point guard ranking

scotsman13

Registered User
Joined
Oct 21, 2002
Posts
1,418
Reaction score
0
Location
salt lake city
http://www.sportsline.com/nba/story/6668313

There are two kinds of point guards in the NBA, says Joe Dumars, president of the Detroit Pistons and a former NBA All-Star.

Not quite as simple as good and bad, although there are plenty of both. It's a little more complicated than that.


PHOTOS: « PREV | NEXT »

Stephon Marbury emerged last season as a leader for the Suns. (Getty Images)
There are those who see the floor and those who see the basket, with a rare minority of players who happen to do both. Dumars had the good fortune of playing next to Hall of Fame point guard Isiah Thomas but also was the backup point when Thomas left the game.

So Joe knows point guards.

"When Isiah was in the game, I would run the creases and look for an open space for my shots," Dumars said. "When he left the game, I had to pick my head up, see the floor and create for the other four guys. It's a much tougher job. These days there are two different kinds. There are the ones like Jason Kidd and the ones like Stephon Marbury."

Coincidentally, they were traded for each other two seasons ago, and what once looked like a lopsided deal, with two-time Eastern Conference champion New Jersey getting Kidd from Phoenix, might turn into a wash. Marbury, four years younger, came on incredibly the second half of last season and into the playoffs until a shoulder injury slowed him and the Suns.

But they are distinct. Kidd is the prototype playmaker. He'll push it whenever possible, but he is forever aware of who is going where and where his teammates like their shots. Marbury tends to look for his shot first unless someone else is wide open.

Gary Payton, like Thomas, has the unique ability to be a consistent scorer and a distributor for his teammates. Payton and Oscar Robertson are the only players in history to average at least 20 points and eight assists five years in a row.

"It's rare that you see anybody like that anymore," Dumars said. "But both Jason and Stephon dominate the game in their own way."

There are others. Actually, Nick Van Exel, traded from Dallas to Golden State, is eminently capable of doing both, although he can be very erratic when he gets in a shooting mode. Still, his toughness is unquestioned.

Positional Rankings
Date Position
Aug. 29 Power Forwards
Sep. 3 Small Forwards
Sep. 11 Centers
Sep. 17 Shooting Guards
Sep. 24 Point Guards
Oct. 1 Top 50 players
Houston's Steve Francis is cut from the Marbury mold -- drive to the rim for the score or the foul, otherwise dish it to the spot-up shooter. Baron Davis of the New Orleans Hornets is the same kind of player, as is Dumars' point guard with the Pistons, Chauncey Billups, and Washington's big free-agent signing, Gilbert Arenas.

In Dallas, Steve Nash is more discriminating with his shots. The same goes for Sacramento point guard Mike Bibby. And the one pure point guard in the draft, Texas' T.J. Ford, is headed to Milwaukee after just two seasons in college basketball. He has been compared to Thomas, only shorter and certainly without the kind of pure scoring skills Thomas had. Still, Dumars likes Ford a lot, with his uncanny quickness and ability to find the open man.

"It's going to be hard because I'm going to be going against a different guy almost every night and they're all great players," Ford said. "But I'll learn. There is so much talent in the NBA, every night will be a different experience and make me a better player."

Points well taken.

1. Jason Kidd, New Jersey Nets: With two consecutive East titles in his pocket, he's setting the pace. But his ankle problems could become chronic now that he has hit 30. Nonetheless, he's the best for now.

2. Stephon Marbury, Phoenix Suns: There is no better point off the dribble than Marbury, who seems to growing as a leader. He's stronger and finally figuring out what it takes to be a star instead of posing as one.

3. Gary Payton, Los Angeles Lakers: This is a slight drop for The Glove, but he's 35. Nevertheless, once he gets a sniff of championship fever with the Lakers, he will be relentless on both ends. Guaranteed.

4. Steve Francis, Houston Rockets: A younger, perhaps stronger version of Marbury, he hasn't figured out yet what it means to make his teammates better. But for pure talent, the guy is off the charts.

