Projection of First 50 picks; Cardinal Mock

DaisyCutter

Hall of Famer
BANNED BY MODERATORS
Joined
Nov 26, 2007
Posts
1,718
Reaction score
0
Here's hopefully my last mock draft of the first round through when the Cards pick in the second. One thing that jumped out at me is that the Falcons are in an incredible position to improve their team.
 
OP
OP
D

DaisyCutter

Hall of Famer
BANNED BY MODERATORS
Joined
Nov 26, 2007
Posts
1,718
Reaction score
0
First-round projection:

1. Miami DolphinsJake Long, OT, Michigan. Drafting Long protects three positions for the Dolphins: OT, QB John Beck, and RB Ronnie Brown.

2. St. Louis RamsGlenn Dorsey, DT, LSU. All the hubbub about Dorsey is for naught. Like Long helping the Fins at multiple positions, Dorsey will improve the play of Tinoisomoa, Witherspoon, and ’07 first-rounder Adam Carricker

3. Atlanta FalconsMatt Ryan, QB, BostonCollege. The Falcons were hoping that Dorsey would fall to them. If he doesn’t, they may try and trade out of this position. They don’t, so they take their next Franchise Quarterback some 20 picks before they intended to.

4. Oakland Raiders – Chris Long, DE/OLB, Virginia. The only thing that Raiders owner Al Davis loves more than speed is former Raiders. He names clauses in rookie contracts after former players. Long will provide discipline, leadership, and character to the Silver and Black.

5. Kansas City ChiefsBranden Albert, OL, Virginia. Cavaliers go off the board back-to-back. GM Carl Peterson takes a chance on greatness here, knowing that Albert can perform at right tackle or left guard if the experiment at left tackle doesn’t work out.

6. New York JetsDarren McFadden, RB, Arkansas. This is too good a value for the Jets to pass on. McFadden will add much-needed star power to the New York Jets, and will provide them with a multi-dimensional playmaker in the offensive backfield.

7. New England Patriots (through San Francisco 49ers)Sedrick Ellis, DT, Southern Cal. New England will take a below-market offer to trade out of this pick. It’s very likely that the Saints would trade into this spot to get ahead of the Bengals, or the Bengals would trade in to make sure they get the character player at the position they need. The Patriots pick up an insurance policy on another disappointing season from Richard Seymour.

8. Baltimore Ravens – Vernon Gholston, DE/OLB, Ohio State. Ozzie Newsome cannot believe his luck. They have concerns at QB and along the offensive line, but it is the defense that makes the Ravens run. They cannot pass on this player.

9. Cincinnati Bengals – Keith Rivers, LB, Southern Cal.The Bengal defense is in dire need of leadership and playmaking ability. Rivers will provide both. They desperately wanted to pick up a defensive tackle at this position, but they’re going to settle for an above-average player who will be an examplar in the locker room.

10. New Orleans Saints – Leodis McKelvin, CB, Troy. The Saints, surprisingly, go into the draft with very few glaring needs. They hoped to get Ellis or Rivers, but they’ll settle for a very good cornerback to develop.

11. Buffalo Bills – Mike Jenkins, CB, South Flroida. The Bills are very interested in trading out of this position. Jenkins will not make anyone forget about Nate Clements early, but will give them an experienced player on the outside of their defense.

12. Denver Broncos – Ryan Clady, OT, Boise State. Clady is not going to help the Broncos with their biggest problem (stopping the run), but he will help solidify their offensive line. Clady is ideal for the zone-blocking schemes the Broncos prefer.

13. Carolina PanthersDerrick Harvey, DE, Florida. With the QB off the board for now, John Fox gets a player that he thinks will help him keep his job. The Panthers are also interested in OT Chris Williams here, but he is a bit of a project for a coach that’s trying to keep his job.

14. Chicago BearsChris Williams, OT, Vanderbilt. General Manager Jerry Angelo calls Cedric Benson (who is crying at home) and says that this year really is his last chance. Williams will improve the Bears at two positions, allowing Tackle Jon Tait to perform at a Pro Bowl level at right tackle next season.

