OT: Geno Smith to the Raiders

[TheCardFan]

Geno is better than Kyler. He's just older.

Kyler, higher ceiling? He's won more playoff games than Geno?

What are you basing your logic on that Geno is better?

 

[Totally_Red]

What are you basing your logic on that Geno is better?

Don't know if he's better but I think Kyler would bring more than a third round pick even with his huge contract.

 

[Stout]

What are you basing your logic on that Geno is better?

See earlier in the thread.

 

[BACH]

Kyler, higher ceiling? He's won more playoff games than Geno?

IMO Kyler has had more games playing at elite level and that is what I’m basing my opinion on.

 

[Cheesebeef]

IMO Kyler has had more games playing at elite level and that is what I’m basing my opinion on.

What do you think Kyler could fetch in the trade market?

 

[BACH]

What do you think Kyler could fetch in the trade market?

Hard to estimate. My guess right now. A low 1st. More than a high 3rd for Geno due to he’s younger, IMO better and doesn’t need a new contract after this season

 

[Cheesebeef]

Hard to estimate. My guess right now. A low 1st. More than a high 3rd for Geno due to he’s younger, IMO better and doesn’t need a new contract after this season

Agree to disagree.

 

[Garthshort]

Their top two WRs are better than our best one. Another trash take.

Better than Trey McBride? I don't think so.

 

[602 Native]

Uhhh, as a QB, "tread" doesn't count like it may for a RB. Simple enough, with age, arm strength starts to suffer. No matter how you slice it, regardless of starts or not, Kyler has way more tread left as a passer than Geno.

Now, Kyler's elite rushing might fall off in a couple of years here, which is going to be a huge issue. He's not a good enough passer to make up for that.


Wait, do you actually think Herbert isn't miles better than K1? I would make that swap in the blink of an eye AND give up assets.

I don't know that Geno and Darnold are much better than Kyler, but the fact we're even having the discussion is depressing.

“Miles better”

No Mahomes, Burrows, and Jackson are miles better.

Herbert throws the prettiest incompletions you will ever see while gagging in big games.

He is no different than K1.

 

[slanidrac16]

I am just so stoked that we got Geno out of the division, he is such an underrated QB. The Seahawks made a fantastic OC hire, but I don't think they will be able to fix their OL in one off season. Bet the over on our sack total if they sign Darnold.

We really need Seattle to faulter after their decision to get rid of Pete Carrol, and I think it's coming, especially if they lose DK as well.

They are deciding they are tired of being "good" without playoff success, so they're blowing things up. That has significant risk. If their next QB doesnt work out they could be in the basement for a long time.

If we go out and sign Hendrickson and Reddick it won’t matter who their qb is.

 

[BirdGangThing]

we don't have to worry about the chickens wanting kyler tho lol that's for sure

 

[kerouac9]

Better than Trey McBride? I don't think so.

Yes. No question.

 

[kerouac9]

“Miles better”

No Mahomes, Burrows, and Jackson are miles better.

Herbert throws the prettiest incompletions you will ever see while gagging in big games.

He is no different than K1.

The Chargers are another poverty organization but Herbert has found a way to be objectively better than Kyler in almost every category and more successful.