5. Baron Davis, New Orleans Hornets: Coming off back and knee problems, Davis could be third best on this list, or he could drop to 10th. This is a pivotal year for him to prove he belongs among the best.

6. Steve Nash, Dallas Mavericks: It will be interesting to see how far Nash can take the team this season without Nick Van Exel to clean up after him. He's a talented leader and a relentless player, that's for sure.

7. Mike Bibby, Sacramento Kings: He's coming off a rough season marred by a broken foot that never let him get back into the swing of things. A great shooter and distributor, he'll prove his worth this season.

8. Nick Van Exel, Golden State Warriors: Warriors fans may discover him to be a lefty version of Tim Hardaway if he's into it. He's as quick and slick with the ball and the shot as any point guard in the game -- but erratic.

9. Chauncey Billups, Detroit Pistons: He was on his way to being the story of the East until a sprained ankle ended his and the Pistons' hopes of beating the Nets in the conference finals. He's on the brink of being special.

10. Gilbert Arenas, Washington Wizards: One of the few big free-agent signings this summer, Arenas promised a trip to the playoffs for the wayward Wizards. Gee, you'd hate to see empty promises start this soon.

Also under consideration: Andre Miller, Denver Nuggets; Sam Cassell, Minnesota Timberwolves; Tony Parker, San Antonio Spurs; Jason Williams, Memphis Grizzlies; Jason Terry, Atlanta Hawks; Brent Barry, Seattle SuperSonics; Eric Snow, Philadelphia 76ers.
 

elindholm

edited for content
Joined
Sep 14, 2002
Posts
27,541
Reaction score
9,821
Location
L.A. area
Payton and Oscar Robertson are the only players in history to average at least 20 points and eight assists five years in a row.

I'm sure that Marbury will join that list. The only reason he isn't on it already is that he averaged a mere 7.6 assists in '00-'01. Otherwise he would qualify over the five seasons '98-'03.
 

slinslin

Welcome to Amareca
Joined
Jun 28, 2002
Posts
16,855
Reaction score
562
Location
Hannover - Germany
Marbury has a career average of 20+ and 8+ the only other player with those averages is Oscar Robertson.

And Francis is a younger version of Marbury?

Francis is only 1 day younger.
 

thegrahamcrackr

Registered User
Joined
Nov 19, 2002
Posts
6,168
Reaction score
0
Location
Scottsdale, Az
That is a biased statement. Marbury and big O are the only 2 players to average over 20 and 8 for their career. Who cares about 5 straight years. Marbury's career has been long enough at this point for his averages to hold enough weight.

I sent the writer an email, here is a copy.



I liked the article, except for one line.

Gary Payton and Oscar Robertson are the only point guards to have averaged more than 20 points and 8 assists for five consecutive seasons.


That is true, but you are ignoring a big fact.

Stephon Marbury and Oscar Robertson are the ONLY 2 players in NBA history to average more than 20 points and 8 assits a game for their CAREER. Although Marbury's career is still rather young (but old enough for that to be a viable statement) you should have made that point along with or instead of the Gary Payton comment.

This calling Stephon a shoot first point guard is what helped him earn that selfish label in the beginning. At just 25 years of age, he joins one of the greatest point guards of all time in the record books, in a point guard discussion, that has to be mentioned.

Andy
 

thegrahamcrackr

Registered User
Joined
Nov 19, 2002
Posts
6,168
Reaction score
0
Location
Scottsdale, Az
Originally posted by slinslin

And Francis is a younger version of Marbury?

Francis is only 1 day younger.

I didn't even think of that. It is funny how the media makes up bogus lines in order to support the players they like best.
 

Chaplin

Better off silent
Joined
May 13, 2002
Posts
46,462
Reaction score
16,990
Location
Round Rock, TX
While Mike Kahn isn't as bad as a lot of NBA writers out there, he consistently messes up little facts, as evidenced by all the things that have come up in this thread.
 

