Fox ranks Yao above Amare??

nothin' but net

All Star
Joined
Mar 7, 2005
Posts
512
Reaction score
0
Location
SE Arizona
Ranking the game's best centers

Mike Kahn / Special to FOXSports.com
Posted: 19 hours ago


Too often the complaint has been there are so few pure centers in the NBA anymore.
Really, how many have there ever been — at least those who were more than just thugs?To be sure, that's why so many teams have gone abroad to find 7-footers with large frames to bang inside. It almost reached epidemic proportions a couple of years ago.


But as we rank the centers of the NBA today, the majority of them still were schooled in the game here and the definition of center continues to expand beyond just locking horns inside.

Of course, there is nobody to compare to mammoth Shaquille O'Neal, who has been the preeminent pivot man ever since Hakeem Olajuwon retired. Because he is a 7-footer and well over 300 pounds with all the requisite skills, Shaq makes a game almost impossible to officiate. Consequently, defending him is mostly based on the attempt to force the ball out of his hands, unless a team can prevent him from getting the ball at all. His health has been an issue the past four seasons — he's missed an average of nearly 14 games a year ¹ and with his 34th birthday coming in March, that's not likely to change.

Nonetheless, he is Shaq!

Although there are a lot of detractors, Yao Ming's game continues to blossom, and with a year alongside Tracy McGrady under his belt, the versatile 7-foot-5 native of China will only get better this season. People forget he just turned 24 this week, so the Houston Rockets will always be contenders with this duo.

Jumping high into the mix, even though he didn't even want to play center on the Phoenix Suns, is Amare Stoudamire, at the ripe age of 22. His extraordinary playoff performance, in which he averaged 29.9 points, 10.7 rebounds and 2.00 blocks, raised the eyebrows of everyone in and around the league.

You must be registered for see images
Because of his sheer size, Shaquille O'Neal is a force in the post. (D. Lippitt/Einstein/NBAE via / Getty Images)

And as if Stoudemire isn't enough of an aberration for centers at 6-foot-10, 250 pounds, you have the two-time Eastern Conference champion Detroit Pistons' irrepressible Ben Wallace to contemplate. He's listed at 6-9, 240. Well, he definitely weighs at least 240 with his undying commitment to body-building, but few people believe he's taller than 6-8 and he still manages to body up every center in the league.

So with all the 7-footers in this league, it speaks volumes that two of the top four really aren't even that close to the magic 7-foot mark, nor are they centers in the truest sense of the position.

Sure, there are plenty more 7-footers — 7-foot-3 Zydrunas Ilgauskas is a wonderful scorer and has exceptional hands. The twin towers in Chicago, with 7-foot-1 Tyson Chandler and Eddy Curry, all 6-foot-11 and close to 300 pounds, there are two legitimate centers.

Take a peek at young Samuel Dalembert, spindly Marcus Camby and various interiors skills of Jamaal Magloire, and you get varying degrees of defensive impact and board work.

But when it comes down to ranking the centers, the only serious barometer is to give props to the unstoppable motor of Shaq Diesel as numero uno, then start the arguments comparing everyone else.

1. Shaquille O'Neal, Miami Heat

Ht./Wt.: 7-1, 325
Numbers: 22.9 pts., 10.4 reb., 2.3 blk.
There is no one like him in all of basketball, even at less than 100 percent. His size, strength, agility and strength are unparalleled today, and only Wilt Chamberlain is comparable in league history.2. Yao Ming, Houston Rockets

Ht./Wt.: 7-5, 295
Numbers: 18.3 pts., 8.4 reb., 2.0 blk.
People expect too much from him, but his somewhat placid veneer makes him a finesse player. And how many other 7-5, 295-pounders are there to match up with him? None. So it really does make him a special player and he makes the Rockets always dangerous.

