Which QB would you draft?

[Jetstream Green]

At this moment, who would you select for the Cards if you had to select a QB. I'm not going to present this as poll because there are way too many options at this point. You do not have to list the round selected or your second and third choices. Simply, you are drafting and whoever you want will be there. This is interesting to do, because removed from the upcoming bowl games, it relies more on what we have seen on the field during their tenure and not combine antics of jump, hop and moxie skip. Plus, none of us are qualified to be scouts, and we can make any ludicrous selections we want from our extreeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeemely limited film exposure to base judgement

I select Tyler Wilson

 

[JeffGollin]

At this moment, who would you select for the Cards if you had to select a QB. I'm not going to present this as poll because there are way too many options at this point. You do not have to list the round selected or your second and third choices. Simply, you are drafting and whoever you want will be there. This is interesting to do, because removed from the upcoming bowl games, it relies more on what we have seen on the field during their tenure and not combine antics of jump, hop and moxie skip. Plus, none of us are qualified to be scouts, and we can make any ludicrous selections we want from our extreeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeemely limited film exposure to base judgement

I select Tyler Wilson

None of the above.

 

[Jetstream Green]

No Jeff, you must select one. The Cards are paying you a nice steak with all the trimmings to select one (which is customary payment, along with a scoop of vanilla ice cream). Do not let the thought of failure dishearten you in doing so, the Cardinals already expect you to fail at finding a QB...it has been a Cardinal tradition since Lomax, but the way Plummer compares to others, he could be counted a mild success

 

[JeffGollin]

No Jeff, you must select one. The Cards are paying you a nice steak with all the trimmings to select one (which is customary payment, along with a scoop of vanilla ice cream). Do not let the thought of failure dishearten you in doing so, the Cardinals already expect you to fail at finding a QB...it has been a Cardinal tradition since Lomax, but the way Plummer compares to others, he could be counted a mild success

No Jet, I don't have to select one. I refuse to be roped into,one of those "Levi over AP because we need a tackle" kind of decisions.

I'd feel differently if we were talking about Andrew Luck or RG3 (or possibly even Bradford). But, as of now, I don 't see anyone coming out this year who is in their league. (Maybe this will change as we enter bowl season).

To put it differently - if my choice was between Tyler Wilson and, say Tyler Wilson or Jonathan Ogden, I'd leap all over the LT. (And, as of right now, I'd choose Te'o over Wilson).

I've got a ton of skirt steak and gelato in the freezer and will, therefore, pass on your generous offer of steak and ice cream.

PS I remember where I was when we drafted EJ Junior and Lomax one-two, it was so cool.

 

[az jam]

Not a popular choice but I would go after Matt Barkley USC. I also like Tyler Wilson. I think that Barkely is the most pro ready of the college qbs. I also think the Cards will take him if he is there.

 

[Jetstream Green]

No Jet, I don't have to select one. I refuse to be roped into,one of those "Levi over AP because we need a tackle" kind of decisions.

I'd feel differently if we were talking about Andrew Luck or RG3 (or possibly even Bradford). But, as of now, I don 't see anyone coming out this year who is in their league. (Maybe this will change as we enter bowl season).

To put it differently - if my choice was between Tyler Wilson and, say Tyler Wilson or Jonathan Ogden, I'd leap all over the LT. (And, as of right now, I'd choose Te'o over Wilson).

I've got a ton of skirt steak and gelato in the freezer and will, therefore, pass on your generous offer of steak and ice cream.

PS I remember where I was when we drafted EJ Junior and Lomax one-two, it was so cool.

EJ Junior...one of my favs

 

[football karma]

Aaron Murray, Georgia ( if he comes out)

Matt Barkley, USC ( although -- I have seen 0 USC games this season, and I know he hasnt had a good stat year, and, is it the throwing shoulder that is injured?)

 

[Go Devils]

I think Landry JOnes is the best o fthe bunch and can be had early in the 2nd

 

[Cardinals.Ken]

I think Landry JOnes is the best o fthe bunch and can be had early in the 2nd

I'd agree with this. Not because I'm some sort of draftnik that follows every college player, but because of the college games I've seen the past couple of years he seems to possess the abilities/throws you look for in an NFL QB.

But I also agree with Jeff, it's too early to tab any college QB draft worthy as none of them stand out like Luck or RGIII did last year.

 

[PJ1]

Tyler Wilson then cross my fingers and hope for the best.

 

[cardinalsfan]

Aaron Murray

if he doesn't come out

Tyler Wilson

 

[Cards Czar]

Get Matt Moore in FA. I like Gino Smith but he will not be their when we pick so on to who i like. Draft Zac Dysert from Miami of Ohio or Ryan Nassib from Syracuse. Nassib has played the last 4 years in a Pro Style offense with a 63.2% rating this year.

 

[PoolBoy]

Ryan Nassib

 

[Chopper0080]

Tyler Wilson in the 1st/2nd
Ryan Nassib in the 2nd/3rd

 

[Cbus cardsfan]

Tyler Wilson in the 1st/2nd
Ryan Nassib in the 2nd/3rd

me too.

 

[Chopper0080]

me too.

I am actually more tempted to trade up from the later round to get them rather than taking them in the earlier round. I like them, but I think there are other players who we might miss on.

 

[Cards Czar]

I am actually more tempted to trade up from the later round to get them rather than taking them in the earlier round. I like them, but I think there are other players who we might miss on.

Nassib i can bet you that he is going to inpress at the bowles and combine. He should be taken in the late 2nd or early 3rd round.

IF we are picking 4/5 I would love for the cardinals to trade back 5-7 spots and get a second 2nd rounder. Perfect sport for grabbing Nassib.

 

[Jetstream Green]

I think Landry will last to the third round, and has a fair chance of being a quality starter in the pros.

 

[artp]

Nassib i can bet you that he is going to inpress at the bowles and combine. He should be taken in the late 2nd or early 3rd round.

IF we are picking 4/5 I would love for the cardinals to trade back 5-7 spots and get a second 2nd rounder. Perfect sport for grabbing Nassib.

I don't see the Cardinals trading down. I would prefer the team to get a Pro Bowl guy at #5 and trade up to get that late 1st, early 2nd rd QB. Tony Dungy likes Aaron Murray

 

[Chopper0080]

I don't see the Cardinals trading down. I would prefer the team to get a Pro Bowl guy at #5 and trade up to get that late 1st, early 2nd rd QB. Tony Dungy likes Aaron Murray

A lot of people like Aaron Murray but he does come with size concerns. Now, Drew Brees and Russell Wilson both have similar issues and overcome them, but they are the exception, not the rule.

 

[conraddobler]

A lot of people like Aaron Murray but he does come with size concerns. Now, Drew Brees and Russell Wilson both have similar issues and overcome them, but they are the exception, not the rule.

He's like an inch shorter than Joe Montana.

 

[Jetstream Green]

I like Tyler Wilson but for some reason his mechanics remind me of Jake Plummer at times, just does.

 

[conraddobler]

I like Tyler Wilson but for some reason his mechanics remind me of Jake Plummer at times, just does.

His mechanics weren't the problem, throwing it to the other team was the problem.

 

[conraddobler]

A lot of people like Aaron Murray but he does come with size concerns. Now, Drew Brees and Russell Wilson both have similar issues and overcome them, but they are the exception, not the rule.

John Skelton is tall.

 

[Jetstream Green]

His mechanics weren't the problem, throwing it to the other team was the problem.

I don't think his mechanics where a problem either, Wilson just seems to have the same type of delivery as Jake