15. Detroit Lions – Rashard Mendenhall, RB, Illinois. The Lions featured the 9th-best passing game in the NFL last season, but the 31st-ranked rushing offense. The Lions’ new OC wants to establish a more power-oriented rushing attack. Mendenhall will provide all the physicality the Lions can ask for.

16. Arizona CardinalsDominique Rogers-Cromartie, CB, Tennessee St.. Jeff Otah’s still on the board, but the Cards already have a right tackle. Jonathan Stewart is tempting here, but the Cards understand that they’re not going to use a Top 20 pick on a player whose talents they’ll underutilize (Whis’s offense does not pass the ball to RBs). They’ve backed themselves into a corner with this pick, which they’re not going to be disappointed with. If you believe in your coaching staff, you are not afraid to select players with a high ceiling like Cromartie.

17. Minnesota Vikings – Philip Merling, DE, Clemson. The Vikings must address the defensive end position, perhaps with more than one choice. Merling has been absent from the postseason workout process, but Minnesota is desperate.

18. Houston Texans – Aqib Talib, CB, Kansas. HC Gary Kubiak knows that he can get 1000 yards from any running back. It’s possible that former Pro Bowl cornerback Dunta Robinson will be out until the middle of next season. Talib represents great value and an insurance policy.

19. Philadelphia Eagles – Jeff Otah, OT, Pittsburgh. Andy Reid loathes using first-round picks on skill-position players, but he loves drafting linemen. Otah is fantastic value here for the Eagles.

20. TampaBay Buccaneers – Devin Thomas, WR, Michigan St. Thomas’s talents will suit Jon Gruden’s offense to a “T”.

21. Washington Redskins – Malcolm Kelly, WR, Oklahoma. The Redskins add a weapon to complement Santana Moss and move Antwan Randle-El to the nickel position. The Redskins would be wise to trade out of the first round altogether with a team that wants the 2nd QB.

22. Dallas Cowboys (through Cleveland Browns) – DeSean Jackson, WR, Cal. Jackson will add some youth to an aging Dallas WR corps. More importantly, he’ll add a terrifying threat to their special teams.

23. Pittsburgh Steelers – James Hardy, WR, Illinois. The Steelers know that they’re going to have to pass more next season. At 6’6”, Hardy is the kind of WR that Ben Roethlisberger will quickly fall in love with.

24. Tennessee TitansCalaisCampbell, DE, Miami (Fl.). The Titans lost two defensive ends to free agency. Campbell will give them a physical presence on the strong side of the line, and should be able to take advantage of the extra attention given to Kyle Vanden Bosch and Albert Haynesworth while he learns the finer points of the game.

25. Seattle Seahawks – Jonathan Stewart, RB, Oregon. GM Tim Ruskell cannot believe that Stewart fell this far to them. Stewart doesn’t take anything off the table when he’s on the field.

26. Jacksonville Jaguars – Kentwan Balmer, DT, North Carolina St. The Jaguars would probably like to trade out of this position. They traded one mammoth DT this offseason, so they’ll pick up a replacement. They’d prefer a pass rusher, but there are none on the board at this point.

27.
San Diego Chargers – Dan Connor, LB, Penn St. The Chargers don’t have a lot of clear needs, but 3-4 defenses cannot compile enough linebackers. Connor is a smart, physical player.

28.
Dallas Cowboys – Felix Jones, RB, Arkanas. Jerry Jones gets an Arkansas runningback who will help the Cowboys in several phases of the game.

29.
San Francisco 49ers (through Indianapolis Colts) – Quentin Groves, DE/OLB, Auburn. Manny Lawson has not developed as HC Mike Nolan might have hoped. Groves will give a pass-rushing presence on the outside of the San Francisco defense.

30.
Green Bay Packers – Kenny Phillips, S, Miami (Fl.). Phillips is probably a bit of an overrated prospect, but the Packers are solid in most aspects of the game. Phillips will spark competition in the Packers’ defensive backfield.

31.
New England Patriots - Forfeited for being cheaters.

32. New York Giants – Gosder Cherilus, OT, BostonCollege. The Giants add a true offensive tackle to their line. They’ve been fortunate with Boston College players in the past, so they’ll go back to that well.
 
