Went back and watched it a few times. Should have been caught. Maybe not a perfect throw, but it was catchable. Somers and Urban both tweeted it should have been caught.
The problem is, without touch those passes on outstretched hands simply are too tough to catch. A little less velocity on the throw, and Spach could have hauled it in, but it was clearly too hard, too fast and too far in front of him. And it wasn't like there was a need to put it in a tight space...Spach was very open.
The pass to Early right before that, however, was an amazing throw. Something that Leinart wishes he could do on his best day...
Hall throws the most consistently nice ball on the team though...but needs some seasoning before getting thrown out on the fire.