Here our my USA player ratings.
McKennie is the clear MOTM for me. 9/10 only not a 10/10 because he missed a couple of would be goals and he was slow to react to the offside goal that was called off. hell of a performance for 120 mins. he was everywhere. he caused 2 of the 3 goals and came close to scoring 2 others. He may have had a chance to play Sargent through for a goal, but he opted to shoot and almost scored. he was physical, he was aggressive, he had a lot of 50/50 challenges in the midfield, and he was in every scuffle as to let the other players know that they would have to go through him first.
Horvath...8/10 for me. this game could have turned sideways when Steffen left the match. yet Horvath made 2 exceptional saves and was solid on a few other shots Mexico put on target. the penalty save was incredible. to be fair Guardado was conservative and looked like he mis hit the shot. Can't fault Horvath for the second Mexico goal. he was slow to react, but he was screened by 3 of his own players. I fault Ream for getting beat and Acosta for ball watching. Horvath had one bad distro on a goal kick that led to goal scoring chance.
Reyna, 7/10. he was dangerous with the ball. He scored a big goal and almost hit Sargent's foot on a good pass across the face of the goal. he too like McKennie was everywhere. how many times did he track back to kill a Mexican counter attack? some of those back tracks were late in the match. what a gutsy kid. he also dropped back several times to help play out of the back. and he had a great corner that hit McKennie on the far post for the second goal. I can't say enough about the kid. wow.
Brooks, 6.5/10. He was solid all game. Vocal leader and other than the one offside goal that Mexico had called back, I don't think that he had any other potential fatal errors. He did have one really bad pass that turned the ball over to a counter that luckily did not hurt them, I think Mexico ended up being offside. Brooks also did well to help play out of the back. Mexico had trouble with him on corners on both sides of the pitch, which I think actually opened it up some for McKennie.
Pulisic, 6/10 he wasn't on the ball enough for me. He also lost possession more than he should, mostly in the first half. Also had a couple fouls that were not given, but I guess that's just going to be what it is for him because defenders will always refuse to give him space given what he does when he goes forward. as the match went on you could kind of see him trending in the right direction. He started to get his feet under him and quietly had a couple of trademark threatening runs in the final third. His corners were on point. And his penalty. some are being critical of his flop. so for me yes he felt the contact and went down. I watch a lot of PL. guess what the top players do. they feel the contact, if they can't score, they are going down to make the referee choose. Like it or not, that is the game and everyone knows it, including the Mexican manager that expelled himself before the VAR check was complete because even he knew it was a penalty. it was clumsy by the Mexican defender. the ball was either going out for a goal kick, or a corner, which the latter would have led to a McKennie brace anyway
Timothy Weah, 6/10, you could tell he was on the pitch. he had several positive moments that led to goal scoring opportunities. It seemed like every time he got the ball he did something positive.
Deadre Yedlin, 6/10, not spectacular, but he was solid. he made a hell of a tackle late in the game that denied a counter attack and salvaged some time. he was also positive going forward. there was a weird mile high bounce that screwed him out of a goal scoring opportunity going forward. I'm guessing the pitch was not the best. that is something that needs to be figured out before the 2026 World Cup or that will be more of a talking point from the players than the poor working conditions that stadium builders are facing in Qatar. Yedlin also had a great throw in that led to the corner that produced the equalizer IIRC.
Kellyn Acosta, 5/10, he has improved for me. He was all over the pitch. he was critical in defending and moving the ball out of the back. He was slow to react on the second Mexico goal. Needs to be more involved moving forward in the attack, but I imagine that was not within his scope in this match.
Tyler Adams, did not see enough mins for him, but he appeared to be solid. He had one bad turnover IIRC.
Sergio Dest, 4/10, so for me he did a lot of dirty work on his side and was well defended. he had some positive moments, but like Pulisic he also lost possession a lot. the positive is he was aggressive and kept going at it with the ball. Negative is that he looked lethargic at times and had one or two poor turnovers where he completely missed the mark. I think in time his chemistry with the team will develop and he will create goals. He and yedlin/other fullbacks need a solid center back pairing so that they can move forward in the attack without fear.
Josh Sargent, 4/10, still need more from him. He had 3 goal scoring chances where he was just a little off balance. Overall I think he is still one of their best forwards, but he needs to score and link more with the other players.
McKenzie, 5/10, terrible mistake in the start of the match. Maybe could be scored lower due to his terrible mistake that on most days would have been ball game, but he didn't collapse. he stuck it out and Mexico were clearly gunning for him. he had several 50/50 challenges that he got right. He also blocked a shot late that may have saved a goal. he had the hand ball that was a difficult one. Was a penalty by the letter of the law, but hard to fault him with how close he was. I guess it's only fair Mexico got a penalty for that after the one was given to the USA.
Steffen 5/10. didn't see enough from him. can't really fault him for the first goal. He did have one hell of a save that robbed Lozano of a walk in goal. it wasn't a bad effort by Lozano, just a better save by Steffen. Steffen doesn't look confident distributing the ball out of the back. this could be due to the fact he is not getting reps. I think it's clear to say he needs to leave M.City so that he can play more.
Tim Ream 3/10, he looked flat footed to often. Got schooled on the 2nd Mexico goal and had a few times that he was just dead in the water in one on one situations. He gives you something with playing the ball out of the back at times, but I can't see him being a viable option on a winning USMNT squad. If USA is ever going to be an attacking side that plays on the front foot, they have to have defenders that can be trusted to come forward and win one on one battles in the back of the pitch.
MEXICAN Players:
Not gonna rate all of them. Overall they played really well and were dangerous going forward. they really were quick to capitalize on most USA mistakes. But their defense of corners were terrible. It seemed like every USA corner was a near goal. the penalty on Pulisic was careless.
LOZANO, 7/10, he was Mexico's best player for the entirety of the match. he was so dangerous with the ball at his feet. he had 3-4 quality efforts, he just hit them too close to the keeper.
Lainez, 8/10, exceptional goal, made Tim Ream and Acosta look so bad. great finish. Like Tim Weah for the USA, he changed the match when he came on. but he had much of a greater impact in his time on the pitch than any other Mexican player.