New punt returner

[Goldfield]

Antrell Rolle.

The all knowing Gambo said he has been begging to get a shot at it.


Rolle is very agile, I bet he would be pretty explosive back there.

 

[CaptTurbo]

He's the PR on madden

 

[JeffGollin]

Rolle is very agile, I bet he would be pretty explosive back there.
Question - After you've finally stopped the hemmoraging at the cornerback position, in part, by drafting a top rookie who's played like a veteran from Day #1 - do you risk everything by letting the rookie return punts?

Answer: Uhhhhhhh....No!

 

[MigratingOsprey]

I definitely think it's a bad move ... rolle has the ability to be a top 5 corner ... don't risk blowing out his legs on punt returns

santana moss is still hampered by injuries caused on the return game

sehorn had his over-rated career crippled when he got injured returning as well

not sure why you'd want a guy like that in line to get smacked around

 

[Billy Flynt]

He'd defintely save a roster spot and would probably be damn good at it. McAlister did it for years for the Ravens but the downside is the potential for injury.

 

[clif]

I think it would add some explosiveness. I would not wanting him being the full time returner, but maybe on occasion.

 

[CaptTurbo]

Imagine if you didnt want to lose Deion Sanders great cover skills by not allowing him to do returns.

 

[Chainthroer]

No way. We've finally have a CB with Pro-Bowl potential. Why jeopardize it!!

 

[Goldfield]

Cant playt football worried about injury.

The point is to win games if he helps I dont see why you dont do it. Unless we had someone else who could do a descent job. But as I search the roster I dont see that guy.

 

[LoyaltyisaCurse]

If they put him at PR I will be steaming mad!!!!

 

[clif]

just do it! Why worry about it? If he wants to do it go ahead

 

[Goldfield]

just do it! Why worry about it? If he wants to do it go ahead

Thats just it. He WANTS to do it.

 

[joko4]

It's not a bad move.
IT"S A STUPID ONE!

 

[Kel Varnsen]

Rolle is very agile, I bet he would be pretty explosive back there.
Question - After you've finally stopped the hemmoraging at the cornerback position, in part, by drafting a top rookie who's played like a veteran from Day #1 - do you risk everything by letting the rookie return punts?

Answer: Uhhhhhhh....No!

Did Rolle block any punts in college or am I thinking of someone else from Miami?

 

[brettman82]

Did Rolle block any punts in college or am I thinking of someone else from Miami?

That would be Ed Reed or Tremain Mack.

 

[Kel Varnsen]

That would be Ed Reed or Tremain Mack.

Thanks.

 

[Shane]

Absolutely not.

Deion Sanders is the rare exception to this rule. Even your best punt returners may average maybe 12 yards a return and get a TD maybe once or twice a year. Sorry but I would rather stick with a measley 5 yards average or so and no TD's then risk injury to a franchise caliber CB.

 

[dreamcastrocks]

I definitely think it's a bad move ... rolle has the ability to be a top 5 corner ... don't risk blowing out his legs on punt returns

santana moss is still hampered by injuries caused on the return game

sehorn had his over-rated career crippled when he got injured returning as well

not sure why you'd want a guy like that in line to get smacked around

Couldn't have said it better myself!

 

[CardLogic]

Absolutely not.

Deion Sanders is the rare exception to this rule. Even your best punt returners may average maybe 12 yards a return and get a TD maybe once or twice a year. Sorry but I would rather stick with a measley 5 yards average or so and no TD's then risk injury to a franchise caliber CB.

Well put!

Too much risk vs. return

 

[Kel Varnsen]

Well put!

Too much risk vs. return

 

[Russ Smith]

Antrell Rolle.

The all knowing Gambo said he has been begging to get a shot at it.


Rolle is very agile, I bet he would be pretty explosive back there.

Did the world learn nothing from Jim Fassel letting Jason Sehorn return kickoffs?