Thoughts on College QBs, RBs, LBers

Mitch

Crawled Through 5 FB Fields
Joined
Aug 10, 2005
Posts
13,405
Reaction score
2,982
Location
Wrentham, MA
1. Aaron Murray, Georgia. I like his temperament, his command and his arm, but I do not think he is NFL ready, just yet. They have a heckuva team coming back next year talent-wise, imo, he should stay put and try to win it all.

The back shoulder throw he made up the left sideline on third and long, had me thinking that he and Fitz could work very well together. The TD throw to the TE had me thinking Housler and the deep pass had me thinking Roberts and Floyd.

The interception down the middle had me thinking of the recent wave of Cardinal QBs.

2. Collin Klein, Kansas St. Of any college QB I have watched this year, he is my favorite to watch. When it comes to toughness, he is in a class all by himself. He is the ultimate scrapper and competitor. But, as a passer, he's not pretty, although he threw an excellent deep ball last night. He's a better runner than Kaepernick, but Kaepernick has the better arm.

When you see how difficult it is for QBs to hold up physically in today's NFL, you really need a guy who is both physically and mentally tough. Klein is all of that and more...but so is Tebow. The question is: can Klein throw with success in the NFL? He will need the right coach and the right system---and I think anywhere he goes his teammates will love him.

3. Marcus Mariota, Oregon. He is the most naturally gifted college QB I have seen this year. He's got good size, arm strength, speed, focus and accuracy. He can do it all. I am amazed at his poise and his innate understanding of the game---but obviously he has embraced the coaching he's received from Chip Kelly. Keep in mind, he's only a freshman.

4. A.J. McCarron, Alabama. Obviously he needs another year in college...but I like his size and his arm---that go route TD he threw was a thing of beauty.

Other Players:

5. RB Eddie Lacy, Alabama---what a load and what wheels to go with. Love the freshman T.J. Yeldon too---same with Georgia's freshman RB Todd Gurley.

6. LBs Jarvis Jones and Alex Ogletree, Georgia. I'd love to see either one of them in Cardinal red. They both would be excellent fits in Horton's defense. They get to the ball in a hurry and they can finish.

7. OLB Xzavier Dickson, Alabama. Strong side OLB played big last night---he's in the Steeler OLB mode because he's 6-3, 262, can dominate the edge and can bull rush his way to the QB.
 

Chopper0080

2021 - Prove It
Joined
May 15, 2002
Posts
28,755
Reaction score
41,753
Location
Colorado
On OLBs, it could be a really good class.

I am partial to Jarvis Jones, but I totally understand the medical risk. Demontre Moore is a special player, but I wonder if he can convert to OLB. Ezekiel Ansah is a freakish athlete, and I am pretty high on Khalil Mack out of Buffalo. Also, Travis Long out of Washington is a bit of a sleeper IMO.

Has anyone watched Cornelius Washington out of Georgia much? Ogletree and Jones get the attention but Washington was once a highly thought of prospect. Curious if anyone knows what happened?
 

PrescottLooie

Registered
Joined
Jul 13, 2004
Posts
228
Reaction score
0
Hey Mitch, there's a QB that plays for Northern Illinois, I can't think of his name but could you ckeck him out and give us an analysis please ?
 
OP
OP
Mitch

Mitch

Crawled Through 5 FB Fields
Joined
Aug 10, 2005
Posts
13,405
Reaction score
2,982
Location
Wrentham, MA
Hey Mitch, there's a QB that plays for Northern Illinois, I can't think of his name but could you ckeck him out and give us an analysis please ?

Funny you should ask that, Louie, because I watched Northern Illinois' OT victory versus Kent St., and QB Jordan Lynch, at least in that game, looked a lot to me like a slightly smaller version of Collin Klein.

He's a tough kid---has sneaky speed and running instincts and has a pretty solid arm. But he's 6-0, 216. A gritty competitor for sure. He's only a junior---he should go back to NIU for his senior year, even though HC Dave Doeren just accepted the NC State job.

Tell us what you think when you see him in the bowl game. Right now, I don't think he would receive a draftable grade from the scouts.
 

Bodha

ASFN Addict
BANNED BY MODERATORS
Joined
Sep 3, 2011
Posts
5,710
Reaction score
754
5. RB Eddie Lacy, Alabama---what a load and what wheels to go with. Love the freshman T.J. Yeldon too---same with Georgia's freshman RB Todd Gurley.

6. LBs Jarvis Jones and Alex Ogletree, Georgia. I'd love to see either one of them in Cardinal red. They both would be excellent fits in Horton's defense. They get to the ball in a hurry and they can finish.

7. OLB Xzavier Dickson, Alabama. Strong side OLB played big last night---he's in the Steeler OLB mode because he's 6-3, 262, can dominate the edge and can bull rush his way to the QB.

Yeldon will be a very high pick next year.

I really like Ogletree. Hes overshadowed by Jarvis Jones much like DWASH was at TCU behind Jerry Hughes. If we could snag him in the late 2nd, early 3rd (if still available) thatd just be a homerun.

I like JJ but he will be our lotto pick, and we need to take Luke Joeckle with that pick, no question.


Im done with Alabama players (outside of Linemen). So few produce in the NFL. Courtney Upshaw, who was 10x the player Dickson is, is a middle of the road player now in the NFL.
 

PrescottLooie

Registered
Joined
Jul 13, 2004
Posts
228
Reaction score
0
Mitch, thanks for the review. At 216 I don't think he would hold up at the next level. Oh well .......
 
Top