MJ's 53 Projection

Mitch

Crawled Through 5 FB Fields
Joined
Aug 10, 2005
Posts
13,405
Reaction score
2,982
Location
Wrentham, MA
Cardinal’s projected 53-man roster


Posted Saturday, August 1st 2015 @ 4pm


Quarterback (2)

In: Carson Palmer, Drew Stanton

Out: Logan Thomas, Chandler Harnish, Phillip Sims

Analysis: Its possible the Cardinals go into the season with two quarterbacks on the active roster, put Sims or Thomas on the practice squad.



Running back (5)

In: Andre Ellington, David Johnson, Stepfan Taylor, Kerwynn Williams, Robert Hughes

Out: Marion Grice, Paul Lasike

Analysis: Taylor entering his third year, like to see more production. Hughes will be the short yardage back. Williams could be in competition as the kick off returner.



Wide receiver (5)

In: Michael Floyd, Larry Fitzgerald, John Brown, Jaron Brown, Brittan Golden

Out: J.J. Nelson, Trevor Harman, Ryan Spadola, Jaxon Shipley, Damond Powell (NFI).

Analysis: Nelson has 4.29 speed, skinny but fast, he’ll need to be out Golden, who plays a role on special teams, could be an option for the practice squad unless they’re afraid he’ll get claimed off waivers. Shipley would be a good option for the practice squad.



Tight end (4)

In: Troy Niklas, Jermaine Gresham, Darren Fells, Ifeanyi Momah

Out: Gannon Sinclair, Gerald Christian, Ted Bolser.

Analysis: The plan for Gresham, he hasn’t had any contact for a while, have him on the PUP list for two to three weeks, bring him along slowly. Chris Cooley still could be an option if they don’t like the depth at the position. Christian is more of an H-back, and could end up on the practice squad.



Offensive linemen (9)



In: Jared Veldheer, Mike Iupati, A.Q. Shipley, Jonathan Cooper, Bobby Massie, D.J. Humphries, Earl Watford, Ted Larsen, Bradley Sowell

Out: Cameron Bradfield, Rob Crisp, John Fullington, Jon Halapio, Antoine McCain, Anthony Steen.

Analysis: Offensive line has some real depth with Humphries, Larsen, Watford & Sowell. Cardinals excited about Crisp upside, an undrafted in free agent along with Steen could be option for the practice squad.



Defensive linemen (8)

In: Calais Campbell, Frostee Rucker, Rodney Gunter, Cory Redding, Corey Peters, Ed Stinson, Matt Shaughnessy, Alameda Ta’amu.

Out: Josh Mauro, Xavier Williams

Analysis: Ta’amu goes into camp on the bubble, being healthy and in shape will go a long way. UDFA Williams will push Ta’amu for a roster spot, otherwise Williams is eligible for the practice squad. Mauro is sleeper to make the roster. Something to watch unfold in camp Shaughnessy moving from linebacker to defensive line.



Linebacker (9)

In: Alex Okafor, Lorenzo Alexander, Markus Golden, Kareem Martin, LaMarr Woodley, Sean Weatherspoon, Daryl Sharpton, Kevin Minter, Glenn Carson,

Out: Shaq Riddick, Kenny Demens, Alani Fua, Edwin Jackson, Andrae Kirk, Gabe Martin

Analysis: Woodley is on the bubble going into camp, low risk one-year deal. Riddick missed the entire off-season workouts, considering he’s a draft pick likely makes the roster but if he doesn’t show up in camp, more of practice squad player. Cardinals are intrigued by Fua (6’5, 234) & Gabe Martin.



Secondary (8)

In: Patrick Peterson, Jerraud Powers Justin Bethel, Tyrann Mathieu, Deone Bucannon, Rashad Johnson, Tony Jefferson, Jimmy Legree, Shaquille Richardson.

Out: Jimmy Legree, C.J. Roberts, Darren Woodard, Cariel Brooks, Damond Smith, Shaquille Richardson.

Analysis: Nine players in the secondary could change to 10 depending on the numbers game. Cardinals released Alfonzo Dennard a few before camp, he was on the bubble going into camp, 20 career starts in New England. Legree made a lot of plays in the off-season.



Specialist (3)

In: Mike Leach, Dave Zastudil, Chandler Catanzaro

Out: Drew Butler

Analysis: Zasty was healthy at the end of the season, Cardinals needed a roster spot, plus they missed him down the stretch including the post-season game.



As for the final 53-man roster going into the season, expect the Cardinals to continue to search the wavier wire for certain players & positions.

Here was my response on his blog:

MJ---Thanks for this roster projection! Please keep updating it! I've called the show a couple of times (Mitch from Foxborough)---it is great to talk Cardinals with you, as always.

I think you make a good move by keeping 2 QBs and 1 on PS---as you know, roster spots this year are going to be very valuable.