OP
OP
D

DaisyCutter

Hall of Famer
BANNED BY MODERATORS
Joined
Nov 26, 2007
Posts
1,718
Reaction score
0
2nd Round:

33. Miami Dolphins – Jerod Mayo, LB, Tennessee. Bill Parcells is stoked that this prospect fell to him. Mayo is one of the fastest-rising prospects in the draft, and will pair with Jason Taylor to be an impact player for the Fins’ 3-4 defense.

34. St. Louis Rams – Limas Sweed, WR, Texas. Sweed will provide an excellent deep target for QB Marc Bulger, and open up underneath routes for WR Torry Holt.

35. Atlanta Falcons – Sam Baker, OT, Southern Cal. Baker was a bit of a disappointment in his final season with the Trojans, but the Falcons are making a big investment in Matt Ryan, and with Baker, they hope to protect it.

36. Kansas City Chiefs – Trevor Laws, DT, Notre Dame. Jared Allen and Tamba Hali are quality defensive ends. But there’s no one on the inside of the Chief’s defense. Laws can play the three-technique or the nose in Herm Edward’s Tampa-2 defense.

37. New York Jets – Martellus Bennett, TE, Texas A&M. A young QB’s best friend is his outlet receiver at the end of the line. Bennett will help the Jets move the chains on offense.

38. Atlanta Falcons – Antoine Cason, CB, Arizona. They like the look of Brandon Flowers at this position, but Cason brings leadership and character as well as productivity and smarts to the Falcons defense.

39. Baltimore Ravens – Brandon Flowers, CB, Virginia Tech. The Hokie star will provide much-needed depth to the Ravens’ defense. The leadership already present in the locker room will keep him in line.

40. San Francisco 49ers – Early Doucet, WR, LSU. The 49ers get a steal in Doucet, who will be the Torry Holt in Martz’s offense. He’s an excellent technician.

41. New Orleans Saints – Curtis Lofton, LB, Oklahoma. New Orleans will continue to add to their defense. They’re disappointed that there is not a defensive tackle available at this position.

42. Buffalo Bills – Fred Davis, TE, Southern Cal. The Bills gambled that one of the big WRs might fall to them here, and it didn’t pay off. They’ll settle for a big target for quarterback Trent Edwards.

43. Denver Broncos – Pat Sims, DT, Auburn. The Broncos need help on the interior defensive line. They reach down for Sims, since he’s the last thing close for quite a while.

44. Carolina Panthers – Brian Brohm, QB, Louisville. The Panthers cannot believe their luck. They feel like he could step in for Delhomme without missing a beat.

45. Chicago Bears – Reggie Smith, S, Oklahoma. Safeties in the Tampa-2 scheme have to have the ability of cornerbacks. Smith could be a star in the Chicago system.

46. Detroit Lions – LawrenceJackson, DE, Southern Cal. Millen and Marinelli wanted Derrick Harvey in the first round, but he didn’t fall to them. They wanted the next Simeon Rice. They got him: A player that’s only interested in rushing the quarterback.

47. Cincinnati Bengals – Mario Manningham, WR, Michigan. With the problems that the Bengals are experiencing, this is a calculated risk. But they’re desperate for WRs at this point.

48. Minnesota Vikings – Andre Caldwell, WR, Florida. Solid value here for the Vikings. Caldwell is a smart player and a good route runner.

49. Atlanta Falcons – Cliff Avril, OLB, Purdue. Atlanta lost a very good player in the offseason in Demorrio Williams. Avril can be a very good player for this team from the strong side or the weak side.

50. Philadelphia EaglesDeJuan Morgan, S, North Carolina St. FS Brian Dawkins is not going to last forever. Morgan will be a physical presence in the Eagles’ secondary.

51. Arizona Cardinals – Chris Johnson, RB, East Carolina. I don’t agree with this pick, but I think that the front office will be enamored with his speed and versatility. I would take Ray Rice, but I don’t think it’ll happen.
 
OP
OP
D

DaisyCutter

Hall of Famer
BANNED BY MODERATORS
Joined
Nov 26, 2007
Posts
1,718
Reaction score
0
Cardinals' picks

16. Dominique Rogers-Cromartie, CB, Tennessee St. See above.

50. Chris Johnson, RB, East Carolina. See above.

81. Anthony Collins, OT, Kansas. This physical specimen will need a year to work on his technique, but should be able to compete for the LT position and win it from Mike Gandy in 2009.

