Quan or Fitz?

[MaoTosiFanClub]

When has Fitz ran through a tackle like Boldin? Ever?

They have different abilities. Boldin is a bully, runs people over. Fitz is a high jumper with great hands. Not the same, not comparable ability. Boldin does everything Fitz does, some of it better. Fitz doesn't do everything Boldin does, but does do some of it better.

Their skills are slightly different, but I'm referring to their overall ability as WRs. They both have the ability to be perennial Pro Bowl wide recievers and possibly one day Hall of Fame ability. I chose Fitzgerald because of the two factors I mentioned.

 

[KingofCards]

Their skills are slightly different, but I'm referring to their overall ability as WRs. They both have the ability to be perennial Pro Bowl wide recievers and possibly one day Hall of Fame ability. I chose Fitzgerald because of the two factors I mentioned.

I know Mao. I chose to ignore for obvious reasons.

 

[KingofCards]

Well to be fair I have not yet see Fitz rip his helmet off and classlessly cost the cards a game and just moments after he committed a personal foul while the cards were driving for a score. You can spin it however you want but that was not a good thing to do.

I think your being little hard on Anquan saying that he cost the Cards that game. I think it is hilarious that you consider that opinion a "fair" opinion.

I m taking Fitz FTW, the guy has unrealistic expectations put upon him by fans like you king while I see you and your fanbois slapping each other in the ass over Jason Mccadley and Marcel Ships of the

WTF???

Are you living with Larry Fitzgerald? I have never talked bad about Fitz on this board or anywhere else idiot. I have definitely never pimped McCadely.

Marcel Shipp does have my admiration. He is a fighter that came into the league an udfa, made it and beat out a couple drafted guys one being the 6th pick in the draft. He recovered from a horrible injury to come back this year. I certainly admire Shipp, I think everyone should.

Have I ever spoken about him on this board before? Not very much, and certainly not against any of our current running backs. I think Arrington needs to touch the ball 25 times a game.

 

[KingofCards]

spam so good

Why do you have "spam so good" as your avatar? I don't get it?

 

[BACH]

Fitz by a hair, and the only reason is injury history with Q. Fitz is a better end zone target, and catches everything, but Q can turn a 5 yard pass into at 50 yard TD run.

We better get something GREAT in this hypothetical though...

Pretty much sums it up for me as well.

 

[Chris_Sanders]

Well to be fair I have not yet see Fitz rip his helmet off and classlessly cost the cards a game and just moments after he committed a personal foul while the cards were driving for a score. You can spin it however you want but that was not a good thing to do.

I m taking Fitz FTW, the guy has unrealistic expectations put upon him by fans like you king while I see you and your fanbois slapping each other in the ass over Jason Mccadley and Marcel Ships of the world for doing basically nothing in their careers other than beat minimal expecations set upon them. And furthermore in my opinion is Fitz is the only cardinal going to the probowl this year now that that kicker got hurt (who cares really, frigin kickers).

You can get away with acting like this on the Suns board, but not here.

Respect your fellow posters or be banned Treesquid, very simple.

 

[WisconsinCard]

q__riffic

 

[seesred]

I can't vote and choose the two best most exciting young players in the NFL. And, they are both ours for many years to come. These two are worth the price of admission alone.

GBR
40

 

[Arizona's Finest]

Q because of his fire and winners mentality (is that better BigDavis?) on the field....

Just by a hair though...and i am accounting for Q's injured past....

Great poll IMO to be able to have....

Ill start another one:

Rob Moore or Frank Sanders

OT: I remember when i used to have arguments with people (i was like 16) about Moore and Sanders being the best tandem in the league. Its ALOT better to be saying that when its accepted fact....and you have Q and Fitz of course

 

[wierwolf]

I like both of them.... But I go with Fitz and hopefully NFL leading receptions leader. Plus, I have his jersey...

 

[Faithful]

Boldin, Boldin, oh and Boldin.

 

[clif]

what no option for Bryant Johnson?


:quicklyexitsroom:

 

[dreamcastrocks]

I took Fitzgerald as well. If Boldin was injury free, it would be much closer. Fitzgerald is a much better end zone target IMO.

 

[Pariah]

I took Fitzgerald as well. If Boldin was injury free, it would be much closer. Fitzgerald is a much better end zone target IMO.

Actually, since Boldin is winning by a healthy margin, if he was healthy it might be a landslide.

 

[dreamcastrocks]

Actually, since Boldin is winning by a healthy margin, if he was healthy it might be a landslide.

Doubtful. Fitzgerald is still good enough to wear Boldin's jock.

But Hines Ward on the other hand..... Now thats a landslide.

 

[NEZCardsfan]

I took Fitzgerald as well. If Boldin was injury free, it would be much closer. Fitzgerald is a much better end zone target IMO.

Can somebody please inform Rowen of this.......and instruct him on how to call the Fade route.

 

[DevonCardsFan]

You can get away with acting like this on the Suns board, but not here.

Respect your fellow posters or be banned Treesquid, very simple.

I love the Suns almost as much as I love the Cards, but the Suns forum everyone is a grouch and seem mean to each other, so I rarely post. I wish more Cards guys liked the Suns too on this board
, because there is never much discussion on the Suns forum.

I pick Q because he seems to have alot more heart then Fitz. I love seeing Q pissed on the sideline, because I wan't the players to be as upset as I am when Cards are losing. When I see Cardinals acting non chalent, during a bad game, It pisses me off

 

[Pariah]

Doubtful. Fitzgerald is still good enough to wear Boldin's jock.

Hey, I voted for fitz, but only because of Boldin's injury history. I suspect others voted that way for that reason, as well.

 

[Pariah]

Can somebody please inform Rowen of this.......and instruct him on how to call the Fade route.

It's not even a fade route that we need to run. It's a jump ball. The fade route seems to me to have a lower chance of success than simply putting the ball up high for Fitz to go and get from the smaller DBs.

Run the fade to Johnson. Throw it up for grabs to Fitz. Drop it off underneath for Boldin and let him will his way into the endzone.

 

[Duckjake]

Q because of his fire and winners mentality (is that better BigDavis?) on the field....

Just by a hair though...and i am accounting for Q's injured past....

Great poll IMO to be able to have....

Ill start another one:

Rob Moore or Frank Sanders

OT: I remember when i used to have arguments with people (i was like 16) about Moore and Sanders being the best tandem in the league. Its ALOT better to be saying that when its accepted fact....and you have Q and Fitz of course

Sanders was always one of my favorite players. A lot of people ragged on him because of his tendancy to drop easy passes but he always made up for it by making a circus catch for a key first down.

Thinking about Moore/Sanders and Boston/Sanders made me go back and look at the old stats for wide receivers. Did you guys know that no Cardinal WR has reached double digits in TD receptions in a season the entire time the Cards have been in Arizona? And that the record for most TD catches in a season (16) was set in 1960?

 

[TRW]

Fitz, but it's pretty much a toss up with me.

Mostly because of the injury issues Quan has had. His knee concerns me a bit.

 

[dreamcastrocks]

Hey, I voted for fitz, but only because of Boldin's injury history. I suspect others voted that way for that reason, as well.

I did as well. But I just do not think that it would be a landslide of Hines Ward proportions.

 

[Black Jesus]

bumpo was 40-28 in favor of Q when i posted

 

[Ryanwb]

bumpo was 40-28 in favor of Q when i posted

Come on this was 3 years ago, what point are you trying to prove?

 

[RugbyMuffin]

Come on this was 3 years ago, what point are you trying to prove?

Probably nothing.

Just fun to re-read this stuff.

I just like seeing some old-posters.