Of late with Keim, I have had no idea who we are drafting and refuse to fall in love with any one guy and slowly removing my admiration for Kizer and will just become a draft ***** with no emotional ties but if we draft a guard in the first round I will go off lol
If you bend the definition of BPA to = Available Athlete Who Can Best Help Us Win (AAWCBHW?) - it builds "position-need" back into the equation.
The right QB would easily rank very high on this list, but the wrong QB or even a meh QB wouldn't even be considered (because he couldn't help us win).
To set up a hypothetical example: Suppose we're weak at CB. A so-so corner might not help us win all that much, so why waste a high pick him?
Visualize our current roster and try to imagine how much or how little the addition of each prospect would best help us improve our W&L and that player should be our guy.
I could see Howard, Davis, M Williams, Hooker, Adams, Peppers, Foster, Reddick or, (under the right circumstances), Ramczyk, Bolles or Feeney or one of the elite edge rushers being that guy. It will all depend on how BA&SK view each prospect within the context of how they view our roster within the even bigger context of what we need to beat specific opponents. (I don't think they're especially forthcoming sharing that sort of information with us).
Bottom Line - I understand your concern about drafting another OG at #13, but is the problem that we drafted a guard or that we drafted the wrong guard? (The Steelers have had pretty good results drafting DeCastro (sp?) and Pouncey, no?)