The not-so-Ultimate Popcorn Flick Kumite: Match-Up #1

Which is the better popcorn movie?


  • Total voters
    29
  • Poll closed .

Cardinals.Ken

That's Mr. Riff-Raff to you!
Joined
Jan 13, 2003
Posts
13,359
Reaction score
60
Location
Mesa, AZ
Fight Club



A young urban professional who works for a major car manufacturer can't sleep. Although he doesn't have any of the associated afflictions, he stumbles across support groups as a means to let out whatever emotions he is feeling, which in turn is allowing him to sleep. But the use of these support groups is ruined when he meets a young woman named Marla Singer, who is also going to all these support group meetings. Because he knows she too is not afflicted with any of the maladies for which the groups exist, her presence has lessened the impact of the stories he hears. His life changes when he meets a soap manufacturer named Tyler Durden, who in many ways is the antithesis of the insomniac. Due to unusual circumstances with his own condo, the insomniac moves in with Tyler, who lives in a large dilapidated house in an otherwise abandoned part of town. After a bit of spontaneous roughhousing with Tyler in a bar parking lot, the insomniac finds it becomes a ritual between the two of them, which is helping him cope with the other more difficult aspects of his life. The fights also attract a following, others who not only want to watch but join in. Understanding that there are other men like them, the insomniac and Tyler begin a secret fight club. As the fight club's popularity grows, so does its scope in all aspects. Marla becomes a circle not specifically of the fight clubs but of Tyler and the insomniac's collectives lives. As the nature of the fight clubs becomes out of control in the insomniac's view, the insomniac's life, in association, is one where he no longer understands what is happening around him, or how he can get out of it without harming himself.

vs.

Batman (1989)




Gotham City: dark, dangerous, 'protected' only by a mostly corrupt police department. Despite the best efforts of D.A. Harvey Dent and police commissioner Jim Gordon, the city becomes increasingly unsafe...until a Dark Knight arises. We all know criminals are a superstitious, cowardly lot...so his disguise must be able to strike terror into their hearts. He becomes a bat. Enter Vicky Vale, a prize-winning photo journalist who wants to uncover the secret of the mysterious "bat-man". And enter Jack Napier, one-time enforcer for Boss Grissom, horribly disfigured after a firefight in a chemical factory...who, devoid of the last vestiges of sanity, seizes control of Gotham's underworld as the psychotic, unpredictable Clown Prince of Crime...the Joker. Gotham's only hope, it seems, lies in this dark, brooding vigilante.
 

BigRedRage

Reckless
Supporting Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2005
Posts
48,274
Reaction score
12,525
Location
SE valley
Batman 1989- classic movie. I was under 10 when I saw this and it was awesome. Joker was very creepy and the final battle was epic.

Fight club - What a ass kicking this movie did to my brain. Great, well thought out original movie of wtf just happened.

While batman is awesome, fight club had me engaged, guessing the whole time and the end caught me very off guard. Nice to have an unpredictable ending. My vote goes to fight club.
 

Gaddabout

Plucky Comic Relief
Supporting Member
Joined
Jul 2, 2004
Posts
16,043
Reaction score
11
Location
Gilbert
Fight Club was punk rock on film. Batman had me eating pop corn.
 

Cheesebeef

ASFN IDOL
Supporting Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2003
Posts
91,266
Reaction score
68,197
DAMN! This is gonna be TOUGH!

I seriously have no idea which to pick. seeing Batman in the theaters is one of the my all-time favorite movie going experiences, but I love me some Fight Club.

Hmmm... gotta go with Batman. I'm kinda surprised by that answer, but it's what my gut's telling me. Hell, just watched that choppy-ass trailer and the theme music alone gives me my answer. It's close, but Batman takes it for me.
 
Last edited:

AZZenny

Registered User
Joined
Feb 18, 2003
Posts
9,235
Reaction score
2
Location
Cave Creek
If a popcorn movie is brainless exciting fluff I'd plop down to watch again and again shamelessly -- neither.
 

MigratingOsprey

Thank You Paul!
Joined
Jul 20, 2003
Posts
13,875
Reaction score
6,757
Location
Goodyear
I liked fight club, but it just doesn't have the same draw ....... batman I saw in the theater - fight club, I don't think I would care where I saw it .... batman had an iffy sequel, but I still joined the packed masses squeezing in for that last remaining theater seat ..... if fight club had a sequel/spin off i'm not sure I'd care

I found fight club to be interesting, but not captivating .... maybe some of this has to do with my age when both came out, but this one is batman all the way - especially when you throw in the rockin' prince soundtrack
 
Top