Possible trade with Giants

[oaken1]

They aren't giving up a one. They probably don't give up the second two. The real question is do you give up MHJ for Odunze and a two+. We ain't getting a one unless we trade back to 11, 12, or 13. No way I do that.

Never know what the QB premium will bring... A simple," I gotta go, got Atlanta on another line...nice try though!"
Suddenly a second and fifth jumps to a first.
Biggest factor is how the giants feel about rolling out Danny dimes one more time

 

[Totally_Red]

First round, picks have been given to move up one spot before…. ironically by the Giants even to get Jags pick right before them.

For a one they can probably get NE to bite. Don't think they are that desperate.

 

[Phrazbit]

How is there any scenario where we're picking at 4 and Harrison AND one of the top 3 QBs are still on the board?

If Harrison is gone, I'd take that deal in a heart beat.

 

[bg7brd]

The Chargers might take MHJ at 5, but I don't believe they will stay at 5 to take Alt if they can help it.

I think the Chargers might want to trade back a bit. Keep an eye on the Bears moving up to 5 for Odunze / Nabers

 

[oaken1]

How is there any scenario where we're picking at 4 and Harrison AND one of the top 3 QBs are still on the board?

If Harrison is gone, I'd take that deal in a heart beat.

Because rumour has it there may now be 4 QB's

 

[Chopper0080]

what if the Giants pay the QB premium and give up next years first to move up two slots?
chargers would almost certainly grab Harrison....would you be satisfied with Odunze and an extra first next year?

There is a price for almost everything. That would be interesting.

 

[Phrazbit]

Because rumour has it there may now be 4 QB's

I'd bet dollars to donuts that JJ McCarthy will still be on the board at pick 5...

of the 2nd round.

 

[oaken1]

I'd bet dollars to donuts that JJ McCarthy will still be on the board at pick 5...

of the 2nd round.

I generally agree. But teams have made crazy trades to get a guy everyone thought they could wait for before. If a GM has fallen in love with a player it doesn't matter where the rest of the world has him ranked....hell, look what the niners gave up to go get Lance

 

[kerouac9]

I generally agree. But teams have made crazy trades to get a guy everyone thought they could wait for before. If a GM has fallen in love with a player it doesn't matter where the rest of the world has him ranked....hell, look what the niners gave up to go get Lance

Post powered by Hopium

 

[oaken1]

Post powered by Hopium

Hopium, haterade, we all have our drink of choice....just so long as it's chilled

 

[Lomax to Green 84]

How about telling the Giants that you want pick #6 and Dexter Lawrence instead of future draft picks.

 

[Denny Green Fan]

Never know what the QB premium will bring... A simple," I gotta go, got Atlanta on another line...nice try though!"
Suddenly a second and fifth jumps to a first.
Biggest factor is how the giants feel about rolling out Danny dimes one more time

Cards on the clock….giants gm to monti “we want this pick” “we will give you 6 and one of our second rounders” monti.. “call me back when u give us 2 second rounders”

 

[AZCB34]

Do you have some sort of analytical evidence of this that supports such a wild claim?

Of course not

 

[AZCB34]

I’d take that too…. Then take Nabers or Odunze and still try and trade up from #27

Odunze…Odunze…Odunze

 

[AZCB34]

Yep.

Jarvin Garrison would still be a top ten player, but right now Odunze would be higher ranked.

We haven't even really discussed how, not only did Harrison skip the workouts, he also skipped the media portion. Players that do that just don't understand that's a slight not only to the media, but also to the fans that ultimately pay to see them play.

I guess it's better than Nabers who really didn't come off as a guy I want on my team.

Of the top 3 WRs, I firmly believe Nabers has, by far, the biggest bust percentage and it isn’t close.

 

[Krangodnzr]

Of the top 3 WRs, I firmly believe Nabers has, by far, the biggest bust percentage and it isn’t close.

Agreed. He doesn't come off as very intelligent and you don't really see how well he deals with press coverage on film at all.

 

[WisconsinCard]

The only reason the giants would want to trade up is if they have Intel that another team or teams are trying to get ahead of them. I say this because they would know that the cards and chargers are not taking QBs.

 

[Denny Green Fan]

no such thing as poll fatigue

Here is the scenario: the New York Football Giants want to draft their QBOTF and offer one of their twos (39 or 47) this year and their second rounder next year to go from 6 to 4.
This likely means we miss out on MHJ, but probably get our choice of Odunze, Nabers or Joe Alt. Do YOU pull the trigger?

For 2 second rounders yes!!! For one second no way not with Marvin there

 

[daves]

Here is the scenario: the New York Football Giants want to draft their QBOTF and offer one of their twos (39 or 47) this year and their second rounder next year to go from 6 to 4.

Well the Giants' #39 pick now belongs to Carolina.

 

[BACH]

Giants traded #39, so only #47 is available. Makes it easy. Take MHJ if he is there. If he is not - absolute go. Draft Alt Or one of the Two other WR and Pick up a 2nd that Can be used as potential leverage to move in the draft.
#27&#47 gets into the 15-20 range
#35&#47 gets into the 19-24 range

 

[Denny Green Fan]

Odunze…Odunze…Odunze

I have a hunch the patriots will take Marvin if daniels goes to Washington. Then they try for nix or penix later.

 

[Fitz4Ever]

I have a hunch the patriots will take Marvin if daniels goes to Washington. Then they try for nix or penix later.

I have a hunch they might if Maye is gone. Daniels is going to be freakin terrible. There is no way the Patriots can think hes going to be a franchise QB. Now Washington...that dumpster fire of a team...Im sure they think Daniels is awesome.

I think for the Pats its either Maye or MHJ

 

[ajcardfan]

I have a hunch they might if Maye is gone. Daniels is going to be freakin terrible. There is no way the Patriots can think hes going to be a franchise QB. Now Washington...that dumpster fire of a team...Im sure they think Daniels is awesome.

I think for the Pats its either Maye or MHJ

Mayes is safer. Herbert Light, just good enough to be mediocre and a decade long tease. Daniels has a lot more capacity for "boom" than Mayes, but he is also more likely to bust. I thought AR going high last year was total bluff, but he did. Daniels is far more talented and polished than Richardson was.

JMO