who would you rather have..seau or Smith?

[pinnacle]

Assuming they could be had for comparable money (big if)..seau or Emmitt Smith? Both are 34 years old and on the downside.. If I were the cardinals, I would go after Junior..he would shore up the pass rush..higher need area..there is a football expert on KDUS now..and he sounds like we may actually end up with Emmitt..

 

[Dback Jon]

Originally posted by pinnacle
Assuming they could be had for comparable money (big if)..seau or Emmitt Smith? Both are 34 years old and on the downside.. If I were the cardinals, I would go after Junior..he would shore up the pass rush..higher need area..there is a football expert on KDUS now..and he sounds like we may actually end up with Emmitt..

I would go with Smith - I think he has more left to give than Seau.

 

[WizardOfAz]

I agree with your points, but Junior (if he is really out in San Diego) has Oakland written all over him in my opinion.

 

[pinnacle]

John Clayton is the guest on KDUS he said :

we would probably sign 2 guys today..he thinks Holliday and Emmitt will end up here..He did not say that these two guys were the 2 guys today..but he made some comment we would probably get 2 more guys today in a different conversation..just and update.. I missed the jerry sullivan interview a couple of hours ago..

 

[Tangodnzr]

No way does this team need Junior Seau. I've posted my reasons why on the "Junior who" thread.
Emmitt,....errrr,...uhhh,....well....ok....I guess.
I just don't see it as a high priority, but I won't complain if he is signed either.

 

[WizardOfAz]

I still smell Raiders!

 

[JeffGollin]

..He did not say that these two guys were the 2 guys today..but he made some comment we would probably get 2 more guys today
It's too fast for signing Emmitt. Holliday and possibly Garcia (who was in today) seem more likely.