and his GM. Case of a coach forced to play politics on a politics-laden team and winding up over his head.
Last edited:
This is bull. We should be opening up the bank to make him an offensive coordinator here. Let he and Kliff both get eyes on the offense and work together on maximizing it. As long as Pederson doesn't mind Kliff having final say.
Pederson would add a tremendous amount of experience and a winning culture to our staff. Its what Keim wants to try and do with Vance Joseph. I would take Pederson as our new HC...but if hes willing to work as an OC next year it would be great to bring him here.
It all comes down to what part of the offense is Kliff willing to open up to someone else...up to and including playcalling.
TaylorSwift
Hall of Famer
Similar threads
Latest posts
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Arizona Cardinals @ Seattle Seahawks Pre Game Thread. 11/17/24-11/23/24- Latest: Chris_Sanders
-
Staff online
-
ShaneComin for you!