3. Amare Stoudemire, Phoenix Suns
Ht./Wt.: 6-10, 250
Ht./Wt.: 26.0 pts., 8.9 reb., 1.63 blk.
His extraordinary playoff performance catapulted him into the land of superstardom. Can he stay there? That's what we don't know. He improved so much, and is so quick, what he lacks in bulk and overall strength, he makes up for in quickness and explosiveness.
You must be registered for see images
What Amare Stoudemire lacks in strength, he makes up for with his quickness and explosiveness. (Andrew D. Bernstein / Getty Images)

4. Ben Wallace, Detroit Pistons

Ht./Wt.: 6-9, 240
Numbers: 9.7 pts., 12.2 reb., 2.38 blk.
He is just as unique as Shaq or Yao or Amare, if only because he is so undersized and yet takes over games with sheer will and energy and a general focus of grabbing every rebound, attempting to block every shot or steal every pass. Even his shooting improved last season because he worked so hard on it.5. Brad Miller, Sacramento Kings

Ht./Wt.: 7-0, 260
Numbers: 15.6 pts., 9.3 reb, 1.21 blk. As far as talent goes, he's right there with all of them. Sort of a latter day Bill Laimbeer without the fangs, he can shoot, pass and rebound extremely well. The liability — and it's a big one — is he can't seem to make it through any season without breaking down. It's always late in the year and it's why the Pacers let him go for the big bucks without a fight. 6. Zydrunas Ilgauskas, Cleveland Cavaliers

Ht./Wt.: 7-3, 260
Numbers: 16.9 pts., 8.6 reb., 2.12 blk.
Z has amazing hands and touch, making him always dangerous offensively and a good alternative in the offense to LeBron James. But his lack of mobility causes him to be erratic on the boards and defensively in the interior, and that has an adverse effect on the entire defense. Nonetheless, his offensive skills make him an All-Star.7. Marcus Camby, Denver Nuggets

Ht./Wt. 6-11, 230
Numbers: 10.3 pts., 10.0 reb., 3.02 blk.
Perhaps the most underrated center in the game, what Camby lacks in strength and touch, he compensates for with energy. Carmelo Anthony is the future star, and others make contributions inside and outside. But Camby is the one who keeps the Nuggets whole with his defense, rebounding and ability to run on the break.
You must be registered for see images
Marcus Camby's defense and ability to get out and run on the break makes him valuable to the Nuggets. (Brian Bahr / Getty Images)

8. Jamaal Magloire, New Orleans Hornets

Ht./Wt.: 6-11, 260
Numbers: 11.7 pts., 8.9 reb., 1.0 blk.
He played in only 23 games last season due to a torn ligament in his hand, and then shortly after he returned in April, he missed eight more games with back spasms. It was a mess, as was the team. But he's a tough and improving interior player which is why there are always rumors about him being traded him9. Samuel Dalembert, Philadelphia 76ers

Ht./Wt.: 6-11, 250
Numbers: 8.2 pts., 7.5 reb., 1.68 blk.
The 11.6 points, 12.8 rebounds and 1.4 blocks a game he averaged against the Pistons in the five playoff games last season earned him a $64 million contract. Is he worth it or will he always be an unfinished project? It's a rather expensive question, but the good news is he has a great attitude and work ethic, which should translate to him consistently improving.10. Tyson Chandler, Chicago Bulls

Ht./Wt.: 7-1, 240
Numbers: 8.0 pts., 9.7 reb., 1.76 blk.
The less-refined talent of the twin towers that included Eddy Curry, Chandler has brought energy and unfailing work habits to be a great impact player off the bench on the defensive end. Because of the way he attacks the game, most expect the offense to come as time goes on. The real concern is what happens to Curry, with his undetermined heart issue, free agency status and weight problem. What we do know is it will only translate into more time for Chandler. Others receiver consideration: Eddy Curry, Chicago Bulls; Erick Dampier, Dallas Mavericks; Primoz Brezec, Charlotte Bobcats; Nenad Krstic, New Jersey Nets; Nazr Mohammed, San Antonio Spurs; Lorenzen Wright, Memphis Grizzlies; Chris Kamen, Los Angeles Clippers; Joel Przybilla, Portland Trail Blazers; Chris Mihm, Los Angeles Lakers.

Veteran NBA writer Mike Kahn is a frequent contributor to FOXSports.com.