112. Jack Williams, CB, Kent St. A sleeper in this draft, Williams provides youth and depth to the Arizona secondary.

141. Nick Hayden, DE, Wisconsin. Hard worker who could eventually develop into an NT. Signing Bryan Robinson did not alleviate the Cards’ need for depth at Defensive End.

176. Anthony Aldridge, WR, Houston. Teeny-tiny WR (5’8”, 170) will have to work a little with strength coach John Lott. But should the Cards turn back to Kurt Warner, Aldridge will quickly become one of his favorite targets.

207. Kirk Barton, OT, OhioState. Barton is a project player that could become the second edition of Reggie Wells. He needs some seasoning, but is an intriguing prospect this late in the draft.
 

football karma

Michael snuggles the cap space
Joined
Jul 22, 2002
Posts
15,204
Reaction score
14,142
Here's hopefully my last mock draft of the first round through when the Cards pick in the second.

dude-- you have 9 days still. Plenty of time for at least 1 more -- expecially if the Chiefs trade Jared Allen for a couple high picks (reportedly close to doing so to either the Vikings or Bucs)

I also prefer Ray Rice over Chris Johnson
 

joeshmo

Kangol Hat Aficionado
Joined
Feb 23, 2004
Posts
17,247
Reaction score
1
dude-- you have 9 days still. Plenty of time for at least 1 more -- expecially if the Chiefs trade Jared Allen for a couple high picks (reportedly close to doing so to either the Vikings or Bucs)

I also prefer Ray Rice over Chris Johnson

Allen about to be traded! Do you have a link? Really interesting development right before the draft to say the least.

Gholston doesnt get past the Chiefs if it goes down.
 

chicards11

Registered
Joined
Aug 24, 2007
Posts
417
Reaction score
0
dude-- you have 9 days still. Plenty of time for at least 1 more -- expecially if the Chiefs trade Jared Allen for a couple high picks (reportedly close to doing so to either the Vikings or Bucs)

I also prefer Ray Rice over Chris Johnson

Ray Rice is an injury waiting to happen. He blasted his way through defenders at Rutgers but believe you me......that won't happen for him in the NFL. All that pounding will end up getting him a rookie trip to the IR
 

lobo

ASFN Lifer
Joined
Feb 16, 2006
Posts
3,310
Reaction score
230
Location
Inverness, Il
16. Dominique Rogers-Cromartie, CB, Tennessee St. See above.

50. Chris Johnson, RB, East Carolina. See above.

81. Anthony Collins, OT, Kansas. This physical specimen will need a year to work on his technique, but should be able to compete for the LT position and win it from Mike Gandy in 2009.

112. Jack Williams, CB, Kent St. A sleeper in this draft, Williams provides youth and depth to the Arizona secondary.

141. Nick Hayden, DE, Wisconsin. Hard worker who could eventually develop into an NT. Signing Bryan Robinson did not alleviate the Cards’ need for depth at Defensive End.

176. Anthony Aldridge, WR, Houston. Teeny-tiny WR (5’8”, 170) will have to work a little with strength coach John Lott. But should the Cards turn back to Kurt Warner, Aldridge will quickly become one of his favorite targets.

207. Kirk Barton, OT, OhioState. Barton is a project player that could become the second edition of Reggie Wells. He needs some seasoning, but is an intriguing prospect this late in the draft.


Striclty opinion of course

If DRC is there (also a couple of other studs) we will go CB in round !..
Agree with your Second Round pick as well. Whoever likes RIce BEWARE...there is a lot of wear on the tires with him...a whole lot of carries...as I mentioned along with some other posters...running back have just so many carries in them before they run of out gas...Rice has a ton of hits...as good as he is.
 

Russ Smith

The Original Whizzinator
Supporting Member
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
87,398
Reaction score
38,616
God I hope DeSean Jackson doesn't become a Cowboy.


If he can't be a card(he won't) I'd actually love to see Buffalo trade down and get him. Lynch, Edwards and Jackson would be a great Bay Area trio.
 
