This episode WAS entering into Kate's All-Time Favorite Episodes Category... that is until....
At the point of Andy ruining Jim's proposal was where this episode went COMPLETELY SOUR for me and ruined the whole episode. Jim and Pam SHOULD HAVE BEEN ENGAGED BY THE END OF THIS EPISODE. Now, since Pam was all "I thought Jim was gonna propose" its going to be a BUNCH OF CRAP DRAMA for the three months over summer break. Can the writers not let this couple actually be happy and BE a couple? Give me a freaking BREAK. Go ahead, have Pam do her internship thing in NY. GO ahead, have them break up for those three months cuz Pam didnt get her proposal. GO right ahead, JERKS.
UGh. I am sorry, this is just a TV show. I am still pissed as all hell.
Top 3 worst things of this episode:
1. Jim and Pam being interrupted before the proposal - stupid, not needed and just plain dumb
2. Dwight and Angela shot at the very end - We all know they still liked eachother - this should have been shown as a flashback during this fall's season premiere or something - now it just negates Andy's proposal WHICH INTERFERED WITH JIM's PROPOSAL!!!!!
3. Jan - I used to like them together but now her character is dead to me. How awful.
To end this one a happy note:
1. Kevin and Holly interaction was the funniest thing I have ever seen on this show. I was literally howling.
2. Dwight saying "This is my fault" was both heartbreaking and sad, but it needed to have been said.
3. Michael and Holly - I actually really enjoyed them together.
edited to add: 4. Michael's glee that Toby was leaving (so funny!!)
This is an epic meltdown for me and I apologize in advance but I am so freaking pissed off right now.