Is Geno Smith really as good as he looks?

[Cbus cardsfan]

It's hard to argue against anything Smith has done this year. He's accurate on deep balls, accurate on short throws, and mobile. He's really improved. Like PA mentioned, I'd still like to see how he does with a big pass rush on him and he has to make the quick read and decision. Syracuse got to him and Maryland was after him pretty good this year. But, for the most part, he's had very little pressure at all and has thrown from a clean pocket all year.

I'd still take Tyler Wilson over him. I just think Wilson is the better NFL QB. It's kind of like last year when you had Luck and Griffith. Both are good, it just depends on personal preference.

 

[Garthshort]

Bodha, reference Geno's intelligence. I'm guessing two things:
1. He's smart enough to play in the NFL.
2. You weren't a fan of Cam Newton when he was coming out of college.

 

[Bodha]

Bodha, reference Geno's intelligence. I'm guessing two things:
1. He's smart enough to play in the NFL.
2. You weren't a fan of Cam Newton when he was coming out of college.

1. Who knows. Its completely 50-50.

2. True, but it was his attitude that irked me. I never questioned his ability. And I wouldnt use Cam as an example considering hes struggling badly this year.

I like Geno. Hes a good guy. Amazing talent. The only thing I question is whether he can make the jump.