OP
OP
D

DaisyCutter

Hall of Famer
BANNED BY MODERATORS
Joined
Nov 26, 2007
Posts
1,718
Reaction score
0
God I hope DeSean Jackson doesn't become a Cowboy.


If he can't be a card(he won't) I'd actually love to see Buffalo trade down and get him. Lynch, Edwards and Jackson would be a great Bay Area trio.

:D

Everything I see on the Bills is that they want a big, physical possession WR. They have a guy that's better and more durable than Jackson in Lee Evans. I can see why a NoCal homer would say that, though.

I really think that Jackson will be a collossal disappointment if he's picked above 20. I think he'll be a good special teams player, but he's like 170 lbs. He'll get broken in half at the NFL level, and he's not going to be able to run around guys like Adrian Wilson.

Career return specialist and slot WR. I wouldn't want to take him for my team.
 

Russ Smith

The Original Whizzinator
Supporting Member
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
87,398
Reaction score
38,616
:D

Everything I see on the Bills is that they want a big, physical possession WR. They have a guy that's better and more durable than Jackson in Lee Evans. I can see why a NoCal homer would say that, though.

I really think that Jackson will be a collossal disappointment if he's picked above 20. I think he'll be a good special teams player, but he's like 170 lbs. He'll get broken in half at the NFL level, and he's not going to be able to run around guys like Adrian Wilson.

Career return specialist and slot WR. I wouldn't want to take him for my team.


Yeah I love the kid but I agree he's too small. If you saw the USC game 2 years ago he got crushd by Taylor Mays and vanished the rest of the game.

Great talent but I can't help but wonder if he'll be durable. Buffalo also has Roscoe Parrish so they probably won't look at a guy as return specialist.

Jackson will make an impact in the NFL just not sure how big because of his size.

I just hope for his sake he goes to a team that has a QB with an arm, I got so tired of him running past the safety only to have Nate Longshore underthrow him by 10 feet.
 
OP
OP
D

DaisyCutter

Hall of Famer
BANNED BY MODERATORS
Joined
Nov 26, 2007
Posts
1,718
Reaction score
0
I just hope for his sake he goes to a team that has a QB with an arm, I got so tired of him running past the safety only to have Nate Longshore underthrow him by 10 feet.


See? You know you want him as a Cowboy...

Although, he'd be an intriguing Viking. There's no arguing Jackon's arm strength.
 

Russ Smith

The Original Whizzinator
Supporting Member
Joined
May 14, 2002
Posts
87,398
Reaction score
38,616
See? You know you want him as a Cowboy...

Although, he'd be an intriguing Viking. There's no arguing Jackon's arm strength.

The Raiders would work too no way he can outrun Jamarcus' arm. But I wouldn't wish the Raiders on my worst enemy let alone a kid I actually like.

If the Cards were picking at the end of the first round and didn't have obvious needs at other positions DeSean would be an intriguing guy for us, speed WR who can return kicks, but we just can't afford another high pick at WR right now.
 
OP
OP
D

DaisyCutter

Hall of Famer
BANNED BY MODERATORS
Joined
Nov 26, 2007
Posts
1,718
Reaction score
0
Way too many Defensive players in top ten. NO Wrs.


There aren't going to be any WRs in the Top 10, wally. There probably aren't going to be any WRs in the Top 15. I think this is a deep class of WRs, but there isn't a lot of wattage at the top.
 

Southpaw

Provocateur aka Wallyburger
Supporting Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2003
Posts
39,818
Reaction score
3,410
Location
The urban swamp
There aren't going to be any WRs in the Top 10, wally. There probably aren't going to be any WRs in the Top 15. I think this is a deep class of WRs, but there isn't a lot of wattage at the top.

Sweed and Devin Thomas. I see this as a very weak draft in the 1st round. Bunch of lucky players will get picked.
 
OP
OP
D

DaisyCutter

Hall of Famer
BANNED BY MODERATORS
Joined
Nov 26, 2007
Posts
1,718
Reaction score
0
Sweed and Devin Thomas. I see this as a very weak draft in the 1st round. Bunch of lucky players will get picked.