The selections that I have question marks with:

RB Stepfan Taylor---like you said, he needs to be more productive. But, I think BA might keep 4 RBs and 6 WRs so he doesn't risk losing J.J. Nelson off waivers. I think you are spot-on about Brittan Golden making it this year.

T Bradley Sowell---with D.J. Humphries being able to play LT and RT, and with Earl Watford being able to swing to RT if need be, Sowell is going to have a hard time making the roster. In addition, I think Anthony Steen is going to turn some heads and make a good case for the roster.

NT Alameda Ta'amu---BA has mentioned playing Ed Stinson some at NT behind starter Corey Peters. Gunter is a big body to help inside as well, if need be. I think you are correct about Josh Mauro being a sleeper---I think that not only will he make the roster, he will be active on game days on STs and as a rotation option at DE.

LBs Daryl Sharpton---I can't see him making it over Gabe Martin or Alani Fua, unless they or Weatherspoon are injured. Glenn Carson has a good chance, I agree with you---but if Martin and Fua have good camps, Carson might be headed back to the PS, if he clears waivers (very likely). I think Kenny Demens and Andrae Kirk might surprise. And I wonder about Lorenzo Alexander---I get the locker room leadership, but he's not been anywhere near the STs player he was in Washington. And he doesn't factor into the defensive rotations. He says he's healthy now, but it's been three years of sub-par play from him. If Zach Wagenmann or Shaq Riddick flashes edge rush pressure, Alexander might not be a lock.I like Wags---reminds me some of Clay Matthews.

CB Shaquille Richardson---you are lsiting 9 DBs instead of 8 and both Jimmy Legree and Richardson are listed as roster guys and waiver guys. You don't mention S Chris Clemons anywhere and I think that because he can play a role in sub packages at a cover safety, he's got a decent chance. It may come down to Legree and Clemons. Two possible sleepers: CB C.J. Roberts and S Harold Jones-Quartey.
 

juza76

ASFN Icon
Joined
Sep 5, 2009
Posts
13,809
Reaction score
9,631
Location
milan-italy
wr) zero chance golden will take jj nelson spot,golden is a good player just without pads
defensive line) shaughnessy is on the bubble considering the great depth we have
lb) demens.carson,alexander,minter,sharpton,all of them are very mediocre players and they shouldnt make the team.
i m pretty sure they will trade with some team for an ILB to pair with weatherspoon, i hope is kendricks.
alexander will make the 53 cause he is a good P.R guy and has a strong friendship with someone important in the organization.
legree is IN and OUT??

if we get a good ILB by trade i see just one weak spot on the defensive unit
rashard johnson
slow safety ,not phisycal,ok he is smart dude but he has many weakness
 
Last edited:
OP
OP
Mitch

Mitch

Crawled Through 5 FB Fields
Joined
Aug 10, 2005
Posts
13,405
Reaction score
2,982
Location
Wrentham, MA
wr) zero chance golden will take jj nelson spot,golden is a good player just without pads
defensive line) shaughnessy is on the bubble considering the great depth we have
lb) demens.carson,alexander,minter,sharpton,all of them are very mediocre players and they shouldnt make the team.
i m pretty sure they will trade with some team for an ILB to pair with weatherspoon, i hope is kendricks.
alexander will make the 53 cause he is a good P.R guy and has a strong friendship with someone important in the organization.
legree is IN and OUT??

if we get a good ILB by trade i see just one weak spot on the defensive unit
rashard johnson
slow safety ,not phisycal,ok he is smart dude but he has many weakness

Agree:

1. Nelson won't be cut---with his speed he'd be claimed off waivers.
2. All the ILB you name are below average, except for Alexander simply because of STs---your point about Alexander's good P.R. is valid.
3. If not a trade for an ILB---a waiver wire pickup is likely---or---does Larry Foote trade in his whistle for pads? Likely not at this point, but if Spoon is nagged by injuries, the playcaller on defense at this spot is too important and Foote was real good until he hit the Week 15 wall.

Respectfully Disagree:

1. Golden will prove himself. I think Nelson will be the KR and Golden the PR. There will be concerns about Nelson's being able to hold up physically, so they will likely limit his role as a rookie.
2. Shaughnessy is not on the bubble---he could be a trade chip---but only at the right price because the coaches really like his aggressiveness and run-stopping ability. Plus, his versatility is an asset.
3. Rashad Johnson proved last year how physical his game has become. He wore down late in the season, but he was garnering a little Pro Bowl consideration with his smart and aggressive play. What he lacks in speed he makes up for in instincts, anticipation and excellent pursuit angles.
 

Russ Smith

The Original Whizzinator
Supporting Member
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
88,292
Reaction score
39,925
He's got Shaq Richardson both in and out?

On Taylor, feel like I've been saying this for a decade, why would Hughes be the short yardage guy when based on actual games, Taylor is better at it than he is?

