Buckybird
Hoist the Lombardi Trophy
Would I trade the Giants straight up? Yes. Because the savings that you'd get for 80% of the production would be worth it. Especially if we're going to a more run-oriented offense. You know that the Giants had a better passing offense than the Cards did last season, don't you? Do you think that's because Warner was a stiff or because the top 3 WRs in Jersey were?
There are lots of good #1 WRs out there. I'll take Miles Austin and $8 million less per season in salary over Larry Fitzgerald. It'll hurt me maybe 5% over the course of the season, but I cam make the rest of my team better with the savings.
Breaston started 9 games in 2008. Let's not pretend that he's Jason Avant. He's a solid #2 WR who put up some good stats on a team that passed all the time because their QB was hot and their RBs were not.
Do you think that Bryant or Shipley will have worse numbers than Early Doucet? Because Doucet has played in 6 games? Will Doucet even be healthy to begin the season?
I know that you're a great fan of the team, but I don't think you watch enough of the rest of the NFL to know what you're talking about here...
K9 I see some of your points but disagree about where you rank the Cards WR corp.
1) 1st of all there is no cap so comparing the GMen to the Cards & Austin to Fitz money wise is ridiculous!!! While Austin's star is pointing upward, he needs to perform at a high level again.
2) Jason Avant? WTH has he ever done? Really...you are way out there on that one.
3) Jets? Holmes is vastly underrated, Edwards drops more than he catches & lets see watch Cotchery does this season.
My rankings
1) Saints-they have 5 very good ones
2) Colts-Wayne & Garcon may be the best starting pair
3) Pack-besides Driver they are young & getting better
4) NE-Moss makes Welker & Edellmans job easy
5) Balt-Q, Housh & Mason make the Ravens title threats
6) Dal-Austin needs to prove last year wasnt a fluke while Bryant takes this unit to new heights towards the middle of the season.
7) Cards-Fitz is a major red zone target, Breaston the deep threat & Doucet works the Lb's. If Williams proves that preason wasnt a fluke he could be make this unit better
Last edited: