I really dont understand this line of thought? The guy came back from his first knee surgery and was not the same the next season. After a full year to recoup he came back and was in the running for defensive MVP... He blows the other knee and he has a year where he isn't quite the same. That tells me that this year he could be inline to explode again.. He is only 25 flipping years old.... It is very common for player to take a full year to regain the magic.. Guy could be a terror this year...
Soon after he got the brace off after the first injury he was nearly back to his old self.
He went all last season and did not seem to improve at all. He seemed to0 slow to cover slot receivers and in my opinion has lost self confidence. If he can no longer cover the slot, he can no longer be a blue chip player.
I want to be wrong, but I saw no improvement over the course of last year, and quite frankly he was very bad, he did not seem like he wanted to make a tackle, he let the offensive player come to him.
If he does not have the disruptive play making attitude he was nicknamed for any longer, than he is just a slow undersized overpaid safety.