George O'Brien said:
I think it is time to come to grips with the real problem. The NBA rules are so radically different than FIBA rules, that it is in a material sense a different game.
The most obvious difference between FIBA basketball and the NBA is that NBA rules are designed to liberate athletes to show off, while FIBA rules make it much harder on super athletes:
1. Pemits hand checking and lots of perimeter contact
2. Tight calling of palming and other tricks for getting a quick first step
3. Permits full zone with no defensive three second violations
4. Has no under the basket circle and calls charges on plays that would be called blocking fouls in the NBA
5. Has very liberal goal tending rules
6. The court is smaller
It is also hard on classic low post scorers:
1. Trapezoid lane pushes low post players away from the basket
2 There are no limits on using two hands to push guys out of the post
3. There are no defensive three second violations
When you add in a ball made of different material than the NBA ball, it really is a different game. I'm not sure enough is made of just how different the FIBA feels, but it seems that most of the NBA players are uncomfortable shooting it.
Put the Greeks on an NBA court, with NBA refs and NBA rules and the results would be dramatically different, even if USA can't defend the pick and roll.
George, several of your points completely contradict the way the game is supposed to be played according to the rules.
1. Pemits hand checking and lots of perimeter contact-No doubt this is the case, but the NBA was the one that decided to limit this contact only on the perimeter. The inside game is an absolute WWE event. The greater contact seems to reduce the constant dribbling and force teams to pass more. Not necessarily a bad thing.
2. Tight calling of palming and other tricks for getting a quick first step-Sorry, but palming is a violation. I've never really understood why, if someone is supposed to be this superstar, superior athlete, does he need to also be allowed to get 2 running steps or bring the ball from one side of his body to the other without having it hit the ground?
3. Permits full zone with no defensive three second violations-I never really understood why the NBA decided that using a 'zone-lite' rule was the answer. Ball movement and shooting kills any zone. Work on that and it's just another defense.
4. Has no under the basket circle and calls charges on plays that would be called blocking fouls in the NBA-It's all about body control and taking what defenses give you. For players like we have on our roster, who can start and stop on a dime, a drive and pullup should be more common place than the drive and slam.
5. Has very liberal goal tending rules-I didn't see a huge effect from this.
6. The court is smaller-This makes it harder to create space with ball handling, but doesn't effect it from a passing standpoint.
And on these:
1. Trapezoid lane pushes low post players away from the basket-I played international ball. This actually helps good offensive post players because you have more room to make a move. It's really nice to play in.
2 There are no limits on using two hands to push guys out of the post-The NBA lets you put an elbow through a guys kidney. Just because your palms aren't on someone, doesn't mean they aren't pushing. The other thing is this goes back to the trapezoid, the wider lane means more area to work in. You don't just camp on a block and wrestle.
3. There are no defensive three second violations-Again, I don't see the issue with this. 3 dribbles and a pullup accomplish the same thing as the drive to the hole.
As far as the ball being a different material goes, I guarantee everyone one of those guys on the US roster played with everything from a Walmart special, that got hard as a rock in cold weather, to an old leather ball missing half the panels. They've had ample opportunity to get used to the feel. This is just one more thing that makes these guys look like whiney, excuse makers.
You guys may remember that I love the international game. It's a really pure form a basketball that rewards players, team play, and fundementals. It doesn't care how gifted you are, the rules apply equally.