What Hughes has done well is be a very slight role player where every game or so we sneak in a carry or a pass out of the backfield when everyone is convinced he won't touch the ball, he gains some yards and everyone gets excited. Then his next carry he runs into the line gets 4 inches and everyone goes oh yeah that's why Taylor gets more short yardage carries.

He's not a great player but he plays his role well, he plays ST, he doesn't go down at first contact, he gets extra yards, he catches the balls thrown to him, and he's a very good blitz pickup guy.
 

GuernseyCard

ASFN Icon
Joined
Dec 29, 2012
Posts
10,123
Reaction score
5,681
Location
London UK
You have Legree both in and out at DB.

We have to find a gunner to replace Bethel given his added responsibilities at CB. (IMO)
 

kerouac9

Klowned by Keim
Joined
Feb 14, 2003
Posts
38,706
Reaction score
30,559
Location
Gilbert, AZ
He's got Shaq Richardson both in and out?

On Taylor, feel like I've been saying this for a decade, why would Hughes be the short yardage guy when based on actual games, Taylor is better at it than he is?

What Hughes has done well is be a very slight role player where every game or so we sneak in a carry or a pass out of the backfield when everyone is convinced he won't touch the ball, he gains some yards and everyone gets excited. Then his next carry he runs into the line gets 4 inches and everyone goes oh yeah that's why Taylor gets more short yardage carries.

He's not a great player but he plays his role well, he plays ST, he doesn't go down at first contact, he gets extra yards, he catches the balls thrown to him, and he's a very good blitz pickup guy.

The Joel Mackovicka conundrum.
 
OP
OP
Mitch

Mitch

Crawled Through 5 FB Fields
Joined
Aug 10, 2005
Posts
13,405
Reaction score
2,982
Location
Wrentham, MA
He's got Shaq Richardson both in and out?

On Taylor, feel like I've been saying this for a decade, why would Hughes be the short yardage guy when based on actual games, Taylor is better at it than he is?

What Hughes has done well is be a very slight role player where every game or so we sneak in a carry or a pass out of the backfield when everyone is convinced he won't touch the ball, he gains some yards and everyone gets excited. Then his next carry he runs into the line gets 4 inches and everyone goes oh yeah that's why Taylor gets more short yardage carries.

He's not a great player but he plays his role well, he plays ST, he doesn't go down at first contact, he gets extra yards, he catches the balls thrown to him, and he's a very good blitz pickup guy.

BA has said Hughes is going to be the short yardage guy. But---at least this time he will be lined up at tailback, not at FB and be able to get a running start. The one time he got a carry like that last year be plowed ahead for 5 yards up the right side G/T gap.

That said, I think you make a good case for Taylor. He's solid in everything he does. High effort guys are hard to cut. Plus, he was drafted by the BA&SK Cardinals.
 

cardpa

Have a Nice Day!
Joined
Mar 14, 2003
Posts
7,427
Reaction score
4,190
Location
Monroe NC
These are locks, all other remaining roster spots are up for grabs which should result in some very spirited competition in camp.

Quarterback (2)
Carson Palmer, Drew Stanton

Running back (3)
Andre Ellington, David Johnson, Stepfan Taylor


Wide receiver (4)
Michael Floyd, Larry Fitzgerald, John Brown, Jaron Brown


Tight end (3)
Troy Niklas, Jermaine Gresham, Darren Fells

Offensive linemen (6)
Jared Veldheer, Mike Iupati, A.Q. Shipley, Jonathan Cooper, Bobby Massie, D.J. Humphries

Defensive linemen (8)
Calais Campbell, Frostee Rucker, Rodney Gunter, Cory Redding, Corey Peters, Ed Stinson, Matt Shaughnessy, Alameda Ta’amu.

Linebacker (5)
Alex Okafor, Markus Golden, Kareem Martin, LaMarr Woodley, Sean Weatherspoon

Secondary (6)
Patrick Peterson, Jerraud Powers Justin Bethel, Tyrann Mathieu, Deone Bucannon, Rashad Johnson

Specialist (3)
Mike Leach, Dave Zastudil, Chandler Catanzaro

40 players I feel will definitely make the roster which leaves 13 spots open and to my count 18-20 real possible players with a chance of making it. Yes I know I left areas like LB thin but remember the names are the ones I feel will be on the roster unless they get injured seriously enough to go on IR or get into some type of trouble that the team would cut ties to them. The LB position is really fluid right now and it will be interesting to watch how that all plays out. I think DL is deep as any team in the league and here is where the likelihood of a trade would come out of because of the depth to bolster another position like LB. The secondary is another area a trade could be worked.

I remember not that long ago it was pretty easy to select 50 spots on this team with just 4-6 players vying for those last 3 spots. I think it speaks to the job that SK has done to get more competition into camp.
 