You may be right. I hope you are, since that would push better prospects down to us. But I don't see it happening. It would take a very desperate coach indeed to invest a Top 15 pick in a guy who had one good season in college in Devin Thomas.

I like Limas Sweed a lot, but I imagine that a team like Buffalo will either trade way down to get him, or move back into the late-first.
 

Arizona's Finest

Your My Favorite Mistake
Joined
Jun 11, 2005
Posts
9,709
Reaction score
1
16. Arizona CardinalsDominique Rogers-Cromartie, CB, Tennessee St.. Jeff Otah’s still on the board, but the Cards already have a right tackle. Jonathan Stewart is tempting here, but the Cards understand that they’re not going to use a Top 20 pick on a player whose talents they’ll underutilize (Whis’s offense does not pass the ball to RBs). They’ve backed themselves into a corner with this pick, which they’re not going to be disappointed with. If you believe in your coaching staff, you are not afraid to select players with a high ceiling like Cromartie.

Love this last comment. You have single handedly caused me toreconsider my stay away from DRC policy because it will take to long for him to develop. I belive in Whiz so why not go for the guy with the most upside....?

Unfortunately for me the player I really want is Mendenhall. Can one of the Illinois Cards fans try to end up at the same party as him and get a picture of him hitting a blunt or something? It seems the last few years every the player I really want in the draft is also wanted by the team right in front of us drafting. I would do cartwheels if we got this kid.....
 

black

ASFN Lifer
BANNED BY MODERATORS
Joined
May 19, 2004
Posts
3,124
Reaction score
1
Location
girard,Il.
16. Arizona CardinalsDominique Rogers-Cromartie, CB, Tennessee St.. Jeff Otah’s still on the board, but the Cards already have a right tackle. Jonathan Stewart is tempting here, but the Cards understand that they’re not going to use a Top 20 pick on a player whose talents they’ll underutilize (Whis’s offense does not pass the ball to RBs). They’ve backed themselves into a corner with this pick, which they’re not going to be disappointed with. If you believe in your coaching staff, you are not afraid to select players with a high ceiling like Cromartie.

Love this last comment. You have single handedly caused me toreconsider my stay away from DRC policy because it will take to long for him to develop. I belive in Whiz so why not go for the guy with the most upside....?

Unfortunately for me the player I really want is Mendenhall. Can one of the Illinois Cards fans try to end up at the same party as him and get a picture of him hitting a blunt or something? It seems the last few years every the player I really want in the draft is also wanted by the team right in front of us drafting. I would do cartwheels if we got this kid.....
Big Illini fan here. Ya, the kid is great. I'd be happy with the pick.
 

WildBB

Yogi n da Bear
Joined
Mar 20, 2004
Posts
14,295
Reaction score
1,239
Location
The Sonoran Jungle - West
DaisyCutter;1689195[B said:
16. [/B]Arizona CardinalsDominique Rogers-Cromartie, CB, Tennessee St.. Jeff Otah’s still on the board, but the Cards already have a right tackle. Jonathan Stewart is tempting here, but the Cards understand that they’re not going to use a Top 20 pick on a player whose talents they’ll underutilize (Whis’s offense does not pass the ball to RBs). They’ve backed themselves into a corner with this pick, which they’re not going to be disappointed with. If you believe in your coaching staff, you are not afraid to select players with a high ceiling like Cromartie.

finer points of the game.

25. Seattle Seahawks – Jonathan Stewart, RB, Oregon. GM Tim Ruskell cannot believe that Stewart fell this far to them. Stewart doesn’t take anything off the table when he’s on the field.

Worst case senario, IMO. Let this future star at a vital position go to a bitter rival.

How is an everydown back of the future be underutilized. And if you say we don't throw to our back, that would be innacurate. Warner checks down rarely, but Leinart will more so. "Even so Arrington was used a couple times a game last season catching out of the backfield.
 
OP
OP
D

DaisyCutter

Hall of Famer
BANNED BY MODERATORS
Joined
Nov 26, 2007
Posts
1,718
Reaction score
0
Worst case senario, IMO. Let this future star at a vital position go to a bitter rival.

