if you had a choice, Boldin or Warner

[john h]

Either both or neither.

We will end up with to much money in the receiver position and to many good receivers and perhaps a QB who cannot hit them like a Kurt Warner. I love Boldin but we can lose him and add a good player at another position. A QB is the heart and soul of any team. Without Warner we have no shot at a superbowl next year. Matt may develop. That is unknown. Warner is a proven commodity. In the NFL you play to win now not two or three years from now.

 

[Jetstream Green]

very good point john, and that has crossed my mind too

 

[ASUCHRIS]

A QB is the heart and soul of any team. Without Warner we have no shot at a superbowl next year. Matt may develop. That is unknown. Warner is a proven commodity. In the NFL you play to win now not two or three years from now.

The voice of reason among this insanity. How many teams win super bowls without superior qb's? The answer is none. (With the exception of the Ravens, who only had one of the greatest defenses of all time).

 

[dreamcastrocks]

Without Warner we have no shot at a superbowl next year. Matt may develop. That is unknown. Warner is a proven commodity. In the NFL you play to win now not two or three years from now.

If we have learned ANYTHING in the NFL last year, is that ANYTHING is possible. How can you say that we have no shot at the superbowl next year? Did you say we were going to the superbowl last year Confucius?

 

[IAWarnerFan]

We have plenty of WR depth. We won in the playoffs without Boldin. We probably wouldn't have won without Warner. The reality is we don't know for sure if Matt Leinart will ever pan out. We hope he will, but who knows if he will and how much longer it will take.

 

[Brian in Mesa]

The voice of reason among this insanity. How many teams win super bowls without superior qb's? The answer is none. (With the exception of the Ravens, who only had one of the greatest defenses of all time).

Isn't Warner only 1 yard (or less) from being 0-3 in SB's?

 

[IAWarnerFan]

Isn't Warner only 1 yard (or less) from being 0-3 in SB's?

Didn't the Patriots cheat to beat the Rams? Sure they still had to execute, but it works both ways.

 

[TJ]

Isn't Warner only 1 yard (or less) from being 0-3 in SB's?

Or he's a video camera and a group of paid off officials away from being 3-0

 

[azsouthendzone]

Boldin

 

[moklerman]

How in the world does Arizona hope to make Boldin happy at this point? With TJ(I'm not gonna try to spell his last name) getting $8M per year Boldin just isn't going to be happy with whatever the Cardinals wind up offering. It will be less than Fitz's deal and it will be less than TJ's deal. I don't think Boldin's even top 3 in salary for NFC West WR's right now.

With the hardline stance that the team is taking with free agent signings and value, they have to trade Boldin or I think he pulls a Chad Johnson and shows up but isn't the same.

 

[DoTheDew]

How in the world does Arizona hope to make Boldin happy at this point? With TJ(I'm not gonna try to spell his last name) getting $8M per year Boldin just isn't going to be happy with whatever the Cardinals wind up offering. It will be less than Fitz's deal and it will be less than TJ's deal. I don't think Boldin's even top 3 in salary for NFC West WR's right now.

With the hardline stance that the team is taking with free agent signings and value, they have to trade Boldin or I think he pulls a Chad Johnson and shows up but isn't the same.

I'm pretty sure he is making less than Burleson Branch and now TJ on the Seahawks. I don't know what Holt's salary is but I assume it is more than Boldin's salary. So he is no greater than 5th in the conference. He is definitely underpaid.