Rank these 4 QB’s all-time...

[GatorAZ]

(listed randomly)
Rodgers
Favre
Brees
Peyton

 

[DVontel]

Peyton
Rodgers
Favre
Brees

 

[HGC]

Peyton
Rodgers
Brees
Favre

 

[BigRedRage]

I mean
Peyton
Favre
Brees
Rodgers

I don't think you can really argue otherwise right now except maybe 3/4

 

[Russ Smith]

Peyton
Rodgers
Favre
Brees

3 and 4 are basically a wash. Favre it's hard to say for much of his career they would have one or two really good receivers that was it, seems like Brees has played with more top end receivers and TE's than Favre did at least all at once.

 

[Red Bird]

Peyton
Rodgers
Brees
Favre

This

 

[GatorAZ]

Rodgers (imagine him in a dome for most his career)
Manning (super close)
Brees (played a much smarter brand of QB than Favre)
Favre (maybe the most exciting but see above)

 

[TRW]

Peyton
Rodgers
Brees
Favre

 

[Dr. Jones]

Peyton
Rodgers
Brees
Favre

This

 

[Brak]

Brees
Favre
Rodgers
Peyton

Peyton the most overrated QB in history IMHO. Couldn't carry his dad's jock.

 

[Shane]

Peyton
Rodgers
Brees
Favre

this

 

[Harry]

Mannng
Brees
Rodgers
Farve

I’d put Warner at number 2. I think he suffered from some terrible GM decisions. They never understood what made him great. Put him with the offense my bottom 3 had and I believe he outscores them.

 

[Minski]

Payton
Brees
Farve
Rodgers

 

[jf-08]

Rodgers (imagine him in a dome for most his career)
Manning (super close)
Brees (played a much smarter brand of QB than Favre)
Favre (maybe the most exciting but see above)

Hard to argue with this.

Also, if your team (Cards) was up by 5 with less than a minute to go and the other team had 1st and 10 on their own 4 yard line, which of the above 4 QBs would you not want to face?

For me, Rodgers.

 

[DVontel]

Hard to argue with this.

Also, if your team (Cards) was up by 5 with less than a minute to go and the other team had 1st and 10 on their own 4 yard line, which of the above 4 QBs would you not want to face?

For me, Rodgers.

If I’m a Cowboy or Bear, Rodgers.


Otherwise, Peyton.

 

[jmt]

Rodgers
Peyton
Favre
Brees

I too think Peyton was overrated.

 

[cardpa]

Peyton
Rodgers
Brees
Favre

 

[GatorAZ]

Mannng
Brees
Rodgers
Farve

I’d put Warner at number 2. I think he suffered from some terrible GM decisions. They never understood what made him great. Put him with the offense my bottom 3 had and I believe he outscores them.

Thought about adding Kurt but he’s well below these guys when it comes to consistency and durability.

 

[oaken1]

Look at the stats..... most of you guys are way under valuing Drew Brees

 

[Solar7]

Peyton
Brees
Favre
Rodgers (but call me back in a few years, he's not done)

 

[SissyBoyFloyd]

Rodgers
Manning
Favre
Brees

 

[PACardsFan]

I have to laugh at a few responses that said that ANY of these guys were overrated. Put them in whatever order you please, they were ALL great. As long as you put Brady at 1, and Montana at 2, the rest of the order is insignificant.

 

[oaken1]

I have to laugh at a few responses that said that ANY of these guys were overrated. Put them in whatever order you please, they were ALL great. As long as you put Brady at 1, and Montana at 2, the rest of the order is insignificant.

Super bowl.... first and ten on your own five yard line... a minute and a half to play and your down by five......
I’d take Montana over Brady every single time

 

[RugbyMuffin]

John Skelton
Ryan Lindley
John Navarre
Max Hall

 

[Cbus cardsfan]

Rodgers
Favre
Manning
Brees

Manning was great but he had much more offensive talent around him than Rodgers. Think he had Harrison, Wayne, Edge, Faulk, Addai all at some point.