SunsTzu

ASFN Lifer
Joined
Aug 28, 2003
Posts
4,866
Reaction score
1,674
After reading the article i doubt this guy even watched Marbury play at all last year. He says Marbury looks to score and only hits a team mate if they are wide open. That is complete BS Marbury is IMO the best interior passer in the league. He is great at dirving and dishing off to his big men in heavy traffic.
 

JJ Slim

Registered
Joined
Jun 16, 2002
Posts
322
Reaction score
0
Originally posted by SunsTzu
That is complete BS Marbury is IMO the best interior passer in the league. He is great at dirving and dishing off to his big men in heavy traffic.

Actually I would have to say that Jason Kidd is the best inside passer. Some of the stuff he does is just amazing.

That being said I would rather have Steph on the Suns any day of the week.
 

SunsTzu

ASFN Lifer
Joined
Aug 28, 2003
Posts
4,866
Reaction score
1,674
Originally posted by JJ Slim
Actually I would have to say that Jason Kidd is the best inside passer. Some of the stuff he does is just amazing.

That being said I would rather have Steph on the Suns any day of the week.


I think Kidd's a better passer, but mainly on the break. However when it comes to passing in traffic Marbury gets the nod IMO.
 

SirStefan32

Krycek, Alex Krycek
Joined
Oct 15, 2002
Posts
18,497
Reaction score
4,913
Location
Harrisburg, PA
I am sick about hearing how "Marbury tends to look for his shot first unless someone else is wide open."

Am I the only one who thinks that Marbury needs to be MORE assertive?

:confused:
 

Joe Mama

Moderator
Supporting Member
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
9,501
Reaction score
964
Location
Gilbert, AZ
Originally posted by JJ Slim
Actually I would have to say that Jason Kidd is the best inside passer. Some of the stuff he does is just amazing.

That being said I would rather have Steph on the Suns any day of the week.

I don't think either one of them are really very good interior passers. When they start to penetrate both of those guys are more comfortable passing to spot shooters instead of the big men around the basket.

I've never seen any point guard better at feeding big men for easy shots than Kevin Johnson. In fact do you remember when he came back to help when Jason Kidd hurt his ankle? Corie Blount hardly knew what to do with a pass for an open layup or slamdunk. All of Jason Kidd' assists came from open court plays and passes for outside shots.

Now in New Jersey's offense Jason Kidd gets quite a few assists on slamdunk and layups in the half-court offense. However those assists are rarely the result of Jason Kidd penetrating towards the basket.


Joe Mama
 

SunsTzu

ASFN Lifer
Joined
Aug 28, 2003
Posts
4,866
Reaction score
1,674
Originally posted by Joe Mama
I don't think either one of them are really very good interior passers. When they start to penetrate both of those guys are more comfortable passing to spot shooters instead of the big men around the basket.


I disagree, Marbury always trys to get it to the big men when he drives inside. Towards the end of the 01-02 season he was feeding Big Jake and making him look good. Also last year he was a large part of Amare's success, being able to get him the ball around the hoop.
 

hcsilla

ASFN Lifer
Joined
Sep 22, 2002
Posts
3,391
Reaction score
218
Location
Budapest,Hungary
Originally posted by Joe Mama
I don't think either one of them are really very good interior passers. When they start to penetrate both of those guys are more comfortable passing to spot shooters instead of the big men around the basket.

Joe Mama
I diagree too.

Marbury is significantly better than Kidd in this area.
Amare, Voskuhl and Outlaw got a lot of easy baskets after Marbury's penetration or after their pick-and-rolls.
 

elindholm

edited for content
Joined
Sep 14, 2002
Posts
27,541
Reaction score
9,821
Location
L.A. area
One reason for this is that Kidd isn't much of a threat to finish on his own when he drives, so the defense isn't as likely to collapse. When Marbury penetrates, the defense has to take notice.
 

