Rank these 4 QB’s all-time...

[PACardsFan]

Super bowl.... first and ten on your own five yard line... a minute and a half to play and your down by five......
I’d take Montana over Brady every single time

You won't get an argument from me if put in that situation. I was a huge Montana fan! But, no one can argue the fact that Brady has won 6. My argument in favor of Montana was that Joe never lost one.

 

[dreamcastrocks]

Look at the stats..... most of you guys are way under valuing Drew Brees

I'm having a hard time with this because you could argue that Brees should be #1 on the list, and he is 3rd and 4th on a lot of lists here.

 

[Shane]

You won't get an argument from me if put in that situation. I was a huge Montana fan! But, no one can argue the fact that Brady has won 6. My argument in favor of Montana was that Joe never lost one.

But how many did he go to? Lol

 

[PACardsFan]

But how many did he go to? Lol

4-0 is still very impressive. Would love to have seen how many more Montana would have won if the Niners hadn't moved on to Young. I'd say maybe 2 more. Yes, the GOAT is heading to his 10th SB. Wow!, that's crazy to even be typing. But, the GOAT has lost 3, and that number could end up being 4. So what's more impressive: 4-0 or 6-4? IMHO, going to 10 is unmatched & will remain unmatched until we see how Mahomes's career plays out.

 

[dreamcastrocks]

4-0 is still very impressive. Would love to have seen how many more Montana would have won if the Niners hadn't moved on to Young. I'd say maybe 2 more. Yes, the GOAT is heading to his 10th SB. Wow!, that's crazy to even be typing. But, the GOAT has lost 3, and that number could end up being 4. So what's more impressive: 4-0 or 6-4? IMHO, going to 10 is unmatched & will remain unmatched until we see how Mahomes's career plays out.

6-4 without question. Brady had much worse supporting casts than Montana ever had.

 

[Cbus cardsfan]

4-0 is still very impressive. Would love to have seen how many more Montana would have won if the Niners hadn't moved on to Young. I'd say maybe 2 more. Yes, the GOAT is heading to his 10th SB. Wow!, that's crazy to even be typing. But, the GOAT has lost 3, and that number could end up being 4. So what's more impressive: 4-0 or 6-4? IMHO, going to 10 is unmatched & will remain unmatched until we see how Mahomes's career plays out.

But still Montana had a ton of weapons. Rice, Taylor, Craig etc.
Funny thing is the 1 year Brady had all the weapons, they were undefeated until they lost in SB.

I think getting to 10 is more impressive. And I think Tampa wins this year.

 

[PACardsFan]

But still Montana had a ton of weapons. Rice, Taylor, Craig etc.
Funny thing is the 1 year Brady had all the weapons, they were undefeated until they lost in SB.

I think getting to 10 is more impressive. And I think Tampa wins this year.

I'm rooting for TB, but not sold they'll win. I agree that nothing compares to 10 trips to the SB.

 

[Shane]

4-0 is still very impressive. Would love to have seen how many more Montana would have won if the Niners hadn't moved on to Young. I'd say maybe 2 more. Yes, the GOAT is heading to his 10th SB. Wow!, that's crazy to even be typing. But, the GOAT has lost 3, and that number could end up being 4. So what's more impressive: 4-0 or 6-4? IMHO, going to 10 is unmatched & will remain unmatched until we see how Mahomes's career plays out.

6-4 is much more impressive. Those 49er teams were far more star studded across the board as well.

 

[DVontel]

4-0 is still very impressive. Would love to have seen how many more Montana would have won if the Niners hadn't moved on to Young. I'd say maybe 2 more. Yes, the GOAT is heading to his 10th SB. Wow!, that's crazy to even be typing. But, the GOAT has lost 3, and that number could end up being 4. So what's more impressive: 4-0 or 6-4? IMHO, going to 10 is unmatched & will remain unmatched until we see how Mahomes's career plays out.

6-4 is EASILY more impressive, lol.