How is an everydown back of the future be underutilized. And if you say we don't throw to our back, that would be innacurate. Warner checks down rarely, but Leinart will more so. "Even so Arrington was used a couple times a game last season catching out of the backfield.

Personally, I think that you draft an RB in the first round because he's a complete player, and you're going to use all of his talents. I like Jonathan Stewart as a prospect, and I think that he'll be very good in this league if he can stay healthy.

But I don't think this team is looking for a complete RB. I think they're looking for a speedier back that is going to hit the crease that he's assigned at full speed, every time.

Edgerrin James is a very, very good pass-catching back. He averaged 50+ receptions a season in Indy (if you take away the season he got hurt), and had a couple seasons where he caught 60+ passes.

In his first season as a Card, James caught 38 passes. In his first season with Ken Whisenhut, he caught 24. I'm not sure what you're talking about w/r/t Leinart throwing him the ball (when we were ostensibly running the purest version of the Whis offense). Through the first five weeks of the 2007 season, James averaged fewer than 2 receptions a game. He never caught more than 4 passes in a game.

You're right that J.J. Arrington was thrown to more (29 receptions), but what were the circumstances of those plays? Why didn't we take advantage of getting Edge the ball in space? Why did Willie Parker only have 31 receptions in his one season as a starter?

Only 16 percent of the total completions last season went to running backs. If anything, we're going to want to run the ball much more next season. I just don't see us needing to draft a RB this high if we're not going to take full advantage of his capabilities.

For comparison's sake, the Chargers (who aren't exactly a West Coast offense) had over a quarter of their completions go to Tomlinson/Sproles/Turner.

Again, I like Stewart as a prospect, but I think they'll get the same positives that they like in Stewart later in the draft while being able to immediately get help at a position the desperately needs it in the first round.
 

slanidrac16

ASFN Icon
Supporting Member
Joined
Jul 11, 2002
Posts
15,521
Reaction score
15,641
Location
Plainfield, Il.
Personally, I think that you draft an RB in the first round because he's a complete player, and you're going to use all of his talents. I like Jonathan Stewart as a prospect, and I think that he'll be very good in this league if he can stay healthy.

But I don't think this team is looking for a complete RB. I think they're looking for a speedier back that is going to hit the crease that he's assigned at full speed, every time.

Edgerrin James is a very, very good pass-catching back. He averaged 50+ receptions a season in Indy (if you take away the season he got hurt), and had a couple seasons where he caught 60+ passes.

In his first season as a Card, James caught 38 passes. In his first season with Ken Whisenhut, he caught 24. I'm not sure what you're talking about w/r/t Leinart throwing him the ball (when we were ostensibly running the purest version of the Whis offense). Through the first five weeks of the 2007 season, James averaged fewer than 2 receptions a game. He never caught more than 4 passes in a game.

You're right that J.J. Arrington was thrown to more (29 receptions), but what were the circumstances of those plays? Why didn't we take advantage of getting Edge the ball in space? Why did Willie Parker only have 31 receptions in his one season as a starter?

Only 16 percent of the total completions last season went to running backs. If anything, we're going to want to run the ball much more next season. I just don't see us needing to draft a RB this high if we're not going to take full advantage of his capabilities.

For comparison's sake, the Chargers (who aren't exactly a West Coast offense) had over a quarter of their completions go to Tomlinson/Sproles/Turner.

Again, I like Stewart as a prospect, but I think they'll get the same positives that they like in Stewart later in the draft while being able to immediately get help at a position the desperately needs it in the first round.

Srewart could fill the speed back role this year before taking over next year. I would imagine Stewart would look like speedracer compared to Edge.
 

dreamcastrocks

Chopped Liver Moderator
Super Moderator
Moderator
Supporting Member
Joined
Aug 19, 2005
Posts
46,238
Reaction score
11,830
I agree with your position about Whiz not throwing to backs. I don't think that should keep us from drafting Stewart. Hell, we have seen JJ line up at WR a few times last year.

Besides, when you have Fitz and Boldin catching passes, he (James or Stewart) should always be a 3rd option anyway.

For the record, I would rather have DRC than Stewart, but just wanted to respond.
 

Latest posts

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
552,047
Posts
5,394,752
Members
6,313
Latest member
50 year card fan
Top