SunsTzu

ASFN Lifer
Joined
Aug 28, 2003
Posts
4,866
Reaction score
1,674
Originally posted by elindholm
One reason for this is that Kidd isn't much of a threat to finish on his own when he drives, so the defense isn't as likely to collapse. When Marbury penetrates, the defense has to take notice.


Exactly.
 

Joe Mama

Moderator
Supporting Member
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
9,501
Reaction score
964
Location
Gilbert, AZ
OK, Marbury might be better than Jason Kidd at the interior passing, but I still don't think he is a great interior passer. Everybody always talks about when he was getting Big Jake the easy baskets at the end of the 2001-02 season. But that's the only time that happened consistently. Where was that last season?

The majority of Marbury's assists come from his penetrating and kicking the ball out to spot up shooters.

BTW, I think Marbury is going to average over nine assists this season.


Joe Mama
 

SunsTzu

ASFN Lifer
Joined
Aug 28, 2003
Posts
4,866
Reaction score
1,674
Originally posted by Joe Mama
OK, Marbury might be better than Jason Kidd at the interior passing, but I still don't think he is a great interior passer. Everybody always talks about when he was getting Big Jake the easy baskets at the end of the 2001-02 season. But that's the only time that happened consistently. Where was that last season?


Frank wasn't playin Big Jake much when he got back the IR, Marbury was still gettin the ball to Amare, Bo, Little Jake around the basket.

BTW if you dont think Marbury is a good interior passer who do you think is?
 

elindholm

edited for content
Joined
Sep 14, 2002
Posts
27,541
Reaction score
9,821
Location
L.A. area
BTW if you dont think Marbury is a good interior passer who do you think is?

Among point guards, probably Payton.

Among frontcourt players, certainly Webber, Malone, Divac, Garnett, etc...

Among wing players, Bryant and Pippen for sure, and others that I can't think of right now.
 

PhiLLmattiC

Last of a Dying Breed
Joined
Oct 14, 2002
Posts
290
Reaction score
0
Location
New York
Bryant passes? Not to Shaq at least. What is an interior passer exactly? I'm getting different ideas from some of the posts. Some people reffer to it as driving the lane drawing the defender and finding the open man. Others reffer to it as a player passing it into the post or interior finding the open man. As far as driving the lane I'd say that Marbury may be the best at that. Even Iverson, a shooting guard, is pretty good at that. However when it comes to passing it into the post, I wouldn't even say marbury is the best on the team at doing that. I think hardaway is much better at it and he's a shooting guard. I don't even think i've seen Marbury look into the post unless its hardaway sealing off a smaller guard and that rarely happens.
 

SunsTzu

ASFN Lifer
Joined
Aug 28, 2003
Posts
4,866
Reaction score
1,674
Originally posted by PhiLLmattiC
Bryant passes? Not to Shaq at least. What is an interior passer exactly? I'm getting different ideas from some of the posts. Some people reffer to it as driving the lane drawing the defender and finding the open man. Others reffer to it as a player passing it into the post or interior finding the open man. As far as driving the lane I'd say that Marbury may be the best at that. Even Iverson, a shooting guard, is pretty good at that. However when it comes to passing it into the post, I wouldn't even say marbury is the best on the team at doing that. I think hardaway is much better at it and he's a shooting guard. I don't even think i've seen Marbury look into the post unless its hardaway sealing off a smaller guard and that rarely happens.


I consider interior passing as passing while around the hoop to another player near the hoop in heavy traffic, and that is what Marbury excells at. I'd consider passing into the post as an entry pass, which as you stated Penny is much better at.
 

jimjames1

Rookie
BANNED BY MODERATORS
Joined
Aug 7, 2003
Posts
57
Reaction score
0
There are a lot of little things I disagree with that have been posted in this thread, so I'm going to attack them all systematically.

I disagree, Marbury always trys to get it to the big men when he drives inside. Towards the end of the 01-02 season he was feeding Big Jake and making him look good. Also last year he was a large part of Amare's success, being able to get him the ball around the hoop.

