Manning or Rivers?

[earthsci]

We should draft Manning. If he is gone, then Roethlisberger.

 

[Pariah]

Originally posted by earthsci
We should draft Manning. If he is gone, then Roethlisberger.

I'd be happy with either, and unless something unforseen happens to effect the draft order, we should most certainly be able to select one of them; we might even have a choice to make between them.

 

[Cbus cardsfan]

A franchise Qb is hard to pass on but has anyone seen Will Smith play lately?The guy is becoming unblockable.I don't think i've seen one player get so much better during the year.At the beginning of the year i would've said he's overrated and i liked Darrion SCott better.But Smith has just taken his game to a new level.If we don't take a QB the he's who i want.I know i've been on the Sean Taylor and Chris Gamble bandwagon but Smith is at a position of need and the real deal.This would be a great year to have multiple #1 picks.

 

[Renz]

I am hoping against hope that we draft Manning. To be honest, the other QB's scare me. It would be just our luck to draft the next Jim Druckenmiller.

 

[maddogkf]

Originally posted by Cbus cardsfan
A franchise Qb is hard to pass on but has anyone seen Will Smith play lately?

Last time I sw him, he was getting jiggy with it...

Party in the city where the heat is on
All night, on the beach till the break of dawn
Welcome to Miami
Bienvenidos la Miami

Bouncin in the club where the heat is on
All night, on the beach till the break of dawn
I'm goin to Miami
Welcome to Miami

 

[Harry]

Does the name Josh Heupel ring a bell for any of you Jason White proponents?

 

[8ndkorner]

hhhmmmmm.....

Three Dog Night had a song but let's see, how did that go?

Eli's coming and the Cards say......

Hopefully NOT "A broken Heart".

 

[Krangodnzr]

Originally posted by BACH
War Room gives him a 4.0 potential rating (10-scale), which means he should be a 4th - 5th round selection. Sorry...

Anyway, they give both Manning and Roetlisberger a 8.8 rating. By comparison the pre-draft ratings last year were: Palmer 8.8, Leftwich 8.7, Boller 8.4 & Grossmann 8.2.

I could care less what the war room says.

But I'm not advocating taking Rivers in the first round, I'm advocating drafting him later.

I've watched him for four years, four winning seasons now, and watched him singlehandedly almost defeat OSU and FSU this year while completing 72% of his passes.