I don't see how they can rank Yao higher when Amare averages almost 8 more points, more rebounds. I know Yao's defensive presence causes more people to alter shots in the paint, but I would choose Amare 10 times out of 10 over Yao.
 

Arizona's Finest

Your My Favorite Mistake
Joined
Jun 11, 2005
Posts
9,709
Reaction score
1
So if Amare vaulted into superstardom last year, Yao is considered a superstar at 18 and 8 a game:confused: . I think Kahn just gave Yao points for being a more traditional center.
 

Chaplin

Better off silent
Joined
May 13, 2002
Posts
45,888
Reaction score
16,178
Location
Round Rock, TX
Don't you guys know any history? Mike Kahn is one of the worst columnists out there, he used to be with CBSSportsline, then got hired by Fox. He's never respected the Suns at all, and by his rankings, knows absolutely nothing about basketball. :D
 

elindholm

edited for content
Joined
Sep 14, 2002
Posts
27,201
Reaction score
9,043
Location
L.A. area
What Stoudemire "lacks in overall strength"? He could break Yao in half. That's a very stupid statement.

Yao can't be considered an elite player until he can log more than 30 minutes a game.
 

Chaplin

Better off silent
Joined
May 13, 2002
Posts
45,888
Reaction score
16,178
Location
Round Rock, TX
elindholm said:
What Stoudemire "lacks in overall strength"? He could break Yao in half. That's a very stupid statement.

Yao can't be considered an elite player until he can log more than 30 minutes a game.

And actually affect the outcomes of more than 15 games...
 

George O'Brien

ASFN Icon
Joined
Nov 22, 2003
Posts
10,297
Reaction score
0
Location
Sun City
I tend to agree, but the case for Yao is entirely on the defensive end.

There can be little doubt that the biggest impact of Yao was how he discouraged opponents to try to score inside. This was a big part of why the Rockets ended up ranked 2nd in holding opponents to only 42.2% shooting. Houston held their opponents to just 91.03 ppg which was third lowest.
Oddly enough, the Suns ranked 9th in blocked shots (5.52) while Houston only 16th (4.61); but there is little doubt that having Yao inside made an impace.

Statistically, Yao looks pretty good. His stats per minute are pretty good his scoring as a proportion of the team's total offense is comparable to Amare's with the Suns.

HOWEVER, whtat the stats don't show is the impact Amare had in forcing teams to double team him and how he would take over games. Yao had some nice games, but he never dominated opponents like Amare did. At the same time, Amare's grown as an all round player continues to be greater than Yao's.

Given a choice, I'd take Amare every time.
 

PakistaniRambo

Registered
Joined
Jul 29, 2005
Posts
107
Reaction score
0
no point in arguing over this. the columnist is obviously biased in some way. i really can't fathom how anyone could think that Yao is a better player today than Amare.
 

Chaplin

Better off silent
Joined
May 13, 2002
Posts
45,888
Reaction score
16,178
Location
Round Rock, TX
George O'Brien said:
I tend to agree, but the case for Yao is entirely on the defensive end.

There can be little doubt that the biggest impact of Yao was how he discouraged opponents to try to score inside. This was a big part of why the Rockets ended up ranked 2nd in holding opponents to only 42.2% shooting. Houston held their opponents to just 91.03 ppg which was third lowest.
Oddly enough, the Suns ranked 9th in blocked shots (5.52) while Houston only 16th (4.61); but there is little doubt that having Yao inside made an impace.

Statistically, Yao looks pretty good. His stats per minute are pretty good his scoring as a proportion of the team's total offense is comparable to Amare's with the Suns.

HOWEVER, whtat the stats don't show is the impact Amare had in forcing teams to double team him and how he would take over games. Yao had some nice games, but he never dominated opponents like Amare did. At the same time, Amare's grown as an all round player continues to be greater than Yao's.

Given a choice, I'd take Amare every time.


Of course, this whole post can be applied to Steven Hunter, if you leave it up to those that wanted him to stay... ;)
 

Forum statistics

Threads
547,594
Posts
5,352,116
Members
6,304
Latest member
Dbacks05
Top