Penny is better than Marbury at simply getting players the ball where it is easy for them to score. Because Marbury is so quick, oftentimes the defense gets so out of position when he drives the lane that if he dumps it off to anybody, they are pretty much wide open. But Penny can get a guy wide open down low in other ways than just driving. He was much better during the season at getting Amare and Voskhul very easy buckets passing into the post and getting guys open under the basket downlow from other areas of the court. He may not be the quickest guy in the NBA physically, but he is probably one of the quickest mentally as far as simply recognizing defensive switches and scrambling. Marbury is good at driving and passing, be it to a guy in the interior or on the perimeter, but Penny is good at simply finding the open man, wherever it may be.

Altogether, I think they basically just make a great backcourt tandem.

Bryant passes? Not to Shaq at least.

I disagree completely. Bryant is a very good passer. During the first half of last season, he was averaging over 7 assists to go with his 30 points and 7 boards. I'm not sure there's an easier guy in the world to pass to downlow than Shaquille O'neal, but nevertheless saying he doesn't get Shaq dunks is a completely erroneous statement.

Marbury is significantly better than Kidd in this area.

How do you think Kenyon Martin scored downlow? 2 years ago, how do you think Todd Maculugh scored downlow? How do you think guys like Aaron Williams and Jason Collins score downlow? (or is it Jared?) With the exception of Martin, these guys don't really have moves at all what-so-ever (or in Macullugh's case, properly functioning nerves and especially not moves), but they still got a lot of dunks. And even Martin is no ballerina in the low post. Maybe Marbury is better, but not significantly.

I've never seen any point guard better at feeding big men for easy shots than Kevin Johnson. In fact do you remember when he came back to help when Jason Kidd hurt his ankle? Corie Blount hardly knew what to do with a pass for an open layup or slamdunk.

I noticed that. My God did I ever notice that! I wasn't a Suns fan when KJ was in his prime, and I didn't even become one until after he retired for the first time, but I was sold on Kevin Johnson in that month that he played in 2000. I can only imagine the kind of interior passer he must of been in his hey-day. Of course, I also noticed that Corie Blount was surprisingly bad at dunking a basketball for a 6 foot 10 human being. He consistently missed dunks when KJ fed him, or got fouled, couldn't convert the shot, and missed at least 1 of 2 free throws. But I digress....

Am I the only one who thinks that Marbury needs to be MORE assertive?

"Only" is a very strong word. I'm fairly certain that there's another humanoid lifeform in the universe that agrees with you wholeheartedly on this issue, but I am afraid I am not one of them. When Marbury is on, it's tough to stop him with a 1,000 men in a Phalanx formation, in which case I say Stephon do your thing and do it as often as you can. But the problem occurs when he is not completely on fire, he can become too assertive and he starts to dominate the ball, pounding the shot clock lower and lower. Because Marbury is so good, often he can overcome this problem by dribbling and dribbling, then finally seeing an opening, or a hint of an opening, or a hint of a hint of a possible opening, and make a play of it, but his dominating the ball leads to the 4 other Suns players to stand around the perimeter and wait for something to happen. Watching Marbury dribble around for 17 seconds to drive and kick the ball to Marion in the corner doing his best Reggie Miller impression from behind the arc with the shot clock winding down is a lot like jumping out of a plane with a parachute strapped to your balls - you might be able to survive by pulling the shoot cord, but is it really worth it?
 

thegrahamcrackr

Registered User
Joined
Nov 19, 2002
Posts
6,168
Reaction score
0
Location
Scottsdale, Az
Originally posted by jimjames1
Watching Marbury dribble around for 17 seconds to drive and kick the ball to Marion in the corner doing his best Reggie Miller impression from behind the arc with the shot clock winding down is a lot like jumping out of a plane with a parachute strapped to your balls - you might be able to survive by pulling the shoot cord, but is it really worth it?


That might be the quote of the summer.........
 
Top