CFLredzoned

Hall of Famer
Joined
Sep 28, 2011
Posts
1,709
Reaction score
1,317
Location
Melbourne, FL
T Bradley Sowell---with D.J. Humphries being able to play LT and RT, and with Earl Watford being able to swing to RT if need be, Sowell is going to have a hard time making the roster. In addition, I think Anthony Steen is going to turn some heads and make a good case for the roster.

I thought the same thing when I saw Sowell over Steen. I think MJ's trying to keep it symetrical - 2 swing tackles (Humpries and Sowell) and 2 swing guards (Watford and Larsen) - vs only 1 swing tackle and 3 swing guards. But since Watford looks like he can play some tackle in a pinch, I don't think that's so important. Especially the way BA emphasizes keeping the best players on the roster - even if it doesn't make sense when you look at position distribution. If Steen outplays Sowell in preseason, I think he'll take the last OL spot.

It seems like every year with BASK, there's one position where they keep more players than what's considered normal. I think this year it's DL. I think they really learned their lesson when the DL ran out of gas last year. I think they'll keep one or two extra bodies there.

Ta'mu will be interesting because he's on a contract year and he seems like a guy that can be special when he's motivated. And I think he's motivated. Campbell even went out of his way to comment on how good he looked in the conditioning tests. So what do you do if he has a great year? Keep giving him one year contracts? Definitely keep Williams around if he shows anything.
 
OP
OP
Mitch

Mitch

Crawled Through 5 FB Fields
Joined
Aug 10, 2005
Posts
13,405
Reaction score
2,982
Location
Wrentham, MA
I thought the same thing when I saw Sowell over Steen. I think MJ's trying to keep it symetrical - 2 swing tackles (Humpries and Sowell) and 2 swing guards (Watford and Larsen) - vs only 1 swing tackle and 3 swing guards. But since Watford looks like he can play some tackle in a pinch, I don't think that's so important. Especially the way BA emphasizes keeping the best players on the roster - even if it doesn't make sense when you look at position distribution. If Steen outplays Sowell in preseason, I think he'll take the last OL spot.

It seems like every year with BASK, there's one position where they keep more players than what's considered normal. I think this year it's DL. I think they really learned their lesson when the DL ran out of gas last year. I think they'll keep one or two extra bodies there.

Ta'mu will be interesting because he's on a contract year and he seems like a guy that can be special when he's motivated. And I think he's motivated. Campbell even went out of his way to comment on how good he looked in the conditioning tests. So what do you do if he has a great year? Keep giving him one year contracts? Definitely keep Williams around if he shows anything.

I think you are absolutely right about keeping a stockpile of defensive linemen this year.
 

Russ Smith

The Original Whizzinator
Supporting Member
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
88,292
Reaction score
39,925
BA has said Hughes is going to be the short yardage guy. But---at least this time he will be lined up at tailback, not at FB and be able to get a running start. The one time he got a carry like that last year be plowed ahead for 5 yards up the right side G/T gap.

That said, I think you make a good case for Taylor. He's solid in everything he does. High effort guys are hard to cut. Plus, he was drafted by the BA&SK Cardinals.

Hughes to me is the classic all airport team guy to quote Dick Vitale, looks great walking through the airport, can't actually play.

He had 7 carries for 11 yards last year and one was the 5 yarder you mentioned so he got 6 yards on his other 6 carries. If I'm reading the splits right he didn't get a carry in the 2nd half of a game all last year, which means even BA doesn't trust him.

The splits say 42.9% first down percentage which I think is 3 of 7 which actually is much better than I would have guessed.

Taylor is one of those guys who has clear holes, lack of speed, sort of a tweener not big enough to be a FB, but he's also one of those guys who doesn't make mistakes that kill you. To my knowledge he has yet to fumble in an NFL game, he blocks well, he seems to understand the game. He's not going to go 78 yards for a TD, but he's not going to forget the play and not block the blitzer that gets your QB injured either.

My take on Hughes is that BA coached him with the Colts, and seems to think he's better than he's shown so my guess is maybe he looks better in practices than in real games.
 

BullheadCardFan

Go for it
Supporting Member
Joined
Sep 5, 2005
Posts
64,395
Reaction score
30,656
Location
Bullhead City, AZ
Ta'mu will be interesting because he's on a contract year and he seems like a guy that can be special when he's motivated. And I think he's motivated. Campbell even went out of his way to comment on how good he looked in the conditioning tests. So what do you do if he has a great year? Keep giving him one year contracts? Definitely keep Williams around if he shows anything.

Ta'Amu, in today's videos on blocking drills looked VG as a bull rusher, moving fast.
Like hearing this about Ta'amu. We need him to be healthy and at full strength.
 

Latest posts

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
556,595
Posts
5,437,516
Members
6,330
Latest member
Trainwreck20
Top